Dnyaneshwar Agashe

Dnyaneshwar Chandrashekhar Agashe
Born	Template:Birth date Pune, Bombay Presidency, British India
Died	January 2, 2009(2009-01-02) (aged 66)
Occupation(s)	Entrepreneur, cricketer, cricket official, benefactor
Years active	1955–2008
Known for	Founder of Suvarna Sahakari Bank; managing director of Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate; vice president of BCCI

Dnyaneshwar Chandrashekhar Agashe (17 April 1942 – 2 January 2009) was a prominent Indian entrepreneur, cricketer, cricket official, and benefactor. He established the Suvarna Sahakari Bank in 1969 and held the position of managing director until his passing. Between 1970 and 1978, he shared the role of joint managing director at the Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate Ltd. with his brother Panditrao Agashe, subsequently becoming the sole managing director from 1978 until his death.

During his early years, Agashe was an accomplished first-class cricketer, playing as a batsman for the Maharashtra cricket team in the Cooch Behar Trophy, serving as a wicket-keeper-batsman for the West Zone cricket team, and performing as wicket-keeper for the Indian Universities cricket team between 1955 and 1968. Later transitioning to cricket administration, he was elected vice president of the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) twice, holding office from 1995 to 1999. He made two unsuccessful bids for the BCCI presidency in 1996 and 1997, both times defeated by Raj Singh Dungarpur.

In his later career, internal conflicts within the Maharashtra Cricket Association between 2003 and 2005 culminated in his resignation after serving seven consecutive terms as executive chairman since 1989. This period was followed by legal challenges related to fraud allegations concerning Suvarna Sahakari Bank in 2008.

Agashe is remembered for his significant contributions to education in Pune, including his role on the board of the Deccan Education Society, financing the establishment of the Panditrao Agashe School, and acting as vice chairperson of the National Cricket Academy in Bangalore. A supporter of Marathi literature and arts, he enriched the collections at the Raja Dinkar Kelkar Museum and published works by various Marathi authors, poets, and dramatists.

Early life, education, and family: 1942–1967

Born on 17 April 1942 in Pune, then part of the Bombay Presidency, Agashe belonged to a Chitpavan brahmin lineage through his industrialist father Chandrashekhar Agashe and mother Indirabai (née Dwarka Gokhale). His father was a member of the distinguished Agashe gharana from Mangdari within the former Bhor State. Among nine siblings who survived into adulthood, he was the third youngest; notable siblings included elder brother Panditrao Agashe and sister Shakuntala Karandikar. His twin sister Mukta passed away during infancy.

His mother descended from the noble Gokhale gharana of Dharwad, being a great niece of Maratha military leader Bapu Gokhale. Through this maternal connection, Agashe was distantly linked to musician Ashutosh Phatak, historian Dinkar G. Kelkar, and scientist P. K. Kelkar.

Agashe spent his childhood across Pune, Shreepur, and Mangdari. Following Mahatma Gandhi's assassination in 1948, during anti-Brahmin riots, their family residence Chausopi and adjacent Ram temple were destroyed by fire. He commenced his education at Nutan Marathi Vidyalaya in Pune before transferring to Raman Baug High School under the Deccan Education Society. He completed a Bachelor of Arts degree at Sir Parshurambhau College in 1964 and subsequently earned a Bachelor of Commerce from Brihan Maharashtra College of Commerce.

In 1967, Agashe married Rekha Gogte, niece of industrialist Raosaheb Gogte. She belonged to the Gogte gharana originating from Belgaum and traced her ancestry to the aristocratic Latey family. This alliance connected Agashe to Kokuyo Camlin's leader Dilip Dandekar and academic figure Jyoti Gogte. Together they had three children: sons Mandar Agashe and Ashutosh Agashe, along with daughter Sheetal Agashe.

Cricket career: 1955–1968

At Raman Baug High School, Agashe honed his abilities across multiple sports, including cricket, field hockey, football, and badminton. Under the mentorship of coach Rambhau Lele, he played as a center-forward in hockey. His batting technique was characterized by a right-handed grip and distinctive lofted strokes. He played a significant role in securing victories for his school's cricket team in tournaments such as the Sethna Cup and Pudumjee Shield.

Between 1955 and 1957, Agashe earned selection for both the Pune district and Maharashtra cricket squads, participating in the Cooch Behar Trophy. Following his training at the National Defense Academy, he took on the role of wicket-keeper-batsman for the West Zone team. His impressive performance during matches in Calcutta led to his inclusion in the Indian Universities cricket team that toured Sri Lanka.

From 1962 through 1968, Agashe appeared in first-class cricket matches representing Maharashtra, accumulating two half-centuries over 13 games. His standout season occurred in 1964–65 when he achieved a personal best score of 75 runs, alongside ten catches and two stumpings. These contributions were instrumental in Maharashtra’s victory against the Gujarat team captained by Nari Contractor. Notable teammates during this period included Chandu Borde, Sadanand Mohol, and Hemant Kanitkar. Additionally, he fulfilled wicket-keeping duties for the Indian universities side facing Sri Lanka that same season.

Initial business endeavors: 1966–1978

The Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate was established by Agashe’s father in 1934. Following his father’s passing in 1956, S. L. Limaye assumed the chairmanship from 1959 to 1990, while managing director positions were held by K. V. Champhekar and subsequently G. S. Valimbe until 1969. Agashe joined the syndicate’s board in 1966 and oversaw expansion efforts that included establishing new branches near Akluj.

In 1969, Agashe became involved with the Maharashtra Cricket Association and founded Pune-based Suvarna Sahakari Bank, which catered primarily to middle-class clientele. That same year, he published a historical fiction novel authored by D. G. Kulkarni and produced research memoirs related to hydraulics from Pune’s Central Water and Power Research Station.

During the 1970s, under the leadership of Agashe and his brother, the syndicate diversified its operations to include liquor production at Shreepur in Maharashtra, focusing on whisky brands under various flagship labels. In July 1970, both brothers were appointed joint managing directors of the syndicate. That year also saw Agashe publish V. H. Vadekar’s collection of short stories and launch Rajas, a newspaper with a monthly circulation.

In response to the severe drought affecting Maharashtra in 1972, Agashe and his brother supplied water from their Mangdari estate to support tap water systems in villages within Bhor district. The following year, they contributed an exhibit commemorating their father to the Raja Dinkar Kelkar Museum. In 1974, Agashe published character sketches written by Chintamani Tryambak Khanolkar.

By 1977, Agashe and his brother had played a pivotal role in founding the Chandrashekhar Agashe College of Physical Education, named after their father. That same year, Agashe was elected vice president of the Deccan Sugar Factory Association.

Broadened involvement in commerce, cricket governance, and charitable activities: 1978–1990

Following his brother's retirement in 1978, Agashe assumed the role of sole managing director at the Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate. By 1979, he was recognized as the printer for C. P. Bhishikar’s analysis of Hindu culture, and in 1983 for publishing M. A. Bhagwat’s correspondence on Marathi theatre. In 1984, he became a member of the editorial board for the Solapur division of the Maharashtra Sahitya Parishad. Starting in 1985, Agashe actively promoted cricket tournaments across India, the United Kingdom, and the Middle East. In January 1986, he conducted an interview with S. L. Kirloskar on behalf of the Mahratta Chamber of Commerce.

After the passing of his brother Panditrao in November 1986, Agashe made donations to Maharashtra Vidya Mandal; subsequently, the Panditrao Agashe School was named to honor him. He also established Chandrashekhar Agashe High School, Junior College, and Indirabai Agashe High School on the family property located in Shreepur, Maharashtra. In 1987, Agashe took part in an inquiry led by Shankarrao Chavan concerning Sharad Pawar’s overseas assets. That same year, serving as secretary of the Maharashtra Cricket Association during the 1987 Cricket World Cup, he forecasted low spectator turnout for the Sri Lanka versus England match.

Agashe chaired Kolhapur Steel after the syndicate expanded into metal printing during the early 1980s. By the late 1980s, he had launched a Taj Rum production unit in Canada and diversified the syndicate’s operations to include pharmaceuticals, power generation, publishing through Mandar Printing Press, and real estate development by the early 1990s. In November 1986, his name appeared among shareholders involved in a lawsuit against Sakal Media Group initiated by Nanasaheb Parulekar’s heirs. He managed the Indian cricket team’s tour of the UK in 1987 and represented private sugar enterprises during Maharashtra’s sugar factory nationalization discussions in 1988. That year also saw him serve as president of the Deccan Sugar Factory Association. In 1989, Agashe was appointed executive chairman of the Maharashtra Cricket Association and held a directorship at Sakal Papers.

Prominent entrepreneur and cricket official: 1990–2003

In 1990, following S. L. Limaye’s death, Agashe was appointed chairman of the Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate board. As BCCI vice-president in 1991, he opposed renewing veto powers held by Australia and England at the ICC and resisted South Africa's inclusion in the 1992 Cricket World Cup while endorsing India’s bid to host the tournament in 1996.

In April 1992, Agashe led the committee responsible for organizing under-19 international cricket tours. Reports indicate that he voted against India’s and Pakistan’s joint bid to host the 1996 World Cup that year. Subsequently, he headed a BCCI panel tasked with preparing India’s official proposal for hosting the 1995–96 World Cup. In September, he recommended changes to simplify the Ranji Trophy points system by adopting an Australian-style format and suggested reducing match durations to enhance competitiveness.

In 1993, Agashe inaugurated the Deodhar Entrance at Pune’s Nehru Stadium and advocated for funding geological research projects in 1994. During this period, he was elected twice as BCCI vice president and once as treasurer. Although he contested for BCCI president in 1996, he narrowly lost but served as vice chairman of the finance committee overseeing joint management of that year's World Cup. He ran again for BCCI presidency in 1997 but was defeated by incumbent Raj Singh Dungarpur amid prevailing political alliances within cricket administration. Sports journalist K. R. Wadhwaney described him as a "gentleman-cricket player" and "soft-spoken official," noting that his electoral defeats reflected increasing politicization within BCCI.

On the business front, Agashe expanded syndicate operations into country liquor production and banking software while advancing sugarcane research initiatives. He relinquished his managing director role in 1996 to his son Ashutosh. That year also saw him publish a Hindi translation of Dnyaneshwari as trustee of Dnyaneshwar Sansthan. By 1997, he chaired Brihans Laboratories, known for producing Brihans Natural Products. In 1998, Agashe served as a director within Baba Kalyani's Kalyani Group and contributed scholarly articles relating to Maharashtra's social studies. He also presented the man of the match award at that year's Wills Trophy.

By 2000, Agashe held positions on both the Deccan Education Society board and Shiv Chhatrapati Award committee; his efforts were acknowledged in Narubhau Limaye's memoirs. In 2001, he unsuccessfully sought election as BCCI treasurer. A ceremony marking his sixtieth birthday took place in Pune in 2002 featuring a motorcycle rally, a festschrift publication, a commemorative cricket match at Nehru Stadium, and receptions hosted by local dignitaries including Sharad Pawar. Additionally, he delivered a keynote address at the seventy-fifth Akhil Bharatiya Marathi Sahitya Sammelan presided over by Rajendra Banhatti. By 2003, Agashe was recognized among leading Chitpavan Brahmin entrepreneurs.

Maharashtra Cricket Association internal conflicts: 2003–2006

Agashe was appointed to a historic seventh term as executive chairman of the Maharashtra Cricket Association in April 2003.<ref> In addition, he held voting membership within the Mumbai Cricket Association and occupied the role of vice chair at the National Cricket Academy.<ref> Due to ongoing factional tensions, a provisional nine-member committee was established in 2003 but was disbanded by January 2004, resulting in Agashe's reinstatement as chairman.<ref>

By September 2004, with disputes continuing between Agashe and Ajay Shirke, the Bombay High Court designated observers for the Maharashtra Cricket Association, including B. G. Deshmukh.<ref> That same month, MCA president Jagmohan Dalmiya barred Agashe from attending the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) annual general meeting, citing internal MCA factionalism.<ref> Additionally, Agashe was stripped of voting privileges in the Board's presidential election, which reportedly influenced Sharad Pawar's narrow defeat by a single vote—believed to be Agashe's.<ref> Pawar’s supporters interpreted Agashe’s late arrival and his protest against the voting ban as intentional.<ref>

In October 2004, Agashe initiated legal proceedings contesting the election results, claiming that his excluded vote resulted in an unjust win for Dalmiya’s preferred candidate, Ranbir Singh Mahendra.<ref> The Madras High Court ultimately upheld the election outcome,<ref> with Agashe publicly expressing contentment.<ref> Subsequently, Maharashtra's Deputy Charity Commissioner issued a court order suspending the MCA managing committee’s activities.<ref>

The rivalry between Agashe and Shirke factions continued throughout 2005.<ref> MCA elections incorporated revised regulations suggested by both sides,<ref> culminating in Shirke’s victory,<ref> thereby concluding Agashe’s unprecedented seventh term as chairman.<ref> Critics attributed a subpar cricket season in Pune to these ongoing disputes.<ref>

In August 2006, during the Poona Young Cricketers' Hindu Gymkhana liquor scandal,<ref> Agashe held the presidency but resigned in September after serving three years.<ref> He had initially been elected club president in 2004.<ref>

Suvarna Sahakari Bank fraud accusations: 2006–2009

By September 2006, financial troubles engulfed Suvarna Sahakari Bank. Allegations connected its collapse, along with difficulties faced by Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate, to Agashe’s failed attempt to secure Pawar’s BCCI presidency in 2004 within a Maharashtra governed by the Nationalist Congress Party. That month, the Reserve Bank of India imposed a moratorium on Suvarna Sahakari Bank, after which Cosmos Bank declared intentions to acquire it.

In June 2007, Agashe’s Hotel Ranjeet was auctioned off to settle outstanding loans, followed by the divestment of his controlling interest in The Kolhapur Steel Ltd. to Kirloskar Brothers in September of that year. By February 2008, depositors gathered at Agashe’s Aundh residence demanding repayment and threatening legal measures. In May 2008, Agashe pledged personal assets valued at ₹200 crore as collateral against deposits amounting to ₹725 crore.

On 22 November 2008, Agashe along with fourteen board members were placed under judicial custody amid allegations of a ₹436.74 crore scam. They faced accusations of approving loans predominantly to companies they controlled and subsequently defaulting on repayments, thereby defrauding depositors. The judicial magistrate remanded them into police custody citing their advanced ages.

Following these arrests, law enforcement searched Agashe’s home uncovering evidence indicative of conflicts of interest and loan disbursements contravening RBI guidelines. The defense maintained that loan approvals were conducted by the bank’s disbursement committee without direct involvement from Agashe and pointed to property sales by his family aimed at loan recovery. They also raised concerns about delays in filing the initial complaint. Requests for bail by Agashe and family members were denied.

Passing, memorial services, and enduring impact: 2009

During his detention, Agashe's health deteriorated significantly due to advanced diabetes and gangrene, necessitating his hospitalization at Sassoon Hospital on 22 December 2009. He succumbed to a heart attack on 2 January 2009, aged 66, while receiving treatment for diabetes-related complications.

On 4 January, his remains were displayed at both his residence in Shaniwar Peth and the Suvarna Sahakari Bank branch. The funeral ceremony took place at Vaikunth crematorium, with prominent attendees such as Suresh Kalmadi and Ashok Mohol. Memorial gatherings were organized at the Poona Young Cricketer's Hindu Gymkhana, the Maharashtra Cricket Association, and at his family home.

Following his demise, Agashe's son, Ashutosh Agashe, assumed the roles of chairman and managing director of the Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate. The legal proceedings concerning the Suvarna Sahakari Bank persisted after Agashe’s death, ultimately resulting in the bank’s closure and its merger with the Indian Overseas Bank in May 2009.

In tribute to Agashe’s legacy, Ashutosh inaugurated the Dnyaneshwar Agashe Trophy in 2015, which serves as the top honor at the Poona Youth Club’s annual cricket competition. Businessman Madhav Apte lauded Agashe’s stature in his 2016 memoir. Additionally, in April 2022, the Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate republished Agashe’s 2002 festschrift in English translation by Nandan Phadnis.

Scholarly articles

• Sabade, B. R.; Gogte, J. J.; Agashe, D. C. "An Entrepreneurial Study: Shri. S. L. Kirloskar", Mahratta Chamber of Commerce, Industries and Agriculture, Educational Media Research Centre, Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune, 16 January 1986.

Book forewords

• Agashe, Dnyaneshwar. Introduction to Vishwasta (1992) by Shakuntala Karandikar, Shri Prakashan, Pune, pages iii–v.
• Agashe, Dnyaneshwar. Introduction to Vishwasta – The Trustee: The Life of Industrialist Chandrashekhar Agashe (2022) by Shakuntala Karandikar, translated by Nandan Phadnis, Brihan Maharashtra Sugar Syndicate Ltd., Pune, pages 6–7.

Bibliography

• Agashe, Trupti & Gopal. आगाशे कुलवृत्तांत (Genealogy of the Agashe Family), Surbhi Graphics, Hyderabad, 2nd ed., 2006.
• Agarwala, R. P., ed. Eastern Economist, R. P. Agarwala, New Delhi, vol. 69, 1977.
• Aggarwal, S. K. Media Credibility, Mittal Publications, New Delhi, 1989.
• Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (India). Annual Report of the Registrar of Newspapers for India, Press Registrar General of India, New Delhi, 1971.
• Central Water and Power Research Station. Annual Research Memoirs: Summary, Pune, 1969.
• Apte, Madhav. Daivāyattam, Rajhans Prakashan, Pune, 2016.
• Barve, Ramesh; Vartak, Taraprakash; Belvalkar, Sharchandra (eds). पुत्र विश्वस्ताचा : गौरव ग्रंथ : ज्ञानेश्वर आगाशे षष्ट्यब्दीपूर्ती निमित्त (Festschrift for Dnyaneshwar Agashe), Jñāneśvara Āgāśe Gaurava Samitī, Pune, 1st ed., 2002.
• Bhagwat, Mahadev Anant. इदं न मम : "बालमोहन" च्या रंगभूमीच्या काळात नातं घडवणाऱ्या नाट्यवेड्या विचक्षण रसिकाची पत्रे, Bāpūrāva Māne, Pune, 1983.
• Bhishikar, C. P. संस्कृतीच्या मळवाटा (The Filth of Culture), Bhāratīya Vicāra Sādhanā, Pune, 1979.
• Booth, Lawrence (ed). The Wisden Archive of Cricketers' Lives, John Wisden & Company Ltd., London, 2015.
• Canadian Manufacturers' Association. Canadian Trade Index, Toronto, 1980.
• Dixit, M. S. आम्ही चित्पावन : कोकणस्थ (We are Chitpavan: Konkanstha), Nīlakaṇtha Prakāśana, Pune, 1st ed., 2003.
• Gadgil, Amarendra Laxman. श्रीरामकोश (Śrīrāmakośa), Śrīrāmakośa Maṇḍaḷa, 1973.
• Glushkova, I. P.; Feldhaus, Anne (eds). House and Home in Maharashtra, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1998.
• Glushkova, I. P.; Vora, Rajendra (eds). Home, Family and Kinship in Maharashtra, Oxford University Press, New Delhi, 1999.
• Gupta P. R., ed. Dairy India, P. R. Gupta Publishers, New Delhi, 1997.
• Gurunathan S. K., ed. Indian Cricket, Kasturi & Sons Ltd., Madras, vol. 20, 1966.
• Jakatdar Shrikrishna Anant. ज्योतिर्वैभव डिरेकटोरी (Jyotirvaibhav Directory), Phal Jyotish Abhyas Mandal Sanstha, Pune, 1967.
• Jamdar Urmila (ed). ज्ञानेव्हारी (Dnyaneshwari), Shri Dnyaneshwar Maharaj Sansthan, Pune, 1996.
• Joshi Nilatai Krishna. कृष्णा काठ ते इंद्रायणी घाट, Mandar Printers, Pune; 2nd ed., 1994.
• Kamath M.V.. The Makings of a Millionaire: A Tribute to a Living Legend Raosaheb B.M. Gogte, Jaico Publishing House Mumbai; 1991.
• Karandikar Shakuntala. विश्वस्त (Viśvasta), Śrī Prakāśana Pune; 1st ed., ISBN 9781532345012; 1992.
• Kelkar Bhaskar; Kelkar Govind; Kelkar Yashwant. केळकर कुलवृत्तांत (Genealogy of the Kelkar Family), Yashoda Typesetting Pune; 2nd ed., 1993.
• Khanolkar C.T.. दीपमाळा (Garland Lamp), Śrī Prakāśana Pune; 1st ed., 1974.
• Sakthi Sugars Limited. Kisan World, Sakthi Sugars Limited Madras; vol., iss.,1988.
• Kothari & Sons. Kothari's Economic and Industrial Guide of India, Madras;1978.
• Kulkarni Dattatray Gangadhar.हैबती : शाहिरी ऐतिहासिक कादंबरी (Haibati: Imperial Historical Novel), Nalinī Prakāśana Pune;1st ed.,1969.
• Maniyar Vitthal.विठ्ठलनाम, Ameya Prakāśana Pune;4th ed.,2005.
• Société géologique de France.Mémoires de la Société géologique de France, Société géologique de France;1994.
• Mergent FIS Inc., Moody's Investors Service.Moody's International Manual, New York; vol.2;1998.
• Hathway Investments Pvt Limited.Outlook, New Delhi; vol.44(issue43–51);2004.
• Pagès Jean-Simon.Actes du Premier Symposium international sur la protection du patrimoine géologique: Digne-les-Bains, Société géologique de France;1994.
• Pathak Gangadhar.गोखले कुलवृत्तांत (Genealogy of the Gokhale Family), Gokhale Kulavr̥ttānta Kāryakārī Maṇdaḷa Pune;2nd ed.,1978.
• Patil Anantrao.नरुभाऊंच्या आठवणी (Memories of Narubhau), Mīrā Prakāśana Pune;2000.
• Pawar Rajaram.Socio-Economic Impact of Sugar Factories on Rural Areas of Solapur District: A Geographical Analysis, Capital Publishing House New Delhi;2016.
• Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (India).Press in India, Press Registrar General of India New Delhi; vol33;1989.
• Puppala Chandramohan.No Ball, Pan Macmillan;2019.
• Ranade Sadashiv.चितपावन कौशिक गोत्री आगाशे कुलवृत्तांत(Genealogy of the Chitpavan Agashe Family), Pustake miḷaṇyāce ṭhikāṇa;1974.
• Ranade Sadashiv.फाटक कुलवृत्तांत(Genealogy of the Phatak Family), Phāṭaka Kula Samitī Pune;2nd ed.;1982.
• Deccan Education Society.Report of the Deccan Education Society for the Year..., Deccan Education Society Poona;2000.
• Roy Ram Narayan.Sugar Industry in Darbhanga Division, Capital Publishing House New Delhi;1988.
• Sharangpani R.C.Fitness training in cricket, Marine Sports Publishing Division Bombay;1992.
• Singh Gurdeep.Cricket in Northern India, Cosmo Publications New Delhi;1966.
• Singh Jasmer.The Young Lions: Kenya's Cricketing Pride, Indiana University Press;1998.
• Maharashtra State Co-operative Union.The Maharashtra Co-operative Quarterly, Bombay; vol63;1979.
• Tikekar Aruna; Tilak Abhay.शहर पुणे : एका संस्कृती संचिता मागोवा(City of Pune: A Cultural Treasure Trove), Niḷubhāū Limaye Phauṇḍeśana Pune; vol2;2000.
• Vadekar Vijay Hari.नम म्हणे : कथा संग्रह(Humbly Speaking: A Collection of Stories), Srī Prakāśana Pune;1970.
• Wadhwaney Kishin R..Cricket's Murky Underworld, Ajanta Books International New Delhi;2001.
• Wadhwaney Kishin R..Indian Cricket Controversies, Ajanta Books International New Delhi;2002.
• Wadhwaney Kishin R..Indian Cricket and Corruption, Siddharth Publications New Delhi;1st ed.;2005.
• Gogaṭe Kulamaṇḍala.गोगटे कुलवृत्तांत(Genealogy of the Gogte Family), Gogaṭe Kulamaṇḍala Mumbai;2nd ed.;2006
• Mahārāshṭra Sāhitya Parishada.महाराष्ट्र साहित्य पत्रिका(Maharashtra Literature Magazine), Pune; issues228–231;1984
• Sharda.शारदा, Mahārāshṭra Sāhitya Parishada Bombay; vol14;1972