Broken Dreams: Vanity, Greed and the Souring of British Football
| Company type | Book |
|---|---|
| Industry | Publishing |
| Founded | 2003 |
| Founder | Tom Bower |
| Products | Non-fiction book |
Broken Dreams: Vanity, Greed and the Souring of British Football is a 2003 factual work authored by British biographer and investigative reporter Tom Bower, which investigates the commercial aspects of English association football. The publication was met with widespread acclaim and secured the William Hill Sports Book of the Year award in 2003.
Content
The book consists of an introduction followed by 13 chapters, offering detailed profiles of prominent football personalities including Terry Venables, Ken Bates, Harry Redknapp, Dennis Roach, and David Dein. It begins with an account of Graham Bean, the compliance officer for the Football Association, and explores reform initiatives led by Alastair Campbell alongside the Football Task Force under Tony Blair. Central themes encompass television broadcasting rights and player transfer transactions within English football.
Reception
Anticipation for Broken Dreams was considerable; The Times speculated that its disclosures could lead to resignations or legal consequences. Although some within the football community expressed disappointment, the book unveiled extensive corruption among managers, fiscal mismanagement by club chairmen and administrators, as well as exploitative behavior by agents.
Reviewers lauded the thoroughness of Bower’s investigation. Anthony Holden writing for The Guardian described it as "dense but devastating," deeming it essential for football enthusiasts. Daniel Finkelstein of The Times labeled it a "devastating book" that exposed widespread unethical conduct. Ros Leckie emphasized its documentation of greed and egotism. Critics from The Daily Telegraph, Russell Davies and John Lanchester, praised Bower’s investigative diligence, though Lanchester remarked on inconsistencies in the writing style. Harry Pearson from When Saturday Comes commended Bower’s lucid explanation of opaque business dealings but found the narrative somber. In The Observer, Will Hutton referred to it as a "tour de force," highlighting its compelling cumulative evidence.
More skeptical was Martin Samuel in The Times, who questioned whether the book revealed novel corruption and criticized certain character depictions along with previously reported information.
The book featured on the Sunday Times bestseller list in February 2003.
Upon winning the 2003 William Hill Sports Book of the Year, Bower was awarded £15,000 along with a complimentary bet. Judge Danny Kelly characterized Broken Dreams as a "powerful weapon" in addressing ethical issues within football.