Jump to content

1969 Vnukovo Airport Il-18 crash

From Alfawiki
Adapted from the English Wikipedia article 1969 Vnukovo Airport Il-18 crash, available under CC BY-SA 4.0Updated 29 November 20252 sources
Vnukovo Aviation Detachment
Company typeAviation unit
IndustryAviation
Founded1960
Headquarters
Moscow
,
Soviet Union
ParentMoscow Civil Aviation Administration


Template:DmyTemplate:Infobox aircraft occurrence

The 1969 Vnukovo Airport Il-18 accident occurred on 26 August 1969 at Vnukovo International Airport. Out of the 101 individuals aboard, 16 lost their lives.

Aircraft

The aircraft involved was an Ilyushin Il-18B bearing tail number 75708 (factory number 189001705, serial number 017-05), produced by the MMZ "Banner of Labor" on 26 December 1959.

It entered operational service with the 235th Separate Aviation Detachment on 23 January 1960. Notably, on 23 July 1961, it transported the first cosmonaut, Yuri Gagarin, to Egypt. On 12 October 1961, the plane was reassigned to the Polar Aviation Administration. Later, on 11 January 1968, it was transferred to the Vnukovo Aviation Detachment under the Moscow Civil Aviation Administration.

By the time of the crash, this aircraft had accumulated a total of 12,023 flight hours and completed 4,367 landings.[1]

Flight

Operating as flight number 1770,[2] the aircraft flew the route from Sochi via Moscow to Norilsk. The flight crew belonged to the 65th Flight Detachment and included Captain Anatoly Khomchenko, Co-pilot Viktor Brakhnov, Navigator Valery Voronkov, Flight Engineer Ivan Mukhin, and Radio Operator Olga Petrova. Cabin attendants Inna Gorelova and Natalia Terekhova managed passenger services.[2] After departing Sochi Airport and reaching cruising altitude, the aircraft maintained approximately 7,800 m (25,600 ft). There were ninety-four passengers onboard.

As evening approached near Moscow, the captain directed the radio operator to begin reading the descent and landing checklist. The radio operator recited items up to "Landing Gear," since subsequent steps were intended to be completed after gear extension during approach. At approximately 20:18, descent commenced from an altitude of 7,800 meters down to 5,100 meters towards Serpukhov. Weather and air traffic conditions were reported as normal. Standard procedure mandated a rectangular approach pattern for landing at Vnukovo International Airport. Nevertheless, the captain opted for a shortcut to reach the target altitude by the third turn instead of following this pattern. Consequently, the Il-18 descended at a vertical speed near 28 m/s—almost triple the maximum permitted rate of 10 m/s—contravening limitations outlined in the flight operations manual (FOM).

During subsequent descent phases, the aircraft stabilized at about 1,200 meters and reached a designated point when air traffic control instructed a 30° turn to maintain proper spacing with other traffic. However, no information was provided regarding other aircraft locations. Distracted by urgency to land and searching for other planes, the crew neglected an essential landing preparation step: extending the landing gear. This lapse was partly facilitated by regulations from the Civil Aviation Administration permitting deactivation of the landing gear warning siren because its sound could interfere with crew communication. Unfortunately, disabling this audible alert also cut power to gear position indicator lights sharing common circuit breakers with it—though gear status remained visible via instrument panel indicators. Consequently, no alert system was reactivated.

After completing their fourth turn and lining up for final approach, the captain failed to instruct the flight engineer to continue checklist verification. The flight engineer also omitted checking landing readiness and did not detect that landing gear remained retracted. Upon passing the outer marker beacon without reporting readiness to land as required, air traffic control nonetheless cleared the aircraft for runway landing without waiting for confirmation.

Accident

At 20:31, the Il-18 touched down on its belly at Vnukovo Airport because the landing gear was not extended. Upon contact with the runway, the propeller blades shattered and scattered in multiple directions, some penetrating the fuselage. These blade fragments breached the aircraft's skin and caused damage to hydraulic lines and electrical wiring. The escaping AMG-10 hydraulic fluid then ignited, triggering a fire that rapidly spread throughout the cabin. The plane slid along the runway for 1,180 meters before coming to a halt. Unaware of the belly landing, the pilots activated the engine fire suppression systems but neglected to consider the passengers inside. The navigator hurried to the cabin and discovered it filled with smoke. Alongside flight attendants and passengers, he opened both front and rear doors as well as two of the four emergency exits.

Believing that the landing gear had been deployed and not realizing the aircraft had landed on its belly, the navigator and flight attendants attempted to restrain passengers from evacuating prematurely, fearing injuries from a high fall. However, the panicked crowd forced their way past the attendants onto the tarmac. In the dim evening light, evacuation was disorganized and lasted over three minutes. Contrary to standard protocol prioritizing "women and children first," women accompanied by children were among the last to exit, as reported by the navigator. No official count of evacuated passengers was conducted, leaving uncertainty about how many remained onboard. Meanwhile, cockpit crew members escaped through windows.

Emergency responders arrived at the scene 15–20 minutes after the incident and quickly extinguished the blaze. Although both passenger compartments suffered extensive fire damage, none of those who survived showed signs of burns or fire exposure on their clothing. Despite this, 16 passengers lost their lives: two men, ten women, and four children. All fatalities were due to smoke inhalation; fifteen occurred in the rear section of the second cabin and one in the front part of the first cabin.

Causes

Template:Unreferenced section The primary cause of this accident was negligence by both the captain and flight engineer during landing preparation and execution—actions governed by procedures outlined in the FOM and standard operating protocols for approach. This negligence resulted in a landing with retracted landing gear. The immediate cause of many deaths was smoke inhalation from a fire sparked by ignition of AMG-10 hydraulic fluid following an electrical short circuit within aircraft wiring.

Additional contributing factors included:

  • Poor discipline and inadequate training within the 65th Flight Detachment.
  • Insufficient oversight regarding crew selection and training, which allowed two inadequately prepared crew members to participate.
  • Weak supervision and lack of effective control by the flight and navigation department of the Moscow Civil Aviation Administration over enforcement of critical safety documents and directives issued by the Civil Aviation Administration affecting flight safety within the 65th Flight Detachment.
  • Technical shortcomings in the Il-18’s landing gear position warning system, notably that disabling its siren during descent also deactivated indicator lights showing landing gear status—a significant design flaw.

References

  1. ↑ "Il-18B CCCP-75708". Scramble Soviet Database. Retrieved 6 January 2025.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 "Plane crash IL-18V at Vnukovo Airport, 1969". AVIA.PRO. 5 January 2015. Retrieved 6 January 2025.

Template:Aviation accidents and incidents during 1969 Template:Aviation accidents and incidents within the Soviet Union throughout the 1960s