Drop Dead Fred

Drop Dead Fred
Company type	Film
Industry	Film industry
Founded	1991; 35 years ago
Founder	Ate de Jong (director)
Products	Black comedy fantasy film
Parent	PolyGram Filmed Entertainment, Working Title Films, New Line Cinema

Drop Dead Fred is a 1991 black comedy fantasy film directed by Ate de Jong, produced by PolyGram Filmed Entertainment alongside Working Title Films, and distributed by New Line Cinema. The movie features Phoebe Cates portraying Elizabeth Cronin, a suppressed woman troubled by her imaginary companion, Drop Dead Fred, played by Rik Mayall. The cast also includes notable performances from Marsha Mason, Tim Matheson, and Carrie Fisher. Although it faced predominantly negative reviews upon release, the film has since developed a devoted cult following.

Plot

Elizabeth Cronin, a timid court reporter based in Minneapolis, experiences a series of personal and career challenges, including a divorce and losing her job. Through reconnecting with her friend Mickey Bunce, she recalls her childhood imaginary friend, Drop Dead Fred, who had once been a source of comfort amid her domineering mother Polly’s control.

After moving back in with Polly, Elizabeth inadvertently frees Fred from a jack-in-the-box secured with tape. Fred’s chaotic behavior initially exacerbates Elizabeth’s troubles and causes distress to those around her. Alarmed by the situation, Polly takes Elizabeth to see a psychiatrist who prescribes medication designed to suppress Fred’s influence.

Fred reveals that Polly’s act of taping the jack-in-the-box symbolized erasing him from Elizabeth’s life, which contributed to her psychological wounds and familial strife. During a dreamlike confrontation with her fears, Elizabeth rejects her unfaithful ex-husband Charles and asserts her independence from Polly. Realizing she no longer requires Fred’s presence, she bids him farewell.

Empowered upon awakening, Elizabeth ends ties with Charles and mends her relationship with Polly. The story concludes with Elizabeth visiting Mickey’s daughter Natalie, who now has Fred as her imaginary friend, suggesting the cycle continues.

Production

The roles of director and Fred were initially offered to Tim Burton and Robin Williams respectively; however, both declined the opportunity.

During pre-production, director Ate de Jong and producer Paul Webster undertook significant rewrites of the screenplay. De Jong incorporated elements inspired by personal childhood trauma related to abuse into the film’s themes, though this background was not openly discussed during filming.

Principal photography took place in August and September 1990, predominantly in Minneapolis, with key scenes filmed at Prince’s Paisley Park Studios located in Chanhassen.

Box office

With a production budget just under $6.8 million, the film premiered across the United States and Canada on May 24, 1991. It generated $3.6 million during its opening weekend and amassed $13.9 million domestically. Worldwide earnings totaled approximately $24 million, including £1.79 million from the UK market.

Critical response

Critics largely condemned Drop Dead Fred for its juvenile approach to complex subject matter. It received low ratings on various review platforms and was met with severe criticism from leading reviewers. Gene Siskel notably gave it zero stars, labeling it among the worst films he had encountered. While the concept intrigued some, many reviewers found the execution lacking and drew parallels between the storyline and psychological conditions such as dissociative identity disorder.

Subsequent evaluations have continued to highlight the film’s deficient humor and mishandling of serious themes. Nevertheless, it has attained cult status within select audiences despite ongoing recognition of its internal inconsistencies. In 2021, critic Alexander Larman described it as a "sophisticated and ahead-of-its-time black comic exploration of anxiety and depression."

Legacy

In the late 2000s and early 2010s, Universal had intentions to produce a Drop Dead Fred remake, with comedian Russell Brand slated to star, supported by screenwriter Dennis McNicholas and producer Marc Platt. Nevertheless, the project was quietly shelved after the unfavorable response to Arthur, another remake featuring Brand.

Drop Dead Fred frequently surfaces as a subject on the podcast How Did This Get Made?. Co-hosts June Diane Raphael and Jason Mantzoukas tend to share favorable opinions, whereas co-host Paul Scheer and guest Casey Wilson have expressed more critical viewpoints.

Prior to the release of the 2024 fantasy movie IF, directed by and starring John Krasinski, parallels were drawn between it and Drop Dead Fred due to their analogous storylines. Krasinski acknowledged his awareness of and admiration for Drop Dead Fred, but denied that it served as a direct influence.

External links