Consolidated National Bank

Consolidated National Bank of New York
Company type	Private
Industry	Banking, Financial services
Founded	July 1, 1902; 124 years ago in New York City, United States
Founder	Mortimer H. Wagar
Defunct	1909
Fate	Merged with Oriental Bank to form National Reserve Bank
Headquarters	New York City, United States
Key people	Mortimer H. Wagar (founder, vice president), Willis S. Paine (founding president), O.F. Thomas (president), Will-tarn O. Allison (president of successor bank)
Products	Banking services

Consolidated National Bank of New York was a financial institution established in New York City on July 1, 1902, with an initial capital investment of $1 million. Founded by Mortimer H. Wagar, the bank sought to attract clients from the Consolidated Exchange and its brokerage community. Operations began at 57 Broadway on September 22, 1902, and in 1903 the bank secured a five-year lease at the Exchange Court Building. In 1906, the Consolidated Stock Exchange withdrew its funds from the institution. Eventually, in 1909, Consolidated National Bank combined with the assets of Oriental Bank to create the National Reserve Bank, temporarily maintaining the Consolidated name.

1902: Establishment

On February 11, 1902, The New York Times announced that subscriptions totaling $600,000 had been raised to fund the Consolidated National Bank, which was organized under the leadership of founding president Mortimer H. Wagar, who previously served as president of the Consolidated Stock and Petroleum Exchange. At that time, a lease was finalized for premises in the Pinkerton Building located at 57 Broadway, with plans to commence operations within three months.

The bank was formally established on July 1, 1902, backed by $1 million in capital and governed by a fourteen-member board based at 51 Broadway. In late August, three additional directors were appointed. By September 12, incorporation documents were submitted to the Controller of the Currency, and the first board meeting was held. The institution officially opened its doors at No. 57 Broadway on September 22, 1902, supported by $1 million in capital and surplus funds. The founding president was Willis S. Paine.

1902-1905: Initial Financial Performance

On October 23, 1902, the bank received its first batch of $20,000 in five-dollar banknotes featuring Benjamin Harrison, part of a larger $250,000 order that also included ten and twenty dollar denominations. The New York Times drew attention to these "new national banknotes" distinguished by their green backs. By November 25, 1902, Consolidated National Bank reported earnings of $1,012,995 alongside deposits totaling $2,607,946, loans amounting to $2,529,810, and overall assets reaching $4,930,742. Initially housed at 57 Broadway, in September 1903 the bank leased approximately 2,500 square feet for five years at the Exchange Court Building, located at Broadway and Exchange Place.

By April 1904, under President Willis Paine’s leadership, Consolidated National Bank began processing clearings through the Fourth National Bank. As of November 1904, Willis S. Paine held the presidency while Mortimer H. Wagar served as vice president. In January 1905, Paine authored an op-ed in The New York Times advocating for regular financial audits to protect both depositors and shareholders. The annual meeting of directors that month saw several resignations. Initially priced at $200 per share upon issuance, stock traded near $175 by September 1905 without issuing dividends. Paine observed that modest interest rates between 2.5% and 3% constrained banks’ profitability.

Around November 1905, Willis S. Paine stepped down as president with intentions to travel overseas.

1905-1907: Leadership Transitions

On October 31, 1905, the board selected O.F. Thomas as the new president, following the resignation of Willis S. Paine. At that time, The New York Times highlighted the bank’s lackluster earnings and anticipated that Thomas would inject new energy into its operations. The initial strategy, which concentrated on attracting depositors from the Consolidated Exchange, had not met expectations, leading to a pivot toward a wider market approach.

By February 9, 1906, the Consolidated Stock Exchange removed its deposits from Consolidated National Bank and transferred them to the National Bank of North America. This move signaled diminished confidence in the bank after leadership changes under E.R. Thomas. Midway through 1907, shares of the bank were publicly trading at $180 each. In October of that year, E.R. Thomas sold his holdings and stepped down from all roles.

In December 1907, Consolidated National Bank intended to merge with the National Bank of North America as part of a plan to decrease capital and distribute cash back to shareholders for reinvestment purposes. However, this merger was blocked by the president of the National Bank, preventing both the acquisition and related capital restructuring initiatives.

1909: Formation of National Reserve Bank

On February 2, 1909, Consolidated approved a proposal to acquire Oriental Bank by offering its shareholders an opportunity to subscribe to shares in a new institution at $150 per share. Although Oriental Bank had ceased operations the previous year, it had fully reimbursed depositors. The newly formed entity, named the National Reserve Bank, combined assets from both organizations. Stockholders ratified this merger on February 18, increasing capital from $1,000,000 to $1,200,000 and appointing 23 directors, including E. A. Fisher and Mortimer H. Wagar. The Consolidated name was retained until March 1.

On March 2, 1909, Will-tarn O. Allison (W.O. Allison), previously president of Consolidated National Bank, assumed the presidency of National Reserve Bank. Vice presidents elected included Thomas J. Lewis and R. W. Jones Jr., with George W. Adams serving as cashier. Following the merger, capital was raised to $2,000,000. The bank commenced operations on March 8 at Oriental Bank’s former premises located at 182 Broadway and John Street in Manhattan before relocating in late April 1909 to the City Investing Building at 165 Broadway.

Directors

At its inception on July 1, 1902, Consolidated National Bank's board consisted of fourteen directors featuring prominent business figures such as Jonathan B. Currey, Mortimer H. Wagar, Willis S. Paine (who also held the presidency), and Perry Belmont. By August 1902, additional board members like Amzi L. Barber, Lyman G. Bloomingdale of Bloomingdale Brothers, and James G. Newcomb had joined. The inaugural directors' meeting was convened in September 1902.

On April 16, 1904, under President Willis Paine's guidance, four new directors were appointed: Alonzo Burbank, Thomas F. Manville, William T. Brown, and Charles H. Patterson. By November that year, Mortimer H. Wagar held the position of vice president alongside Paine. Board membership continued to evolve with John W. Griggs retiring around November 1905; following which E.R. Thomas appointed directors including Edward Russell Thomas, O.F. Thomas, Robert Maclay, and George B. Hays. These adjustments mirrored ongoing changes in corporate governance aligned with the bank’s strategic development throughout its operation period.

External links