Jump to content

Erie Railroad

From Alfawiki
Erie Railroad
Company typeRailroad
IndustryRail transport
FoundedApril 24, 1832; 194 years ago (1832-04-24)
DefunctOctober 17, 1960 (1960-10-17)
FateMerged with Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad to form Erie Lackawanna Railway
Headquarters
New York City (1832–1931), Cleveland (1931–1960)
,
United States
Area served
Northeastern United States (New Jersey, Pennsylvania, New York, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois)
Key people
Frederick D. Underwood (president 1910), John Joseph Bernet (president 1927–1929)
ProductsPassenger and freight rail services

Erie Railroad

The Erie Railroad (reporting mark: ERIE) was a prominent rail carrier in the Northeastern United States, originally connecting Pavonia Terminal in Jersey City, New Jersey, to Dunkirk, New York, on Lake Erie. Its network extended westward to Chicago following the 1865 merger with the Atlantic and Great Western Railroad, also known as the New York, Pennsylvania and Ohio Railroad.

Erie's principal route played a vital role in fostering economic development throughout New York's Southern Tier, linking important urban centers such as Binghamton, Elmira, and Hornell. Hornell housed the railroad’s main repair facilities and served as the junction where the mainline diverged toward Buffalo and Chicago. This location was a significant employment center and operational focal point for the Erie system.

On October 17, 1960, the Erie merged with its competitor, the Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad, creating the Erie Lackawanna Railway. The Hornell repair shops were shuttered in 1976 when Conrail assumed control and centralized maintenance operations in Scranton, Pennsylvania. Although Hurricane Agnes caused extensive damage to the Hornell-Binghamton corridor in 1972, restoration efforts reinstated this critical segment, which today forms part of Norfolk Southern Railway’s Southern Tier mainline. Remaining Erie Lackawanna assets were incorporated into Conrail during 1976. By 1983, segments of the former Erie Railroad had been absorbed into New Jersey Transit services, with most surviving lines operated by Norfolk Southern Railway.

The company's headquarters were initially established in New York City from 1832 until 1931 before relocating to Cleveland, Ohio, where they remained until 1960. Erie's strategic growth through mergers and expansions established its competitive position and operational footprint across several states including New Jersey, Pennsylvania, New York, Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois.

New York and Erie Railroad: 1832–1861

The New York and Erie Rail Road was chartered on April 24, 1832, by New York Governor Enos T. Throop with the objective of linking the Hudson River at Piermont to Lake Erie at Dunkirk. Authorized in 1841 to extend into northeastern Pennsylvania, construction commenced in 1836 and progressed incrementally until reaching Dunkirk on May 19, 1851. From Dunkirk, steamboat connections facilitated travel across Lake Erie to Detroit, Michigan. The route traversed the Kittatinny Mountains at an elevation of 870 feet.

The railroad’s completion was celebrated with a special excursion that included President Millard Fillmore and members of his cabinet such as Secretary of State Daniel Webster, who notably traveled comfortably aboard a flatcar. The line was constructed using a broad gauge track width selected for its enhanced stability compared to the standard gauge.

In 1848, the company erected the Starrucca Viaduct in Lanesboro, Pennsylvania, a stone arch bridge that remains operational today. In 2021, its current owner invested $3.2 million for track alignment improvements, ballast replacement, and masonry restoration. The viaduct spans , rises to a height of , and is recognized as Pennsylvania’s oldest stone railroad bridge still in active use.

Critical maintenance facilities supported railroad operations: initial shops opened in Susquehanna, Pennsylvania in 1848 and expanded by 1863 to employ approximately 700 workers; car repair shops located in Meadville, Pennsylvania employed around 3,500 personnel by 1912. By the late 1920s, Hornell’s shops had become Erie’s largest maintenance complex, servicing roughly 350 locomotives annually with major overhauls.

Erie Railway: 1861–1878

In August 1859, financial difficulties from excessive construction expenses forced the company into receivership, leading to its reorganization on June 25, 1861, as the Erie Railway. This event marked the first significant bankruptcy of a major U.S. trunk line.

Throughout the 1860s Erie War, key financiers such as Cornelius Vanderbilt, Daniel Drew, James Fisk, and Jay Gould competed for control of the railroad. Ultimately, Gould emerged victorious but stepped down in 1872–73 following public outrage linked to the 1869 gold market scandal and financial losses caused by British swindler Lord Gordon-Gordon. Investors became increasingly cautious due to Gould’s contentious financial battles with Vanderbilt, which resulted in stock price instability and operational setbacks. Upon his exit, Gould asserted that the railroad owed him $4 million.

In 1869, Erie shifted its primary workshops from Dunkirk to Buffalo. The Dunkirk site was leased to Horatio G. Brooks, former chief engineer of NY&E, who established Brooks Locomotive Works. This independent company operated until its 1901 merger with the ALCO. ALCO continued locomotive production at the Buffalo plant until 1934, with the facility closing in 1962.

To reduce expensive cargo transfers between broad and standard gauge tracks, Erie introduced dual-gauge rolling stock beginning in 1871. This innovation allowed truck exchanges—including passenger and freight connections to St. Louis, Missouri—using a Nutter car hoist located in Urbana, Ohio. By 1876, due to high interchange expenses, Erie commenced converting its lines to standard gauge. By 1878, a third rail was laid along the main route from Buffalo to Jersey City. These costly gauge conversion efforts contributed significantly to another bankruptcy.

New York, Lake Erie and Western Railroad: 1878–1895

Following ongoing financial losses, Erie was sold through bankruptcy reorganization in 1878 and renamed the New York, Lake Erie and Western Railroad. The railroad completed its transition to standard gauge by June 22, 1880.

In 1886, Erie collaborated with the Philadelphia and Reading Railway to operate ferry services connecting their Jersey City terminals, including Pavonia Terminal and Brooklyn's Fulton Ferry. The opening of a new bridge over the Hackensack River in 1889 further improved terminal accessibility.

Erie Railroad: 1895–1960

After entering bankruptcy again by 1893, the company reemerged in 1895 as the Erie Railroad with financial support from J. P. Morgan. In 1898, Morgan orchestrated Erie’s acquisition of the New York, Susquehanna and Western Railroad (NYS&W), providing access to anthracite coal mines south of Scranton, Pennsylvania and enhancing competition against the Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad (DL&W).

George W. Perkins appointed Frederick D. Underwood as president in 1910. During the eastern railroad strike of 1913, Underwood maintained direct operational oversight amid wage conflicts, emphasizing management autonomy separate from financiers like J.P. Morgan.

In the mid-1920s, control passed to Cleveland’s Van Sweringen brothers who installed John Joseph Bernet as president (1927–1929). Bernet implemented restructuring and cost-reduction strategies that improved both efficiency and financial health. He modernized equipment by introducing standardized assets including Erie's signature 2-8-4 "Berkshire" steam locomotives.

Though Erie remained independent through much of the Great Depression until declaring bankruptcy in 1938, it reorganized by acquiring the Cleveland and Mahoning Valley Railroad to cut costs. The NYS&W separated during its own bankruptcy in 1940; however, Erie retained ownership of the Susquehanna Connecting Railroad. After reorganization, Erie resumed paying dividends.

In 1948, Erie began operations at Cleveland Union Terminal near Terminal Tower and acquired stakes in Niagara Junction Railway alongside New York Central and Lehigh Valley railroads. By March 1954, Erie's locomotive fleet was fully dieselized; later that year it introduced trailer-on-flatcar (TOFC) freight services.

Although profitable through the mid-1950s, earnings dropped sharply between 1956 and 1957 and deficits followed during 1958–59. These financial pressures initiated merger negotiations with DL&W aimed at consolidating operations and eliminating duplicate facilities in Binghamton and Elmira. Passenger services transitioned from Pavonia Terminal to DL&W’s Hoboken Terminal between 1956–57; by 1958 DL&W had abandoned much of its Binghamton-Elmira mainline in favor of Erie's parallel route.

On October 17, 1960, Erie merged with DL&W forming the Erie Lackawanna Railway. This entity operated for sixteen years before declining finances led to absorption into Conrail in 1976. Tracks formerly belonging to Erie between Hornell and Binghamton suffered damage from Hurricane Agnes in 1972. Conrail subsequently closed Erie’s Hornell repair shops, consolidating maintenance at DL&W’s Scranton facility.

Lines operated

Railroad Branch From To Approx. Mileage Years Erie-Operated Notes
Erie Railroad Original Main Line Piermont Dunkirk 448 miles (721 km) 1841 - 1960 Construction started in 1836; the segment from Piermont to Goshen opened in 1841. Extended westward to Dunkirk by 1851, linking with Lake Erie steamboats bound for Detroit, Michigan.
Newburgh Branch Main Line at Greycourt near Chester Newburgh 18.6 miles (29.9 km) 1850 - 1960 (Except five miles at east end) Established to serve the port city of Newburgh, NY, historically a coal shipping center. Currently mostly abandoned aside from a short industrial spur.
Newburgh and New York Railroad (Newburgh Shortcut) Newburgh Junction, near Harriman Newburgh Branch at Vails Gate 12.7 miles (20.4 km) 1869 - 1936 "Shortcut" line offered a more direct connection between Newburgh and the southern mainline. Its use declined with the downturn of coal traffic; segments remain active today as part of Metro North's Port Jervis line and various industrial spurs.
Graham Line Newburgh Junction, near Harriman Otisville 42.3 miles (68.1 km) 1909 - 1960 Built as a freight bypass to circumvent steep grades and numerous grade crossings on the original mainline; includes engineering feats such as the Moodna Viaduct and Otisville Tunnel. Currently incorporated into Metro-North's Port Jervis Line.
Paterson and Ramapo Railroad New Jersey Line New York Line at Mahwah Paterson 14.5 miles (23.3 km) 1852 - 1960 Initially opened independently in 1848; became part of Erie operations by 1853 following third rail gauge conversion.
New York Line: Union Railroad New Jersey Line at Suffern Main Line in Suffern 0.82 miles (1.32 km)
Paterson and Hudson River Railroad Paterson, New Jersey Jersey City, New Jersey 15.7 miles (25.3 km) 1852 - 1960 Operated independently since 1833; Erie began service to the Jersey City terminal after installing broad gauge third rail in 1853.
Buffalo and New York City Railroad Hornellsville, New York Buffalo, New York 92.3 miles (148.5 km) (Leased 1852–1857; owned 1857–1859) 'Buffalo and New York City' line provided Erie with access to Buffalo, offering a superior terminal compared to Dunkirk. Sold following Erie's bankruptcy.

A map from 1960 shows Erie’s control over former Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati and Indianapolis Railway routes as well as portions of the New York Central near Williamsport, Pennsylvania.

Passenger service

The Erie Railroad operated a variety of named passenger trains; however, none achieved the same level of fame as competitors like the Pennsylvania Railroad's Broadway Limited or the New York Central Railroad's 20th Century Limited. Among its notable trains were the Erie Limited, Lake Cities, Atlantic Express, Pacific Express, Midlander, Southern Tier Express, and Mountain Express. Most of these services ended in Chicago except for the Mountain Express, which terminated in Hornell, New York.

Erie maintained a comprehensive commuter rail system in northern New Jersey and the southern region of the Hudson Valley, New York. Following the consolidation into Erie Lackawanna and later integration into Conrail in 1976, these lines became part of NJ Transit's Hoboken Division for New Jersey routes and Metro-North Railroad for those in the Hudson Valley.

In addition, Erie operated an electrified commuter line serving its Rochester, New York terminal—one of its few electrified stations. The company was an early pioneer in electric commuter rail service, initiating it in 1907.

Company Leadership

Heritage Unit

In honor of the 30th anniversary of the Norfolk Southern Railway, twenty newly built locomotives were painted in the color schemes of predecessor railroads. Among these, NS #1068, an EMD SD70ACe, showcased the Erie Railroad’s traditional green passenger livery and was revealed on May 25, 2012.

To celebrate the 40th anniversary of NJ Transit Rail Operations, in October 2023, locomotive EMD GP40PH-2B No. 4210 was adorned with the Erie Railroad’s distinctive black-and-yellow paint scheme.

See also

Further reading

  • Ackerman, Kenneth D., The Gold Ring: Jim Fisk, Jay Gould, and Black Friday, 1869 (2011)
  • Halstead, Murat, Life of Jay Gould: How He Made His Millions (1892)
  • Meyer, B.H. & MacGill, Caroline E., History of Transportation in the United States before 1860 (1917)
  • Mott, Edward Harold, Between the Ocean and the Lakes: The Story of Erie (1908)
  • Reynolds, William; Gifford, Peter K.; Ilisevich, Robert D., European Capital, British Iron, and an American Dream: The Story of the Atlantic & Great Western Railroad (2002)
  • Starr, Timothy, The Back Shop Illustrated, Volume 1: Northeast and New England Regions (2022)

Primary sources

  • Daniel C. McCallum, "Superintendent's report: 1856" in Classics of Organization Theory (2015)
  • Digitized issues of Erie and Lackawanna employee magazines at elmags.railfan.net
  • Mott, E. H., The Erie route: a guide to the New York, Lake Erie & Western Railway and its branches (1882)
  • Erie Railway Tourist, 1874 – promotional publication outlining the Erie Railway’s routes and amenities

External links

Retrieved from "https://www.alfawiki.org/index.php?title=Erie_Railroad&oldid=7486"