Eckwersheim derailment
| Industry | Rail transport |
|---|---|
| Founded | 1938 |
| Headquarters | France |
Key people | Guillaume Pepy (President at time of accident) |
| Products | High-speed rail services (TGV) |
| Website | www |
On 14 November 2015, a TGV train experienced a derailment in Eckwersheim, Alsace, France, during commissioning runs on the second segment of the LGV Est high-speed railway, which was scheduled to commence commercial operations five months later. This incident resulted in 11 fatalities and 42 injuries, representing the first deadly accident in TGV history and the most severe French rail disaster since the 1988 Gare de Lyon rail accident.
The test train was moving eastward along the southern track when it entered a curve at a speed exceeding the permitted limit. This caused the rear bogie of the leading locomotive to derail outward due to centrifugal force. The locomotive separated from the train and collided with a concrete barrier on a bridge over the Marne–Rhine Canal, subsequently overturning and sliding down an embankment approximately beyond the bridge. Cars two through seven derailed before reaching the bridge and went beyond the canal by , while cars eight and nine came to rest on the canal’s eastern bank; the rear locomotive was partially submerged in water.
The investigation pinpointed delayed braking that led to excessive velocity as the immediate cause of the accident. In response, the national rail company SNCF halted all high-speed test runs until investigations concluded. The commercial launch of LGV Est’s second phase was postponed by three months, moving from April to July 2016, to implement enhanced safety measures.
Background
The LGV Est européenne (LGV Est) is a high-speed rail corridor linking Paris with Strasbourg, developed through two construction phases. The initial phase, connecting Vaires-sur-Marne near Paris to Baudrecourt, opened on 10 June 2007. Work on the second phase, spanning 106 km from Baudrecourt to Vendenheim close to Strasbourg, commenced in 2010. The final rail weld for this segment was completed in March 2015, signaling structural completion despite some finishing tasks remaining. Commercial operations were originally planned to begin on 3 April 2016 following commissioning and operator training.
Testing activities on this line were organized into four stages:
- Component factory testing (2013–14);
- On-site subsystem and component testing (2013–14);
- Static tests with slow-moving trains (late 2014 through August 2015);
- Dynamic high-speed trials starting September 2015, aimed for completion by November 2015.
A dedicated test train, the Dasye set number 744 adorned with commemorative livery, initiated dynamic trials on 28 September 2015. More than 200 test runs assessed ride quality, overhead line performance, radio communication, and signalling functionality. Certain runs were conducted at speeds up to 10% above planned operational limits, with some automated safety features temporarily disabled to permit higher speeds. Operator training sessions were slated for January to March 2016 ahead of the initially scheduled April launch. In January 2016, SNCF announced a postponement of the line’s opening date to 3 July 2016.
Departure
Tests on both tracks and directions at speeds exceeding commercial limits by 10% were planned for 11 and 14 November. On 14 November, the test train was set to depart from Meuse TGV Station at 14:18 and arrive at Strasbourg Station by 15:17. Clearance was granted at 14:26, with departure occurring two minutes later. The train proceeded eastbound on Track 2—the LGV Est’s southern track—running opposite to usual traffic flow (which is Strasbourg to Paris). This run formed part of the line’s final testing phase.
The train attained a peak speed of , surpassing the limit of . As it neared the flying junction close to Vendenheim, it was required to decelerate from before KP 403.809 where the speed restriction was . This section featured a right-hand curve atop an embankment approximately high crossing over the Marne–Rhine Canal. The flying junction signified the termination point of LGV Est; beyond here, trains continued along conventional tracks toward Strasbourg Station.
Derailment
At 15:04:42, as the train negotiated the right-hand bend entering the flying junction at KP 404.003, the rear bogie of the leading power car derailed to the left.[1] This caused violent lateral forces that led to the separation of the lead power car.[1] Its rear section collided with a concrete bridge parapet (KP 404.209) located on the abutment over the Marne–Rhine Canal.[1] The collision fragmented the lead power car, causing oil from its transformer to ignite and spread flames across the bridge and adjacent canal banks. The rear bogie remained lodged at the parapet impact site; meanwhile, the transformer fell onto the canal’s east bank, and the remaining debris slid off and overturned beyond the bridge.[1]
Cars numbered 2 through 7 derailed before reaching the bridge, overshooting the canal and coming to rest beyond its start point.[1] Cars 8 and 9 stopped on the canal’s east bank, while the rear power car was partially submerged in water.[1]
Response and casualties
At 15:05, signalling control lost contact with the train near Vendenheim junction.[1] Emergency protocols were activated by 15:10, leading to closure of non-high-speed lines passing through Vendenheim.[1] Shortly thereafter, a construction company involved in line works was alerted by an employee aboard the train.[1] The local mass casualty plan was implemented before 17:45.<ref> Emergency responders, including around 100 gendarmes from Bas-Rhin, Moselle, and Haut-Rhin departments, deployed up to 104 fire engines.[2] Minor injuries were treated by French Red Cross personnel at Eckwersheim school.<ref> Shortly after, French Ministers Ségolène Royal and Alain Vidalies visited the scene along with SNCF president Guillaume Pepy and SNCF Réseau president Jacques Rapoport.[3]
The train carried a total of 53 individuals, which included four unauthorized children aged between 10 and 15 years.[4] The derailment resulted in 11 fatalities: four SNCF employees, five technicians from engineering firm Systra, and two guests.<ref> Ten victims died instantly; one succumbed later. As of February 2016, one seriously injured person remained hospitalized.[5] Among those killed was SNCF Réseau’s LGV Est line director.<ref> Despite extensive damage to the lead power car, none of its seven occupants perished. The penultimate car sustained most fatalities after striking the canal wall.[6] This incident marked TGV’s first fatal derailment since commercial operations started in 1981 and its third derailment overall.[7]
Investigation
Three separate inquiries were initiated following the accident. The French Land Transport Accident Investigation Bureau (BEA-TT), responsible for rail accident investigations in France, commenced a technical non-judicial investigation and released its final report in March 2017.
SNCF launched both a criminal probe and an internal review focusing on whether employee negligence allowed unauthorized children aboard the test train. SNCF’s president stressed that test trains operate under strict regulations prohibiting such practices. Given that this derailment occurred shortly after the November 2015 Paris attacks, initial concerns about terrorism were investigated.
On 19 November, SNCF disclosed that the train entered the curve at a speed of 265 km/h and derailed while traveling at 243 km/h—exceeding the permitted speed by 67 km/h. The primary cause was identified as delayed braking, which should have commenced at least one kilometer or twelve seconds earlier. Investigations cleared infrastructure, train condition, and technical staff of any faults. Seven individuals were present in the driving cab during the incident; this may have contributed to delayed braking response.
Following these findings, SNCF initiated disciplinary measures against employees for multiple breaches including permitting children onboard, overcrowding in the cab area, inadequate passenger list management, insufficient access control procedures, and operational human errors.
Aftermath
On 16 November, SNCF held a moment of silence to honor those affected by the tragedy, followed by a commemorative ceremony in Mundolsheim attended by SNCF President Guillaume Pepy. In response, all high-speed test runs were halted until safety procedures could be revised based on the investigation’s conclusions. To mark the first anniversary of the incident, a memorial garden and plaque were established at the location of the derailment.
The commercial rollout of the LGV Est’s second phase was delayed by three months, shifting from 3 April to 3 July 2016. Additionally, a section near the derailment site remained limited to single-track operation until repairs were finalized on 11 December 2016.
See also
- List of TGV accidents
- Salisbury rail crash (1906), involving a LSWR boat train traveling from Plymouth Friary railway station to London Waterloo station that failed to negotiate a sharp curve at Salisbury station in England.
- Amagasaki rail crash (2005), a derailment caused by excessive speed on a curve involving a suburban train in Japan.
- Santiago de Compostela derailment (2013), a deadly high-speed train accident in Spain attributed to overspeeding on a curve.
- Ingenheim derailment - TGV derailment occurring in Bas-Rhin
External links
- Eckwersheim derailment – Official SNCF information regarding the accident
- Website of the victims' families
- Eckwersheim English summary – Report from the French Land Transport Accident Investigation Bureau
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; no text was provided for refs namedSNCF report 19 Nov - ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; no text was provided for refs namedDNA: Response - ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; no text was provided for refs namedL'Alsace: Initial report - ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; no text was provided for refs namedL'ER: Children - ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; no text was provided for refs namedBEATT Feb 2016 - ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; no text was provided for refs namedDNA: Cause was late braking - ↑ Cite error: Invalid
<ref>tag; no text was provided for refs namedLe Figaro: First fatal TGV accident