Jump to content

Bank of Credit and Commerce International

From Alfawiki
Bank of Credit and Commerce International
Company typePrivate
IndustryBanking, Financial services
Founded1972
FounderAgha Hasan Abedi
Defunct1991
Headquarters
Karachi and London
,
Pakistan and United Kingdom
Area served
Worldwide (78 countries)
Key people
Agha Hasan Abedi (founder), Swaleh Naqvi (CEO), Zafar Iqbal Chaudhry (CEO)
ProductsBanking services

The Bank of Credit and Commerce International was a global bank established in 1972 by Pakistani financier Agha Hasan Abedi. Although incorporated in Luxembourg, its main offices were situated in Karachi and London. Within ten years, BCCI expanded to operate more than 400 branches across 78 nations, amassing assets over US$20 billion, which positioned it as the seventh largest private banking institution worldwide.

During the 1980s, BCCI came under intense regulatory examination due to inadequate oversight. Investigations revealed widespread money laundering and various financial crimes, including covert ownership of a significant American bank. In 1991, authorities from seven countries conducted coordinated raids on BCCI branches under Operation C-Chase, culminating in the bank’s compulsory shutdown.

Authorities from the U.S. and UK determined that BCCI was "intentionally structured to circumvent centralized Financial regulation, operating extensively within jurisdictions known for bank secrecy." Its intricate organizational framework facilitated large-scale fraud while avoiding detection.

The appointed liquidators, Deloitte & Touche, initiated legal action against the bank’s auditors, Price Waterhouse and Ernst & Young, resulting in a $175 million settlement in 1998. By 2013, Deloitte reported recovering approximately 75% of creditors’ losses.

BCCI continues to serve as a significant example within international finance. In March 2023, U.S. Acting Comptroller of the Currency Michael J. Hsu drew comparisons between BCCI’s collapse and the downfall of crypto company FTX, underscoring its influence on reforms in banking oversight.

History

Established in 1972 by Agha Hasan Abedi, BCCI was founded following Abedi’s earlier success in creating the United Bank Limited in Pakistan in 1959 with support from the Saigols. Prior to United Bank Limited’s nationalization in Pakistan during 1974, Abedi sought to build a new international banking entity. The initial capital structure of BCCI consisted of 25% investment from Bank of America and 75% from Sheikh Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan, ruler of Abu Dhabi in the United Arab Emirates.

Throughout the 1970s, BCCI pursued rapid expansion focused on increasing long-term assets rather than immediate profits, targeting wealthy clients and substantial deposits. The organization was restructured into BCCI Holdings, under which the banking operations were divided between BCCI SA (based in Luxembourg) and BCCI Overseas (located in the Cayman Islands). The bank acquired institutions such as Banque de Commerce et Placements (BCP) of Geneva in 1976 and established entities including the Kuwait International Finance Company (KIFCO), Credit & Finance Corporation Ltd, along with Cayman Islands companies consolidated as ICIC (International Credit and Investment Company Overseas). By 1976, BCCI had grown from 19 branches across five countries (in 1973) to 108 branches, with assets increasing from $200 million to $1.6 billion. This swift growth generated capital challenges; The Guardian reported that BCCI utilized deposits to cover operational costs rather than for investment purposes. Author Joseph J. Trento suggested that Saudi intelligence influenced this transformation to support clandestine U.S. intelligence activities following the Watergate affair.

In 1973, BCCI sought an offshore banking license in Singapore, but the application was denied by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) due to its nascent status and limited capitalization. A subsequent application in 1980 was again refused because of concerns over its international reputation.

BCCI expanded into African markets beginning in 1979 and entered Asia during the early 1980s. It was among the first foreign banks authorized to operate within China’s Shenzhen Special Economic Zone, a milestone achieved before competitors such as Citicorp and JP Morgan. Several prominent Chinese state-owned banks became depositors at its Shenzhen branch.

The bank employed a highly compartmentalized management system; 248 managers reported directly to founders Abedi and CEO Swaleh Naqvi. No single nation exercised regulatory authority over BCCI, enabling its broad expansion. Its two holding companies were headquartered in Luxembourg and the Cayman Islands—both jurisdictions known for lax banking regulations—and it lacked supervision by any central bank country. The U.S. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency consistently advised against permitting BCCI’s acquisition of American banks due to regulatory concerns.

By 1980, BCCI declared assets exceeding $4 billion with more than 150 branches across 46 countries. That year, Bank of America diminished its stake; ownership shifted predominantly to International Credit and Investment Corp ('ICIC'), controlling about 70%. By 1989, ICIC’s share declined to roughly 11%, with Abu Dhabi-based groups holding nearly 40%, although many shares were nominally held by BCCI nominees.

In 1982, fifteen Middle Eastern investors who were clients of BCCI acquired Financial General Bankshares (FGB), a Washington, D.C.-based bank holding company later renamed First American Bankshares. Despite public assurances that BCCI would not manage this entity, evidence indicated its involvement from inception. Due to BCCI's unfavorable reputation and regulatory resistance in the U.S., these investors acted as nominees for its interests. To mitigate regulatory concerns, Clark Clifford—advisor to five U.S. presidents—was appointed chairman; his law firm managed much of BCCI's legal affairs within America. This close association fueled speculation that BCCI effectively controlled First American.

BCCI employed an unusual auditing arrangement: Price Waterhouse audited BCCI Overseas; Ernst & Young oversaw audits for BCCI Holdings (London and Luxembourg); other subsidiaries like KIFCO or ICIC lacked independent audits. In October 1985, regulators mandated audit consolidation due to reported losses; Price Waterhouse became sole auditor by 1987.

A Price Waterhouse audit conducted in 1990 uncovered unreported losses amounting to several hundred million dollars. Sheikh Zayed covered these deficits as majority shareholder with a controlling interest of 78%, relocating much documentation to Abu Dhabi. The audit revealed significant irregularities including $1.48 billion lent to shareholders secured by BCCI stock.

It also confirmed suspicions that BCCI covertly owned First American despite contractual prohibitions; investors had borrowed heavily from BCCI using First American shares as collateral. When interest payments defaulted, BCCI gained control over more than 60% of First American’s stock.

Despite these problems, Price Waterhouse approved the 1989 annual report largely due to Sheikh Zayed’s financial support. Following Abedi’s departure, Swaleh Naqvi assumed CEO responsibilities; amid ensuing controversies, leadership transitioned later in the decade to Zafar Iqbal Chaudhry.

Lending practices

BCCI attributed its expansion to deposits originating from oil-rich nations holding bank shares, as well as sovereign states in the developing world. Despite this, regulatory bodies remained wary; for instance, the Bank of England imposed a cap on BCCI’s UK branch operations, limiting them to 45 locations.

The primary apprehension involved BCCI’s lending strategies, given that many clients were practicing Muslims who opposed charging interest (riba), which is fundamental to conventional banking. In numerous developing countries, loans were often granted based on personal connections rather than financial reliability. A prominent example includes the Gokal family, influential shipping entrepreneurs closely linked to founder Abedi, who secured loans amounting to US$1.2 billion—equivalent to three times BCCI’s total capital. Likewise, UK real estate magnate Nazmu Virani obtained unsecured loans totaling £500 million. Typically, banking regulations restrict individual loans to a maximum of 10% of a bank’s capital.

Money laundering

In addition to breaches in lending protocols, BCCI was involved in laundering money for notable figures such as Saddam Hussein, Manuel Noriega, Hussain Muhammad Ershad, and Samuel Doe, along with criminal organizations like the Medellín Cartel and Abu Nidal. This earned the institution the moniker "Bank of Crooks and Criminals International" due to its clientele engaged in arms trafficking, drug smuggling, and other illegal financial activities. Pakistani bankers Syed A. Hussain and Amjad Awan played key roles in managing Noriega’s accounts within BCCI.

Former U.S. Customs Commissioner William von Raab disclosed that the CIA maintained several accounts at BCCI. A 1991 Time magazine report revealed that the National Security Council utilized BCCI accounts for covert operations, including transactions related to Iran–Contra involving funds and weapons transfers. Following investigations by Congress, the CIA admitted in 1991 that it was aware of BCCI’s involvement in laundering drug money.

Investigations begin

The unraveling of BCCI began in 1986 when a U.S. Customs undercover operation led by Special Agent Robert Mazur penetrated the bank’s private client division located in Tampa, Florida. This probe exposed BCCI’s active solicitation of deposits from drug traffickers and money laundering networks. The two-year investigation culminated in 1988 with a staged wedding attended by both BCCI officials and international drug dealers, underscoring the bank’s extensive engagement in unlawful activities. Mazur also established links with the Medellín Cartel, using his undercover identity to dismantle their money laundering schemes. This operation later inspired the 2016 film The Infiltrator.

By 1988, BCCI was identified as a central hub for a large-scale money laundering operation. After a six-month legal proceeding, the bank entered a guilty plea in 1990 under the doctrine of respondeat superior. While federal regulators refrained from taking direct action, authorities in Florida compelled BCCI to withdraw from the state.

In 1990, U.S. Senator Orrin Hatch publicly defended BCCI during a Senate address and collaborated with his aide Michael Pillsbury to mitigate adverse media coverage. Hatch also sought approval from BCCI for a $10 million loan intended for his close associate, Monzer Hourani.

Sandstorm report

In March 1991, the Bank of England engaged Price Waterhouse to conduct an investigation into BCCI. By 24 June 1991, Price Waterhouse delivered the Sandstorm report, which exposed extensive fraud and deceptive practices that concealed the true state of BCCI’s financial affairs.

Leaked excerpts of this report to The Sunday Times revealed that the Abu Nidal terrorist organization used fabricated identities to open accounts at BCCI’s Sloane Street branch in London. Britain's intelligence agency, MI5, enlisted two insiders—a Syrian-born branch manager named Ghassan Qassem and a British staff member—to supply documentation related to these accounts.

Samir Najmeddin from Iraq served as BCCI’s liaison for Abu Nidal. Throughout the 1980s, BCCI issued millions in letters of credit to Najmeddin, primarily financing arms transactions with Iraq. Qassem later identified Najmeddin’s frequent associate as financier Marc Rich, who subsequently faced U.S. charges for tax evasion and racketeering.

Qassem also recounted escorting Abu Nidal—under the pseudonym Shakir Farhan—on shopping trips, unaware of his true identity, which led to the notable 1991 London Evening Standard headline: "I Took Abu Nidal Shopping".

Forced closure

BCCI was awaiting final regulatory consent for a restructuring plan intended to relaunch it as "Oasis Bank." Nevertheless, following the revelations in the Sandstorm report, authorities concluded that BCCI was too compromised to continue operations and mandated its closure. Earlier, in March, BCCI had been compelled to cease its U.S. activities due to unlawful control over First American.

On 5 July 1991, a court in Luxembourg ordered BCCI’s liquidation on grounds of insolvency, noting losses that surpassed its total capital and reserves from the previous year. Regulators closed BCCI’s offices at 1 pm London time that day, directly affecting approximately one million depositors.

Hong Kong’s banking regulator shut down BCCI’s Hong Kong branch on 7 July 1991 because of non-performing loans and insufficient funding from its principal shareholder, the Sheikh of Abu Dhabi. The liquidation of this branch was completed on 17 July.

Several weeks later, Manhattan District Attorney Robert Morgenthau charged BCCI, founder Agha Hasan Abedi, and partner Naqvi with twelve counts including fraud and money laundering. Morgenthau highlighted BCCI’s covert ownership of First American and fraudulent deposit schemes, describing it as "the largest bank fraud in world financial history."

Federal indictments on 15 November accused BCCI, Abedi, and Naqvi of unlawfully taking control of Independence Bank of Los Angeles through Saudi businessman Ghaith Pharaon acting as a front.

In December 1991, liquidators Deloitte and PWC admitted guilt to all U.S. criminal allegations against BCCI, enabling formal liquidation proceedings later that year. BCCI agreed to pay $10 million in fines and surrendered $550 million in U.S. assets—the largest criminal forfeiture at that time—used to cover losses at First American and Independence Bank and compensate depositors. Despite these efforts, Independence was seized in 1992 and First American sold to First Union in 1993.

Most principal figures evaded trial; Abedi passed away in 1995 while indicted but avoided extradition due to protection from Pakistan. Pharaon remained at large until his death in 2017.

In 2002, Denis Robert and Ernest Backes disclosed that BCCI continued illicit operations after closure through Clearstream’s undisclosed accounts.

Financial damages are estimated between $10 billion and $17 billion, with partial recovery efforts carried out by liquidators Deloitte & Touche.

Investigations and Legal Proceedings in the United States

In 1991, Robert Mueller revealed that the government had been probing BCCI since 1986, which triggered widespread media attention.

The following year, Senators John Kerry and Hank Brown jointly produced a report for the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations concerning BCCI. This scandal played a role in shaping the Public Interest Disclosure Act (PIDA) of 1998. The report exposed that Clifford and his associate Robert A. Altman had ties to BCCI dating back to 1978, having been introduced by Bert Lance, former head of the Office of Management and Budget. Pharaon was identified as the nominal owner of National Bank of Georgia and the controlling figure behind CenTrust Bank in Miami, Florida. Clifford and Altman denied knowledge of BCCI’s dominance over First American; however, officials contended they should have been aware.

Morgenthau alongside federal prosecutors charged Clifford and Altman; Clifford was not prosecuted due to health issues and passed away in 1998. Altman faced trial in New York and was acquitted but subsequently agreed to a lifetime ban from banking as part of a civil settlement with the Federal Reserve.

British Investigation and Legal Proceedings

In 1992, an independent inquiry was initiated by the British government under the leadership of Lord Justice Bingham. The inquiry’s findings were published in October under the title Inquiry into the Supervision of the Bank of Credit and Commerce International. Following this, the BCCI liquidators, Deloitte Touche, filed a lawsuit against the Bank of England seeking £850 million for alleged misfeasance in public office. This litigation extended over 12 years until Deloitte withdrew its claims in 2005 after England’s High Court ruled that continuing was not in the best interest of creditors. Deloitte incurred £73 million in legal fees payable to the Bank of England. This case is recognized as one of the costliest in British legal history.

Ongoing Litigation Worldwide

Despite major lawsuits concluding, legal actions connected to BCCI continued well beyond its collapse, with cases still active as late as 2013—over two decades later.

Notable Former Directors

  • Khalid bin Mahfouz, non-executive director; he and his siblings collectively owned a 20% share in BCCI from 1986 to 1990.
  • Alfred Hartman
  • Shaikh Mohammed Ishaq

Significant Legal Cases Involving BCCI

See also

Comprehensive and sourced references

  • Adams, James Ring & Frantz, Douglas. A Full Service Bank, London, 1991
  • Brisard, Jean-Charles & Dasquié, Guillaume. Ben Laden: La Vérité interdite, Gallimard, 2002
  • Ehrenfeld, Rachel. Evil Money. Encounters along the Money Trail, Harper Business, 1992
  • Kerry, John & Brown, Hank. The BCCI Affair, Report to the Committee on Foreign Relations United States Senate, December 1992
  • Robert, Denis & Backes, Ernest. Révélations, Arènes Editions, 2001
  • Price Waterhouse. Report on Sandstorm SA [Part 1], Bank of England, June 1991
  • Price Waterhouse. Report on Sandstorm SA [Part 2], Bank of England, June 1991
  • Kochan, Nick & Whittington, Bob. Bankrupt: The BCCI Fraud, London, 1991
  • "Case study: Bank of Credit and Commerce International", Erisk, June 2001 (via Internet Archive)
  • Compilation of BCCI reports, Association of Accountancy and Business Affairs, accessed November 9, 2005 (archived)

External links

  • Price Waterhouse’s Report on Sandstorm SA [Part 1] for the Bank of England, including redacted sections
  • Price Waterhouse’s Report on Sandstorm SA [Part 2] prepared for the Bank of England
  • Archived homepage of BCCI (in liquidation) as of 17 May 2014
  • BBC News overview covering BCCI liquidators’ withdrawal from a £1 billion lawsuit and legal action against the Bank of England
  • Profile of Bank of Credit and Commerce International (BCCI) at Cooperativeresearch.org (archived)
Retrieved from "https://www.alfawiki.org/index.php?title=Bank_of_Credit_and_Commerce_International&oldid=88519"