A&P

The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company

File:A&P logo.svg Logo used by A&P
Company type	Public
Industry	Retail (Grocery)
Founded	1859 (1859)
Founder	George Gilman
Defunct	2015 (2015)
Headquarters	Jersey City, New Jersey , United States
Area served	United States, Canada
Key people	George Gilman (founder), George Huntington Hartford (leader)
Products	Groceries, tea, coffee, private-label food products

Overview

The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company, commonly referred to as A&P, was a prominent American grocery store chain that operated from 1859 until 2015. Between 1915 and 1975, A&P held the position as the largest grocery retailer in the United States, and until 1965, it was the biggest retailer of any kind nationwide.

Regarded as a symbol of American retail history, The Wall Street Journal once described A&P as being "as recognizable as McDonald's or Google are today," dubbing it "the Walmart of its era." During its peak in the 1940s, the company accounted for approximately 10% of all grocery expenditures in the U.S. Renowned for pioneering innovations in the grocery sector, A&P enhanced consumer nutrition by offering a wide variety of food products at significantly reduced prices. Up until 1982, the company also maintained a substantial food manufacturing division.

Historical Development

The origins of A&P trace back to 1859 when it was established as "Gilman & Company" by George Gilman. Initially, it consisted of a small network of retail outlets specializing in tea and coffee located in New York City, which later expanded into a national mail-order operation. By 1878, the company had grown to encompass 70 stores, and by the turn of the century, it operated nearly 200 locations. The introduction of the economy store model in 1912 spurred rapid expansion, with store numbers reaching 1,600 by 1915. Following World War I, A&P diversified its offerings by incorporating meat and produce sections and expanding its manufacturing capabilities.

By 1930, A&P had become the largest retailer globally, generating sales totaling $2.9 billion (equivalent to several billion dollars today) and operating approximately 15,000 stores. The company embraced the self-service supermarket format in 1936 and transitioned toward larger store formats, opening around 4,000 such locations by 1950 while gradually closing many smaller outlets. After enduring two bankruptcy proceedings, A&P ultimately ceased operations entirely in 2015.

1859–1878: Gilman period

The origin of A&P traces back to the 1850s when Gilman & Company was established by George Gilman (1826–1901), initially to sustain his family's leather tanning enterprise; by 1858, the business was located at 98 Gold Street in Manhattan. After his father's passing in 1859, which left him financially secure, Gilman expanded into the tea and coffee trade from the same premises. It is suggested that Gilman shifted toward a more reputable industry following his inheritance. In May 1861, he delegated the tanning operations to his brother Winthrop and relocated the tea business to 129 Front Street. Originally functioning as a wholesaler, Gilman & Company transitioned into retail in early 1863 under the name Great American Tea Company. The company quickly launched five retail outlets and moved its headquarters and storage facilities to 51 Vesey Street.

Gilman excelled in marketing strategies, rapidly growing the enterprise by promoting affordable prices. The dual role as wholesaler and retailer enabled the firm to maintain low costs. Additionally, Gilman developed an extensive mail order service across the country. By 1866, the company’s valuation exceeded $1 million (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year). Following the completion of the transcontinental railroad in 1869, Gilman established a related entity called the Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company to market prepackaged tea branded as Thea-Nector. Some accounts credit George Huntington Hartford as a co-founder of this venture. The original Great American name persisted for mail-order transactions. In 1871, A&P innovated by offering premiums—such as lithographs, china, and glassware—alongside coffee and tea purchases in their stores; these items have since become collectibles.

Development of the grocery store

File:George Huntington Hartford mid 1870s.jpg

George Huntington Hartford, circa mid-1870s

Hartford began his career at Gilman & Company possibly in the late 1850s as a clerk, advancing to bookkeeper and then cashier by 1866. By 1871, he held significant authority and oversaw A&P’s expansion into Chicago, opening its first store outside New York City shortly after the city's great fire. The chain expanded rapidly; by 1875, A&P operated outlets in sixteen cities. In 1878, Gilman withdrew from active management, leaving Hartford at the helm. At that time, the company managed seventy well-appointed stores alongside a mail-order division with combined annual sales reaching $1 million.

File:1888 Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Co Advert for Norfolk.jpg

Advertisement for A&P from 1888 in a Norfolk, Virginia guidebook showcasing product variety

To increase income, Congress imposed higher tariffs on tea and coffee, which reduced profit margins on these goods; consequently, around 1880 A&P began retailing sugar. The company pursued aggressive growth strategies and by 1884 had stores extending westward to Kansas City and southward to Atlanta. It also operated wagon delivery routes serving rural clients. During this period, two of Hartford's sons—George (1864–1957) and John (1872–1951)—joined the enterprise. According to company tradition, George persuaded his father to broaden their product range with A&P-branded baking powder. Over the following decade, additional private-label products such as condensed milk, spices, and butter were introduced. This expansion of offerings marked the gradual formation of one of the earliest grocery chains. By 1900, sales reached $5 million (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year) across 198 stores plus mail order and wagon route services. However, competing grocery chains were growing faster and saturating their markets more thoroughly than A&P’s geographically dispersed locations, placing it at a competitive disadvantage.

File:A and P newspaper ad 1922.png

A&P advertisement from New York City newspaper dated 1922

Following George Gilman's death intestate in 1901, legal disputes arose among his heirs. Senior Hartford asserted that an unwritten partnership agreement from 1878 granted him half ownership of A&P. Court evidence confirmed that Hartford had been receiving half of the profits since that year and that leases were held under his name. Recognizing Hartford’s essential role in maintaining profitability, Gilman heirs agreed in 1902 to incorporate A&P with assets valued at $2.1 million (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year).

Under this settlement, Gilman heirs received preferred shares worth $1.25 million bearing a 6% dividend rate; Hartford obtained $700,000 in common stock plus remaining preferred shares—securing control over voting stock. Over time, Hartford repurchased preferred shares from the Gilman heirs. A&P maintained rapid expansion by opening approximately one store every three weeks. The company constructed a nine-story headquarters and warehouse in Jersey City, New Jersey, which later included manufacturing facilities and a bakery.

By 1908, George Hartford Sr. divided managerial duties between his sons: George Jr. managed finance while John oversaw sales and operations. Together they led A&P for over four decades. The younger Hartford aggressively promoted the A&P brand and significantly broadened its product assortment. To accommodate new merchandise lines, A&P replaced traditional store premiums with Plaid Stamps—a rewards program designed to rival popular offerings like S&H Green Stamps. By 1912, A&P operated around 400 stores with an average gross margin of 22%, generating approximately a 2% net profit. Additionally, peddlers managed about 5,000 rural delivery routes using distinctive red-and-black wagons.

Evolution of economy stores

The issue of Food prices became a significant political topic during the 1912 presidential race, following a 35% rise over a decade. To address this challenge, certain chains tested a no-frills store model. After extensive discussions, the Hartford family consented to John's suggestion to trial an economy store aimed at maintaining a 12% gross margin. With an initial capitalization of just $3,000, covering inventory and setup, the pilot economy outlet was staffed solely by a manager and featured minimalistic fixtures. Within eight weeks, weekly revenue climbed to $800, yielding an annual return on investment of 30%. This success prompted A&P to rapidly scale the concept; by 1915, the chain operated 1,600 such stores.

However, A&P’s rapid expansion strained supplier relations. Cream of Wheat, the leading breakfast cereal producer, insisted that all retailers comply with its set retail prices. A&P acquired the cereal at 11 cents per box wholesale—3 cents less than standard—and applied only a 1-cent markup consistent with its economy store pricing strategy. In response, Cream of Wheat ceased shipments, prompting A&P to initiate legal action. U.S. District Court Judge Charles Hough ruled against A&P, affirming manufacturers’ rights to fix retail prices. This ruling encouraged A&P and other major chains to increase production of private-label brands.

Following the death of Hartford Sr. in 1917, company ownership transferred into a trust managed entirely by his sons George, Edward, and John as trustees.

Expansion into stores offering grocery, meat, produce, and dairy

Post-World War I, A&P experienced rapid growth; by 1925 it operated 13,961 outlets. These newer combination stores incorporated dedicated sections for meats, fresh produce, and dairy products alongside traditional groceries. Annual sales reached $400 million with profits totaling $10 million. Nevertheless, the Hartford brothers grew concerned as gross margins had climbed to 22%, reflecting rising costs and a departure from their low-price principles. Early in 1926, they consulted division leaders and launched initiatives aimed at reducing prices and tightening cost controls. That year saw sales increase by 32%, accompanied by the relocation of A&P’s headquarters to the new Graybar Building near Grand Central Terminal.

In 1927, A&P inaugurated its Canadian division, and by 1929 managed 200 stores across Ontario and Quebec. By 1930, the corporation’s total of 16,000 stores generated $2.9 billion in sales (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year), securing approximately a quarter share of grocery sales within its markets and about one-tenth nationwide. No retailer before had attained such scale; A&P was double the size of its nearest competitor Sears and quadruple that of grocer Kroger. Unlike many rivals, A&P was well-positioned to endure the Great Depression. The Hartford family had expanded organically without debt; their low-price strategy further boosted sales volumes. Between 1929 and 1932, A&P posted record after-tax profits totaling $110 million while each Hartford heir received dividends and equity exceeding $5 million annually.

A&P’s dominance sparked resistance that posed an existential threat. Thousands of small independent grocery stores were unable to compete on price. Although these smaller retailers lacked significant political influence individually, their supply chains included numerous wholesalers who wielded considerable political power. Anti-chain store sentiment gained momentum in the 1920s and intensified during the Depression era. In 1935, Texas Congressman Wright Patman introduced legislation proposing a federal tax on chain stores—a measure that could have potentially dismantled A&P.

While this bill did not advance through Congress at that time, Patman sponsored the Robinson–Patman Act in 1936 which prohibited charging different prices to comparable customers; this law was enacted. Subsequently, Patman reintroduced his original tax proposal. In response, A&P engaged lobbyists and ceased opposing unionization efforts led by the politically influential American Federation of Labor (AFL). Additionally, George and John Hartford took the rare step of publishing an open letter highlighting that such legislation would raise food costs. Public opinion shifted against the bill resulting in its defeat.

Transition to Supermarkets

File:Commercial. A & P store in Snowdon BAnQ P48S1P06559.jpg

An A&P supermarket located in Snowdon, Quebec, circa 1941

File:Photography by Victor Albert Grigas (1919-2017) PERS-SCENIC 00058 (49853017882).jpg

An A&P outlet during the 1940s

The inaugural supermarket in California was established in 1930. On the East Coast, former A&P employee Michael J. Cullen launched his initial King Kullen supermarket in Jamaica, Queens. Shortly thereafter, in 1932, Big Bear commenced operations in Elizabeth, New Jersey, rapidly matching the sales volume of 100 A&P locations. By 1933, A&P experienced a 19% decline in sales, totaling $820 million, largely due to competitive pressures. Following extensive deliberation, the Hartford brothers resolved to inaugurate 100 supermarket outlets, beginning with one in Braddock, Pennsylvania. These new supermarkets proved highly successful; by 1938, the company managed 1,100 such stores. The chain continued expanding its supermarkets while gradually phasing out smaller shops except in densely populated urban centers; by 1950, A&P operated 4,000 supermarkets alongside 500 smaller stores. Annual sales reached $3.2 billion with a net profit after tax of $32 million.

A&P's rapid growth drew scrutiny from President Franklin D. Roosevelt's anti-trust chief, Thurman Arnold, who was encouraged by Representative Wright Patman to investigate the company. In 1942, A&P and its senior executives—including the Hartford brothers—faced criminal charges for trade restraint in federal court in Dallas. However, in 1944, prosecutors withdrew the case after the presiding judge deemed it insufficiently strong.

On the same day as the Dallas case dismissal, similar charges were filed against the same defendants in Danville, Illinois, overseen by Federal Judge Walter Lindley. The government alleged that A&P's vertical integration—encompassing manufacturing, warehousing, and retailing—gave them an unfair pricing advantage. Additionally, prosecutors criticized A&P for refusing to purchase from food retailers who sold exclusively through brokers or did not provide advertising allowances. The judiciary expressed concerns that unchecked growth could lead A&P to monopolize the market. A&P countered by stating their grocery market share was approximately 15%, significantly lower than dominant firms in other sectors. Judge Lindley sided with the government and imposed fines of $10,000 on each defendant.

In 1949, the U.S. Court of Appeals upheld Judge Lindley's ruling; subsequently, A&P chose not to pursue further appeals. Later that year, the anti-trust division petitioned the court to mandate a divestiture of A&P's manufacturing operations and a breakup of its retail business into seven separate entities. The Justice Department received thousands of letters supporting A&P during this period. The Hartford brothers conducted extensive interviews with Time magazine and appeared on its November 13, 1950 cover. Time noted that aside from General Motors, no retailer globally sold more goods than A&P. John Hartford was quoted stating, "I don't know any grocer who wants to stay small ... I don't see how any businessman can limit his growth and stay healthy." The litigation continued into the administration of President Eisenhower. By late 1953, the government agreed to abandon its breakup demands provided that A&P ceased operating its produce brokerage—which also supplied competitors.

During these legal battles, A&P emphasized its significant contributions to public welfare—a legacy attributed to George Hartford Sr. and his sons. The innovations developed by the Hartfords and their rivals enabled consumers to access healthier food options at reduced prices. By 1950, average American food consumption had increased by 10% compared to 1930 levels, with lower-income families benefiting notably from improved food quality. Economist John Kenneth Galbraith supported this perspective in his 1952 work American Capitalism, citing A&P as an example of countervailing power. He referenced a 1937 study conducted by A&P regarding establishing a corn flakes manufacturing plant; merely contemplating this move compelled existing corn flake producers to reduce prices by 10%.

1951–1974: Era Following Hartford's Leadership

File:View of A&P, 1955-1970 style, Pluckemin A&P.jpg

Between 1955 and 1970, A&P’s newly opened stores were generally smaller than those of its rivals. This particular location in Pluckemin, New Jersey remained largely unchanged—aside from the adoption of A&P’s "sunrise" logo—until its closure in 2013.

John Hartford passed away in 1951 at the Chrysler Building shortly after attending a meeting of the automaker’s board. Following his death, George Hartford continued as chairman and treasurer of A&P, appointing Ralph Burger—longtime company secretary—as president. Burger had begun his career at A&P in 1910 as a clerk in Glens Falls, New York, but lacked the visionary marketing acumen that John Hartford possessed. Under Burger’s leadership, A&P still reported record revenues and maintained operating costs at 12.6% of sales, well below the industry average of 15%.

Burger also served as president of the John A. Hartford Foundation, established by John and George Hartford in 1929, ensuring his influence over A&P upon George’s death in 1957. At that time, George’s trust was dissolved and A&P stock began trading publicly on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker GAP, initially priced at $59 per share. For the first time, six independent directors joined the company’s board. By late 1961, A&P shares reached a peak of $70 (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year).

The foundation for A&P’s prolonged decline—from leading grocery retailer to eventual bankruptcy and liquidation over the next three and a half decades—was laid during the 1950s:

• Capital investment was severely limited at A&P. Although publicly traded, control remained concentrated with Burger, who led both the corporation and the Hartford Foundation. The majority of profits were paid out as dividends to meet trust beneficiaries’ income requirements. The company resisted borrowing and relied solely on funds from depreciation reserves for capital expenditures. While competitors invested heavily in larger and more modern supermarket formats, A&P lagged behind in updating its retail infrastructure. By 1970, its stores were noticeably smaller and older compared to rivals’.

• Excessive focus on private-label merchandise hindered competitiveness. In 1951, the Supreme Court ruled that manufacturers could not enforce minimum retail prices without retailer consent. This decision catalyzed a discount retail revolution, further driven by the rise of television advertising which boosted demand for national brands. Contrary to industry trends, A&P allocated significant scarce capital toward expanding its manufacturing capabilities, including investing $25 million to build what was then the world’s largest food processing facility in Horseheads (town), New York. Due to the smaller store sizes, private-label items dominated shelf space while national brand products were frequently unavailable.

• Labor expenses exceeded those of most competitors. As growth stagnated, an increasing portion of A&P employees earned higher wages due to seniority. This was less problematic for rapidly expanding competitors who had fewer long-tenured staff members. To counterbalance rising labor costs, A&P attempted to reduce store staffing levels, which led to longer checkout lines and poorly stocked shelves.

In an effort to reverse declining sales volumes, Ralph Burger reintroduced trading stamps under the “Plaid Stamps” program for A&P customers. However, initial improvements faded by late 1962 and six independent board members threatened resignation unless Burger stepped down. Upon his departure in May 1963, stock prices had fallen into the $30 range (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year). Subsequent presidents failed to halt the downward trend.

In 1971, William J. Kane—who began at A&P as a store clerk in 1934—was appointed president. Kane believed revitalization was possible by refocusing on core store operations such as cleanliness, product availability, customer service, and courtesy.

When these efforts stalled, Kane shifted strategy toward aggressive price reductions by converting stores into warehouse-style outlets branded as W.E.O.—Warehouse Economy Outlet (also known as Where Economy Originates). However, most A&P locations were too small to effectively implement this concept; losses quickly increased. By early 1973, shares had declined to $17 when Charles Bluhdorn of Gulf+Western made a tender offer at $20 per share. Kane declined this bid despite some shareholders viewing it favorably given ongoing challenges. In this period, A&P withdrew from California (1971) and Washington state (1974), limiting its western presence to Missouri. Additionally, in 1974 the company relocated its headquarters from the Graybar Building to Montvale, New Jersey.

1975–2001: Leadership of Scott and Wood

File:View of A&P, Loyalist Market, Belleville, ON..jpg

During the Scott and Wood leadership period, A&P began developing contemporary store formats. This particular location was situated in Belleville, Ontario. Notice the "sunrise" emblem introduced in 1975.

In February 1975, A&P reviewed a proposal from Booz Allen Hamilton recommending the closure of 36% of its 3,468 outlets. Kane agreed to step down and was succeeded by Jonathan Scott, then 44 years old and previously president of Albertsons. Over the next three years under Scott’s direction, A&P shuttered 1,500 stores, bringing the total count down to 1,978. Scott recruited many external executives and decentralized decision-making to regional management. Within his initial three years, the company launched 300 supermarkets ranging from 23,000 square feet (2,100 m²) to 32,000 square feet (3,000 m²), as well as its inaugural grocery-pharmacy hybrid stores branded as A&P Family Mart, measuring approximately 40,000 square feet (3,700 m²). The first Family Mart debuted in Greenville, South Carolina in 1977 as The Family Mart.

The Family Mart outlets typically ranged between 40,000–55,000 square feet (3,700–5,100 m²) in size and were among the earliest A&P locations to integrate a full-service supermarket with an in-store pharmacy. Scott also advanced Kane’s initiatives to enhance fundamental store operations such as cleanliness and customer service by launching extensive training programs. Weekly sales per store rose from $37,000 in 1974 to over $70,000 by 1976, while total revenue grew from $6.4 billion to $7.2 billion despite the reduction in store numbers. Additionally, manufacturing operations underwent reorganization. Although early indicators were favorable, by 1978 A&P’s profitability began declining due to economic challenges linked to high inflation.

File:AundPLogo.svg

The A&P sunrise logo created by Lippincott & Margulies, used from 1976 to 2005

With share prices falling to $7, the John A. Hartford Foundation concluded that waiting longer for a turnaround was untenable. Erivan Haub, head of the German Tengelmann Group, expressed interest in acquiring a stake. Born in 1930, Haub had studied retailing in the United States after World War II and expanded his family’s grocery business into a chain of approximately 2,000 stores generating annual sales around $2 billion. Although maintaining residency in Germany, his children were U.S.-born.

Haub agreed to purchase 42% of A&P's shares at $7.375 per share and gradually increased his holdings until he controlled 50.3% by February 1981. Jonathan Scott opted not to renew his five-year contract; Haub appointed James Wood as chairman. Wood, an Englishman of similar age to Haub, had previously managed the American supermarket chain Grand Union. Many executives brought on by Scott departed, replaced by Wood’s associates from Grand Union.

Tengelmann had achieved notable success with its Plus stores in Germany—smaller outlets featuring low-cost private-label goods alongside a limited selection of meats and produce. A&P introduced several Plus store divisions in the U.S., leveraging its manufacturing facilities and numerous smaller locations. However, this concept failed to attract American shoppers who preferred competitors offering low prices on national brands.

Recognizing the need for further restructuring, James Wood initiated another extensive store closure program. Announced in October 1981, this plan aimed to reduce store count below 1,000 and included shutting down the Chicago division. As part of this strategy, A&P also dismantled most of its manufacturing operations except for four coffee warehouses. To fund these changes, A&P decided to terminate its non-union pension plan which had a $200 million surplus; obligations were covered through annuities costing about $130 million due to prevailing high interest rates at that time. Non-union employees were provided defined contribution plans via 401(k) accounts.

William Walsh, recently retired from an executive role at A&P, filed a class action lawsuit that resulted in settlements increasing annuity values. Despite this adjustment, A&P still realized over $200 million and avoided taxes owing to tax loss carryforwards from earlier closures. The company also planned to close its Philadelphia division unless unions agreed to contract modifications; when unions declined concessions, closures proceeded. Unions proposed purchasing stores but lacked sufficient capital; alternatively, they accepted profit-sharing if A&P created a subsidiary operating under a different brand name. The resulting banner "Super Fresh" proved profitable. This experience led A&P to recognize that its own brand name no longer held the value it once did.

File:A&P Midland Park, NJ.JPG

A&P Fresh store in Midland Park, New Jersey: Converted into an ACME following A&P's liquidation in 2015.

Beginning in 1982, A&P expanded by acquiring various chains which continued operating under their original names rather than being rebranded as A&P. While profitability returned during the 1980s, by 2002 the company recorded record losses amid intensified competition especially from Walmart. This resulted in additional store closures including divesting its substantial Canadian division and spinning off Eight O'Clock Coffee, its last manufacturing asset.

In 1982, following Stop & Shop’s exit from New Jersey (not returning for nearly two decades), A&P acquired most of those stores as replacements for aging locations. The following year saw acquisition of Wisconsin-based Kohl's Food Stores (part of the Kohl's department store chain) from BATUS, enabling re-entry into Wisconsin and Illinois markets. In 1984, A&P purchased Pantry Pride's Richmond division. The subsequent year involved strengthening its profitable Canadian presence by closing stores in Quebec and acquiring Ontario's Dominion Stores. In the U.S., construction began on larger supermarkets approximately 40,000 square feet (4,000 m²) known as A&P Future Stores.

In 1986, acquisitions included Waldbaum's, serving southern New York and southern New England regions, along with upscale New York City-based chain The Food Emporium. In 1989 A&P bought Michigan’s Farmer Jack chain; it also attempted European expansion through an unsuccessful bid for the UK’s third-largest grocery chain Gateway Corporation (owned by Somerfield), though it did operate stores in the Netherlands until the early 2000s. By decade’s end, A&P reported a profit margin of 1.3%—above the industry average of 1.04%—on revenues totaling $11 billion.

During the early 1990s economic downturn and growing competition from Walmart caused renewed difficulties for A&P; sales fell to $1.1 billion in 1992 with a net loss of $189 million. The company responded by enhancing private label offerings and revamping remaining U.S. operations. Smaller stores under 40,000 square feet (4,000 m²) were either expanded or replaced with larger units ranging from 50,000 square feet (5,000 m²) up to 80,000 square feet (7,000 m²), featuring pharmacies, expanded bakeries, and broader general merchandise selections.

A&P withdrew largely from Southern states including Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Carolinas, Tennessee and Virginia; most locations were sold to Kroger. Consequently, operations consolidated into four regions: Northeast U.S., Midwest (Michigan and Wisconsin), New Orleans area, and Ontario Canada. To bolster presence in New Orleans region, six supermarkets were acquired from John G. Schwegmann; overall store count declined to approximately 600.

In leadership changes during this period: Christian W.E. Haub—youngest son of Erivan Haub—became co-CEO in 1994 and assumed CEO duties upon James Wood’s retirement in 1997; Wood also stepped down as chairman in 2001 with Haub taking over that role.

2001–2015: The concluding phase as a supermarket operator

File:A&P logo.svg

In 2005, A&P updated its sunrise emblem by eliminating the colored stripes and reducing the oval's dimensions. A variant of this design continued to be used on Best Cellars liquor outlets until their shutdown.

File:A&P logo 2013.png

Following its transition to a private entity in 2012, A&P introduced a round logo. The two preceding logos remained in use until the supermarkets ceased operations.

Across the United States, Walmart established a commanding presence within the grocery sector, compelling many competitors to scale back; however, Walmart had yet to become a significant grocery rival in A&P’s traditional Northeast stronghold. After recording its largest financial loss in 2003, A&P shuttered Kohl's Food Stores along with its remaining outlets in Vermont and New Hampshire, thereby reducing its total store count to just over 500. That same year, A&P divested its final manufacturing segment, the Eight O'Clock Coffee division, selling it to Gryphon Investors for $107 million. (Gryphon subsequently sold Eight O'Clock Coffee to Tata Global Beverages in 2006 for $220 million).

In 2005, A&P disposed of its Canadian operations, which included 237 stores under banners such as A&P, Dominion, Ultra Food and Drug, and Food Basics, by selling them to Montreal-based Metro Inc. for Can$1.7 billion in cash plus Metro shares. By 2009, the A&P brand had been phased out from these locations. In 2007, A&P exited the New Orleans market, consolidating its presence exclusively within the Northeast. That same year, it acquired long-standing Northeastern competitor Pathmark for $1.4 billion (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year). This acquisition restored A&P’s status as the largest supermarket chain in the New York City metropolitan area. Concurrently, Tengelmann reduced its ownership stake to 38.5%, while private equity firm Yucaipa, a principal shareholder of Pathmark, acquired 27.5% of A&P’s shares. In 2012, following bankruptcy proceedings, A&P transitioned back into private ownership, with Tengelmann divesting its holdings; modest profitability was briefly regained during 2013 and 2014.

This restructuring enabled A&P to reclaim its position as the largest grocery retailer within New York City and the second-largest in Philadelphia. Nevertheless, the Federal Trade Commission ruled that this acquisition created a monopoly situation in certain areas of Long Island and Staten Island. To comply with FTC mandates, A&P was compelled to divest select Waldbaum's and Pathmark stores.

Celebrating its 150th anniversary in 2009, A&P was ranked No. 21 among North American grocery retailers according to Supermarket News, based on estimated sales of US$9.6 billion for fiscal year 2008 (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year). Tengelmann maintained approximately a 38.5% stake in A&P, with Yucaipa holding around 27.5%; remaining shares were owned by individual investors and various groups. Christian Haub served as chairman during this period. Eric Claus departed from his roles as president and CEO, with Sam Martin succeeding him.

Initial Chapter 11 Bankruptcy (2010)

Fluctuation in Store Count Over Time

Year	Number of Stores
1863	5
1878	70
1900	400
1915	1,600
1930	15,709
1950	4,500
1970	4,000
1980	2,000
1990	1,000
2000	600
2010	395
2015	296

All locations ceased operations by November 25, 2015.

The Great Recession led to widespread challenges for supermarket chains as shoppers increasingly favored discount retailers. A&P was particularly vulnerable due to its substantial debt incurred from acquiring Pathmark. In June 2010, the company halted payments amounting to $150 million (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year) for rent on shuttered Farmer Jack outlets. By August of the same year, A&P declared plans to shutter an additional 25 stores across Connecticut, Maryland, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania, affecting 13 Pathmark locations, six A&P outlets, two Waldbaum's stores, and four Super Fresh branches. The following month, A&P revealed the sale of seven Connecticut stores to Big Y.

On December 10, 2010, speculation about bankruptcy intensified as A&P’s stock price plummeted from over $3 per share to under $1 before trading was suspended. Two days later, the company officially filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. Court filings submitted in White Plains, New York disclosed that A&P held assets exceeding $2.5 billion while carrying debts totaling $3.2 billion.

Despite the bankruptcy filing, A&P continued operations under the new stock ticker GAPTQ, while formulating a restructuring strategy. By November 2011, the firm announced securing $490 million (~$Template:Format price in Template:Inflation/year) in combined debt and equity financing from investors including Yucaipa, Mount Kellett Capital Management, and funds managed by Goldman Sachs Asset Management. This financial backing facilitated A&P’s successful emergence from Chapter 11 as a private company in early 2012. Concurrently, Christian Haub departed from the company and Tengelmann wrote off its remaining equity stake.

Second Chapter 11 Bankruptcy and Closure of Supermarkets

A&P managed a brief return to modest profitability by reducing expenses in its remaining outlets, despite a continued decline in customer purchases. In 2013, the company was once again placed on the market, but no appropriate buyer emerged. Sam Martin stepped down in January 2014, and by March, Paul Hertz was appointed CEO and President as the company reached a break-even point. On January 15, 2015, the industry publication Supermarket News indicated that A&P remained available for sale.

Speculation circulated about potential buyers, including Cerberus Capital Management, which still controlled Albertsons assets, yet no viable offers materialized. In May, it became apparent that A&P was facing deeper financial challenges after reporting substantial losses for the previous fiscal year in April, largely due to losing market share to more efficiently run competitors. As customer traffic dwindled further, the company contemplated filing for bankruptcy protection a second time within five years.

Reports suggested A&P might divest all stores located more than 40 miles from its headquarters, potentially shrinking operations to roughly 100 locations. Other rumors hinted at selling off the entire chain. Discussions also arose about the possibility of Chapter 7 liquidation involving piecemeal asset sales or alternatively a Chapter 11 restructuring with asset divestitures. Despite these considerations, the company continued to be marketed as a whole entity but failed to attract any purchase bids for individual stores. Additional options included selling other corporate assets.

On July 19, 2015, A&P officially filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection and immediately shuttered 25 poorly performing stores. The following day, it was announced that Albertsons—owner of Philadelphia-based Acme Markets—had acquired 76 locations, including Super Fresh and Pathmark outlets as well as one Food Emporium store. Stop & Shop purchased 25 stores primarily consisting of Pathmarks situated in New York City and Nassau and Suffolk counties. The Key Food cooperative took ownership of 23 stores, mainly within New York City, encompassing all remaining Food Basics and Food Emporium locations.

Morton Williams bought two Food Emporium sites in Manhattan, while Wakefern Food Corporation—the cooperative operating ShopRite and PriceRite—acquired 12 stores, including nine Pathmark units. Several local grocers also obtained properties through direct sales or auction processes. By November 25 (Thanksgiving Eve), all supermarkets under A&P had ceased operations. The last segment of A&P, Best Cellars at A&P, underwent an auction during summer 2016; eleven stores were sold (none continuing operations), while six leases were rejected.

Store design

File:FQJan07APGuitarist.jpg

The A&P in New Orleans' French Quarter (1930–2007)

According to the A&P Historical Society, the earliest stores were described as "splendid emporiums," often adorned with vermilion paint and featuring a prominent gas-lit T-shaped sign. Inside, customers would find crystal chandeliers, tin ceilings, and walls decorated with gilt-edged Chinese panels. Service was provided by a clerk stationed behind an extended counter, as self-service did not become widespread until the 1930s. The cashier's area was uniquely designed in the style of a pagoda. When promotional premiums were introduced, large shelving units were installed on the wall opposite the counter to showcase these giveaways.

In the early 1900s, with John Hartford overseeing marketing, A&P began distributing S&H Green Stamps to optimize space for an expanded grocery selection within stores. The economy store concept Hartford introduced in 1912 removed decorative elements entirely. These compact stores, generally around 600 square feet (56 m²), contained only essential shelving and a small ice box. To maintain flexibility, A&P committed solely to short-term leases, enabling swift closure of underperforming locations.

By the early 1920s, A&P launched combination stores offering groceries, meat, and produce, which evolved into supermarkets during the 1930s. Each supermarket typically replaced six earlier combination outlets. The company’s practice of signing short leases caused store designs to vary well into the 1950s. Throughout the mid-20th century, A&P stores were notably smaller than those of competing chains; even as late as 1971, half of their locations measured less than 8,000 square feet (740 m²).

Under Scott’s leadership, store design became standardized and centrally managed from corporate headquarters. Four prototype store sizes were developed: 23,000 square feet (2,100 m²), 28,000 square feet (2,600 m²), 30,000 square feet (2,800 m²), and 32,000 square feet (3,000 m²). The Family Mart format combined grocery and drugstore offerings within approximately 40,000 square feet (3,700 m²) of retail space.Template:Fix/category

Futurestore

During Wood’s tenure, A&P introduced the "Futurestore" concept characterized by black-and-white interior décor. The Family Mart chain served as a testing ground for this design approach.

Futurestore was one of two major concepts A&P launched during the 1980s—the other being Sav-A-Center, which is also defunct. The first Futurestore opened in 1984 in the New Orleans region, converting two acquired Kroger locations. The inaugural transformation of an existing A&P into a Futurestore occurred in New Jersey in 1985.

This concept expanded to A&P stores throughout the southeastern United States and their traditional Mid-Atlantic markets (operating under the Super Fresh banner in Philadelphia). However, by the late 1980s, all Futurestores had either been rebranded or shuttered.

Distinctive features and color schemes identified both Futurestore and its counterpart Sav-A-Center; Futurestores utilized black-and-white interiors compared to the green-and-white theme of Sav-A-Centers. Many Futurestores also incorporated glass atrium entrances. Signage included pictograms, reminiscent of European supermarket designs.

Futurestores generally offered upscale gourmet departments and advanced electronic services targeting affluent neighborhoods. Their amenities emphasized specialty and gourmet products more than typical A&P or Sav-A-Center outlets. Additionally, these stores featured newer fixtures and equipment than other A&P locations at that time.

Since Futurestore never achieved widespread adoption, A&P gradually retired the brand—closing some locations and converting others back to standard A&P or Sav-A-Center formats. Many shoppers perceived Futurestore as lacking the sophistication of other high-end grocers that not only stocked gourmet items but also prepared and delivered meals. Unlike with Sav-A-Centers, however, A&P did not immediately alter Futurestore interiors when rebranding them as A&P Food Markets during the 1990s.

Pharmacies

During the mid-1990s, A&P expanded its operations by incorporating pharmacies, focusing on developing stores ranging from approximately 41,800 to 60,400 square feet in size.

International endeavors

In the early 1980s, A&P explored the possibility of establishing a store in Saudi Arabia. According to reports from A&P Preservation in March 2018, the company did open a location in Riyadh. Petra Czech, a representative from Tengelmann, indicated that the brand name was licensed to local Saudi operators. It is believed that this store was eventually rebranded under the Saudi equivalent of Safeway.

Store brands

File:Farmer682.jpg

A&P acquired the Farmer Jack chain with 79 stores in 1989 and maintained that brand until the division's closure in 2007.

File:Pathmark Supermarket.jpg

After acquiring the Pathmark chain with 141 stores in 2007, A&P continued operating most locations under that name until 2015.

For the majority of its existence, A&P operated its outlets under its own name. This practice shifted during the leadership of Scott and Wood when A&P either developed new chains or retained original names of acquired businesses. Below is an overview of A&P’s operations under alternative retail names:

• Family Mart: Launched in 1977, this chain featured large grocery and pharmacy stores inspired by similar concepts developed by Skaggs-Albertson's, where A&P Chairman Scott had previous experience. Initially thriving, Family Mart expanded to 28 locations across Alabama, Florida, Georgia, and the Carolinas within a decade. The 18 Family Mart stores in Florida were divested in 1987, with the remaining outlets closing by 1999.
• Plus: Tengelmann operated numerous small-scale discount supermarkets in Germany under the Plus brand. Following its acquisition of a majority stake in A&P, Tengelmann converted some smaller A&P stores to adopt the Plus format.
• Super Fresh: During the 1981–82 restructuring that led to the shutdown of A&P’s Philadelphia division (covering Delaware, Maryland, and southern New Jersey), labor unions proposed purchasing many of these stores. A&P consented, resulting in a new labor contract featuring profit-sharing arrangements and a requirement that these stores operate under the new Super Fresh banner. These outlets proved profitable and by 1986 expanded into Washington D.C. and Virginia markets; this expansion included former Pantry Pride stores acquired in Richmond in 1981. Super Fresh locations remained operational until A&P’s liquidation; subsequently, the Super Fresh brand was acquired by Key Food and relaunched primarily around Newark, New Jersey rather than its original Philadelphia base.
• Food Basics (US & CA): In response to record losses during the early 2000s recession affecting middle-class suburban areas such as Paterson, North Bergen, and Glassboro in New Jersey, A&P transformed these underperforming locations into no-frills supermarkets branded as Food Basics. These outlets offered essential grocery items at reduced prices and carried both America's Choice and Food Basics private labels alongside national brands found in other A&P stores. By 2010, Food Basics operated over a dozen stores in economically challenged New Jersey cities as well as several former Super Fresh locations converted to Food Basics within central Philadelphia. These stores eliminated most service departments except for deli counters; all other meat, seafood, and bakery products were sourced externally. This strategy reduced labor costs by more than half by replacing higher-paid butchers and bakers with additional stocking staff and cashiers.
• Kohl's Food Stores: After closing its large Chicago division in 1982, A&P acquired Wisconsin-based Kohl's Food Stores in 1983. Established in 1946 and expanding into department stores during the 1960s, Kohl's was owned by British American Tobacco from 1972 until it sold its grocery operations to A&P around a decade later. Kohl's Food Stores were shuttered by A&P in 2003.
• Dominion (Canada): In 1985, A&P purchased Dominion—a Canadian chain comprising 92 supermarkets, two warehouses, and an administrative complex. Dominion was later sold off in 2005.
• Ultra Food & Drug / Miracle Mart / The Barn Markets (Canada): These Canadian supermarket chains were acquired by A&P and operated until their phase-out during the early 2000s; their store formats mirrored those of other A&P holdings.
• The Food Emporium: Acquired also in 1985, this New York City-based chain consisted of 26 stores at purchase time. Originally founded as Daitch Crystal Dairies in 1919 (later renamed Shopwell Supermarkets), it peaked at over a hundred locations by 1962 before downsizing and rebranding as The Food Emporium to target affluent neighborhoods during the late 1970s and early 1980s. The Food Emporium continued operating through A&P’s liquidation process; Key Food purchased this brand along with four stores and retains its use today.
• Waldbaum's: Purchased in 1986, Waldbaum's was founded in New York City in 1904 with its first supermarket opening in 1951. The chain expanded rapidly into Nassau and Suffolk counties as well as Connecticut and Massachusetts. By the early 2000s, A&P operated approximately eighty Waldbaum's locations primarily outside Manhattan but within southern New York State. Many remained open when liquidation commenced.
• Farmer Jack: This Detroit-based supermarket chain with seventy-nine stores was acquired by A&P in 1989. Established in 1924 and renamed from Borman's back to Farmer Jack during the late 1960s, it suffered financial strain due to a prolonged strike before being sold to A&P for $76 million. Subsequently, all Detroit-area A&Ps were rebranded as Farmer Jack within five years; some Virginia and South Carolina locations were also converted. By 2007 all Farmer Jack outlets had been closed or sold.
• Sav-A-Center: Originating as a group of twenty supermarkets around New Orleans, Louisiana, Sav-A-Center operated throughout Louisiana with two additional stores located in Mississippi. The division included three traditional A&P stores such as a longstanding corner grocery established since 1931 in New Orleans’ French Quarter. By August 2005 Sav-A-Center primarily served Baton Rouge and New Orleans metro areas along with Mississippi’s Gulf Coast. Many locations suffered damage from Hurricane Katrina; twenty-one reopened within months while two others resumed after remodeling due to flood damage; five were permanently shuttered due to severe destruction. In April 2007 Sav-A-Center exited Baton Rouge; by May that year A&P announced plans to leave New Orleans entirely and sought buyers for its remaining twenty stores citing a strategic focus on Northeast markets where most stores were located. Later that year Rouses acquired sixteen Sav-A-Center locations—including Mississippi outlets and the French Quarter store—sold one to competitor Breaux Mart while closing others.
• Pathmark: Once a significant competitor within the New York metropolitan area prior to acquisition by A&P in 2007, Pathmark originated as Supermarkets General—a subgroup formed within ShopRite’s cooperative structure—in 1956. After splitting from ShopRite in 1968, it rebranded its eighty-one stores as Pathmark. By 1977 Pathmark began constructing larger supermarkets featuring pharmacies. To avoid a hostile takeover attempt in 1987, management executed a $2.7 billion leveraged buyout resulting in heavy debt obligations. The company filed for bankruptcy protection in 2000; following reorganization Yucaipa Holdings acquired a forty percent stake for $150 million. At acquisition by A&P in 2007 Pathmark operated one hundred forty-one stores with market capitalization near $634 million. Many Pathmark outlets remained open during A&P’s liquidation phase; ownership of the brand transferred to Foodtown, with a revived Pathmark store reopening under Allegiance Retail Services ownership in Brooklyn’s East Flatbush neighborhood as of April 2019.

Private brands

File:A & P (Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co.), 246 Third Avenue, Manhattan (NYPL b13668355-1219150).jpg

A&P, 246 Third Avenue, Manhattan, 1936. Notice the prominent advertisements for A&P's own private label products.

At its inception, A&P operated in a market where branded food items were nonexistent, and retailers typically sold bulk food commodities. In 1870, the company became one of the pioneers in offering a branded, pre-packaged food item by launching the "Thea-Necter" tea brand. The "A&P" name first appeared on baking powder packaging in 1885. Additionally, during the 1880s, the company introduced "Eight-O'Clock" as the brand name for its coffee. When A&P relocated its headquarters to Jersey City, New Jersey in 1907, it incorporated bakery and coffee roasting facilities into its operations.

A&P's growth into one of the nation's leading food producers was significantly influenced by a 1915 court ruling in the Cream of Wheat case, which affirmed manufacturers' rights to set retail prices. To maintain competitive pricing, A&P focused heavily on developing private label merchandise. By 1962, the company managed 67 manufacturing plants before merging many into the expansive Horseheads facility, spanning 1.5 million square feet and recognized as the largest single-roof food production plant globally. In his 1952 work, American Capitalism, economist John Kenneth Galbraith highlighted A&P's manufacturing model as a textbook example of countervailing power, presenting it as an effective alternative to government-imposed price controls.

As late as 1977, private label products constituted a quarter of A&P’s total sales, with over 40% of these items produced by A&P itself. That year alone, A&P's manufacturing division generated $750 million in revenue from its 23 plants—an output that would have ranked it approximately 350th on the Fortune 500 list.

Prior to establishing a unified Manufacturing Group in 1975, A&P’s production was divided among four distinct divisions:

• Bakery (brands such as Grandmother's, Marvel, and Jane Parker): Jersey City housed A&P’s sole bakery until 1923. The bakery division expanded rapidly thereafter to become the largest bakery operation in America with 37 plants. By 1977, this number had been reduced to seven; however, the division was shuttered during restructuring efforts in 1981–82. Although a Canadian bakery continued producing Jane Parker cakes for a time, it declared bankruptcy in 2014. The rights were subsequently acquired by Alex and Chris Ronacher in 2016.
• Coffee (including Eight O'Clock Coffee, Bokar, Red Circle): In 1919, A&P consolidated its coffee operations under the "American Coffee Company," establishing roasting and grinding facilities. By 1977, the company operated three coffee roasting plants and an additional facility dedicated to canned coffee production. This coffee division survived the restructuring of 1981–82 and remained under A&P ownership until its sale in 2003.
• Dairy: Established in 1922 with the acquisition of the White House Milk Company based in West Bend, Wisconsin, this division produced evaporated milk at a time when fresh milk sales were limited due to refrigeration challenges. By 1977, it managed three dairy plants along with a cheese factory and a dry milk facility.
• Grocery (featuring Quaker Maid, Ann Page, Our Own Tea): Starting with a vegetable cannery opened in 1907, A&P expanded post-World War I by acquiring Alaskan canneries amid declining salmon prices. The company then broadened its manufacturing portfolio to include canned goods, frozen foods, nuts, tea bags, pasta, peanut butter, detergents, insecticides, gelatin products, paper items, and candy. Additionally, A&P operated a printing plant responsible for producing labels and packaging materials for all divisions as well as promotional content for retail outlets. By 1977, this segment included the Horseheads plant plus six smaller facilities.

In the mid-1990s, A&P launched a streamlined store brand named America's Choice that persisted until the chain’s closure in 2015. In Canadian markets, this brand was marketed as "Master Choice," which also served as branding for gourmet selections within U.S. stores.

During 2008 and 2009, A&P expanded its private label offerings by introducing environmentally conscious Green Way products, premium Food Emporium Trading Company items, and budget-friendly Food Basics alternatives.

Woman's Day

The publication now known as Woman's Day originated in 1931, created by A&P as a complimentary leaflet featuring menus. By 1937, it evolved into a magazine sold exclusively at A&P outlets for five cents. Its circulation expanded to 3 million by 1944 and reached 4 million in 1958, the year it was acquired by Fawcett Publications.

In arts, entertainment, and media

• The opening sequence of the film Breaking Away features Dennis Quaid singing about wanting to be buried in an A&P parking lot.
• In season 4, episode 3 of Boardwalk Empire, characters Gillian Darmody (portrayed by Gretchen Mol) and Roy Phillips dine with A&P executives.
• In Tim Burton's film Big Eyes, Margaret Keane visits an A&P store and discovers her artwork being sold there.
• The supermarket is referenced in the song "Garbage Dump" by Charles Manson.
• Within the Starz series Gaslit, a character tells Martha Mitchell (played by Julia Roberts) that they are going to the A&P.
• The 1981 track "Christmas Wrapping" by The Waitresses includes the line "A&P has provided me with the world's smallest turkey."
• Between 1924 and 1936, A&P sponsored the musical radio program The A&P Gypsies.
• A&P was also a longtime sponsor of Kate Smith's radio show; Smith became an A&P spokesperson and attended numerous store openings nationwide.
• In the 1951 Popeye cartoon "Vacation With Play," two squirrels originally recite a transcribed radio commercial for A&P's Jane Parker Donuts, audible only when the cartoon is slowed down. Jane Parker was the brand name under which A&P marketed their baked goods such as doughnuts and cookies.
• The setting for John Updike's 1961 short story "A&P" is an A&P store.
• In 2013, A&P collaborated with the Lifetime Network to produce the food-reality show Supermarket Superstar.
• The 1988 film Scrooged includes a line where Bill Murray's character says, "Look up A&P. If it's not under 'A', then look under 'P'", referring to turkeys intended for a shelter.
• In the 1989 movie Born on the Fourth of July, Ron Kovic works at an A&P early in the story; his father manages the store, and Kovic asks his high school crush to prom inside that supermarket.
• The 2001 book Good to Great analyzed A&P alongside its competitor Kroger.
• In 2007, brothers Mark and Matt D'Avella filmed their rap music video "Produce Paradise" at an A&P location. The company later settled a lawsuit related to this video out of court.
• The 2009 episode "The Arrangements" of Mad Men depicts a police officer informing Betty Draper that her father died while waiting in line at an A&P.
• In season 2, episode "Wannabe" of Without a Trace, Emily Levine remarks about her friend Brandee's mother: "Well at least her mom doesn't work at the checkout counter at the A&P."
• The 2022 film adaptation of Don DeLillo's novel White Noise prominently features A&P as the preferred grocery store, notably during the final credits.
• An episode from season five of Psych, titled "Not Even Close... Encounters", reveals that Lassiter maintains a "crap list," which includes "Check out Girl @ the A&P," although this may be outdated since no A&Ps remained in California when the episode aired.

See also

• List of supermarket chains in the United States
• Retail apocalypse
• List of retailers affected by the retail apocalypse

External links

• Official website at the Wayback Machine (archived 2012-09-26)
• Time magazine cover featuring John and George Hartford
• Photograph from the 1970s showing an A&P location in Towson, MD
• A&P section on Groceteria, containing a brief history of Futurestore along with a photo collection of former A&P stores and several Futurestores Archived May 9, 2008, at the Wayback Machine