Columbia Amusement Company

Columbia Amusement Company

Company type	Private
Industry	Burlesque entertainment
Founded	1902 (1902)
Founder	Sam A. Scribner, William S. Campbell, William S. Drew, Gus Hill, John Herbert Mack, Harry Morris, L. Lawrence Weber, A. H. Woodhill
Defunct	1927 (1927)
Headquarters	New York City , United States
Area served	Eastern United States and Toronto
Key people	Sam A. Scribner (President), Gus Hill (President of American Wheel)
Products	Touring burlesque shows

The Columbia Amusement Company, frequently referred to as the Columbia Wheel or the Eastern Burlesque Wheel, was a leading burlesque production enterprise in the United States from 1902 until 1927. Each year, it managed a rotation of approximately thirty to forty touring burlesque ensembles that cycled through a network of theaters, ensuring steady work for entertainers and a continuous influx of fresh performances for venues. The company focused on relatively "clean" variety shows, featuring comedians and appealing performers. Nevertheless, shifts in audience tastes, rivalry from its former offshoot and competitor, the Mutual Burlesque Association, alongside the emergence of cinema and more provocative burlesque styles, ultimately contributed to its downfall.

Background

Burlesque producers and theater managers, inspired by vaudeville producers and theater owners who collaborated to present quality acts and consistent programming, established the Traveling Variety Managers of America (TVMA) in 1897. The idea, credited to Gus Hill, entailed producing sanctioned burlesque performances that rotated systematically among theaters in a "wheel" format. This structure secured prolonged employment for performers and guaranteed theaters a steady flow of productions without competing for shows.

Formation

The TVMA divided into two separate wheels: the Empire Wheel covering the western region and the Columbia Wheel serving the eastern area. On July 12, 1902, sixteen managers and producers formed the Columbia Amusement Company, with Sam A. Scribner at the helm alongside key figures including William S. Campbell, William S. Drew, Gus Hill, John Herbert Mack, Harry Morris, L. Lawrence Weber, and A. H. Woodhill. Based in New York City, Columbia's circuit encompassed theaters in major eastern urban centers such as Washington, D.C., Philadelphia, New York, Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Toronto, and Boston—earning it the moniker Eastern Wheel.

Early years

The Columbia company sought to provide affordable burlesque entertainment that was relatively "clean," catering to both female and male audiences. Its variety programs included comedians, sketches, specialty acts, and chorus girls. In August 1905, Will Rogers contracted for five one-week engagements in Brooklyn, Buffalo, Cleveland, and Pittsburgh. By 1908, Columbia had acquired the Murray Hill Theatre located on Lexington Avenue.

Although the wheel system brought stability to the industry, it also led to shows becoming formulaic and expensive to update with new routines and costumes. Performers frequently transitioned to legitimate theater as they gained fame. Distinguished former members included Bert Lahr, Rose Sydell, Sophie Tucker, Fanny Brice, Leon Errol, Jean Bedini, and the comedy duo Bobby Clark with Paul McCullough. Despite frequent turnover among talent, burlesque remained lucrative due to strong audience interest in chorus girls.

In 1908, Chicago's Star and Garter promoted "Clean Entertainment for Self-Respecting People." On January 10, 1910, Columbia inaugurated its premier venue—the Columbia Theatre—situated at Broadway and 47th Street in Manhattan. Owned and operated by the Columbia Amusement Company and designed by architect William H. McElfatrick, this theater accommodated 1,385 patrons and represented a strategic milestone for the company's leadership within burlesque entertainment. Its opening garnered considerable attention from both the press and notable figures.

Evolution

Under the guidance of Scribner, Columbia consistently delivered respectable productions, while the Empire Wheel, managed by Isidore Herk, frequently tested the limits of legality. At times, Columbia compromised its usual standards to directly challenge Empire’s offerings. In 1913, these two circuits combined to form the Columbia Wheel, with Scribner and Herk jointly producing shows that were relatively wholesome.

Following the decline of the Empire Wheel, the Progressive Wheel arose as a new rival. In response, Columbia introduced a secondary circuit in 1914, known as "No.2," aimed at competing with both Progressive and local stock burlesque troupes. By 1915, this No.2 circuit had absorbed Progressive and was spun off as the American Wheel, continuing Columbia’s reputation for cleaner entertainment. Gus Hill was appointed president and effectively eliminated competition.

After World War I, Scribner upheld Columbia’s dedication to maintaining cleaner entertainment despite changing audience preferences. While the American Wheel incorporated cooch dancers and runway performances, Columbia refrained from using runways until its final years. Scribner prohibited smoking within theaters and sought to restrict comedians’ use of suggestive double entendres, though with limited effectiveness. A 1922 report highlighted Columbia’s emphasis on "clean, wholesome offerings," distinguishing it from traditional burlesque.

Affiliated Theaters

In the 1922–23 season, Columbia productions toured a wide array of theaters in major urban centers, including:

Palace (Baltimore); Casino and Gayety (Boston); Miner’s (The Bronx); Casino and Empire (Brooklyn); Gayety (Buffalo); Columbia and Englewood (Chicago); Star & Garter (Chicago); Olympic (Cincinnati); Colonial (Cleveland); Lyric (Dayton); Gayety venues in Detroit, Kansas City, Louisville, Milwaukee, Minneapolis, Montreal, Omaha, Rochester, St. Louis, Washington D.C.; Majestic (Jersey City); Miner’s (Newark); Cohen’s theaters in Newburgh and Poughkeepsie; Columbia and Hurtig & Seamon’s 125th Street (New York City); Orpheum (Paterson); Casino (Philadelphia); Gayety (Pittsburgh); Empire theaters in Providence, Toledo, Toronto; Colonial (Utica); Lyceum (Scranton); Grand (Worcester).

These theaters varied by season and most have since been demolished.

Show Titles

The 1922–23 season on the Columbia circuit featured productions such as American Girl, Beauty Revue, Big Jamboree, Bowery Burlesquers, Broadway Brevities, Chuckles of 1922, Follies of the Day, Greenwich Village Revue, Keep Smiling, and Radio Girls, among others. Some show titles were recycled annually with new casts, while others retained their performers but changed titles. It is important to note that Billy Watson and Sliding Billy Watson were separate entertainers.

Decline and dissolution

The American Wheel disbanded in 1922 after a rift between Scribner and Herk, who considered Columbia’s approach outdated. Subsequently, Herk took leadership of the competing Mutual Burlesque Association, which showcased simpler productions inspired by risqué revues from Flo Ziegfeld and Earl Carroll.

By 1923, Columbia still operated as the largest burlesque organization with thirty-eight shows but experienced decreasing revenues. In 1925, Scribner reluctantly permitted chorus girls to appear barelegged and approved the "Powder Puff Revue," which featured bare-breasted tableaux reminiscent of Ziegfeld’s spectacles. However, growing competition from cinemas offering combined film screenings and live acts at lower prices diminished Columbia’s market share. Performers and venues increasingly defected to Mutual’s more explicit stock burlesque shows.

Mutual encountered difficulties in the late 1920s, culminating in a 1927 merger with Columbia that created the United Burlesque Association; Herk served as president while Scribner assumed the role of board chairman. This merged organization controlled 44 theaters but soon reverted to operating under the Mutual name.

By the 1927–28 season, financial strains worsened significantly. The onset of the Great Depression proved decisive as efforts to revive clean burlesque during 1930–31 failed in the face of competition from smaller and more affordable stock theaters, ultimately leading to the circuit’s closure.

References

Citations

Sources