Muddy Waters Research
| File:MuddyWaters Logo.jpg | |
| Muddy Waters Capital LLC | |
| Company type | Private |
| Industry | Investment management |
| Headquarters | San Francisco, California, United States |
Key people |
|
| AUM | $227 Million |
Number of employees | 7+ |
| Website | www |
Muddy Waters Research LLC is a US-based private investment firm specializing in due diligence research, established by Carson Block. The company conducts in-depth investigations into publicly traded firms and aligns its investment decisions with the insights gained. Its work has revealed financial misstatements and fraudulent activities mainly within Chinese enterprises, but also in companies throughout Asia, Europe, and North America.
The firm is widely recognized for exposing deceptive practices at Sino-Forest Corp, a Chinese company listed in Canada, whose share price collapsed by 74% before it sought bankruptcy protection in March 2012.
History
American short-seller Carson Block founded Muddy Waters, drawing its name from the Chinese saying "muddy waters makes it easy to catch fish" (). In January 2015, the firm secured an initial capital raise of $100 million to advance its investment approach.
Analysis of Sino-Forest
Muddy Waters rose to prominence in 2011 when it published a detailed report accusing Sino-Forest Corp of artificially inflating its asset values and earnings, effectively rendering its stock worthless. The firm described Sino-Forest as a "multi-billion dollar ponzi scheme". After the report's release, the company's shares plummeted by 82%, leading investor John Paulson to divest his entire holding at a loss amounting to $720 million. Sino-Forest refuted these claims and commissioned an independent inquiry led by PricewaterhouseCoopers. Ultimately, on March 30, 2012, Sino-Forest filed for bankruptcy protection under Canada's Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act.
Link Motion Inc (NQ Mobile)
On October 24, 2013, Muddy Waters published a report targeting NQ Mobile, a Chinese company specializing in cybersecurity and mobile applications, accusing it of having "fabricated" clients and revenue figures. Following this, in April 2015, co-CEO Omar Khan stepped down after the company’s stock value had fallen by nearly 84%.
Other
Block has also directed scrutiny towards various corporations such as American Tower Corp., Noble Group, Focus Media, Olam International, Groupo Casino, Orient Paper, China Media Express, Bank of the Ozarks, Rino International, Bolloré, and TeliaSonera.
In April 2016, Muddy Waters accused the German MDAX-listed advertising company Ströer SE & Co. KGaA of breaching IFRS accounting guidelines and inflating its digital organic growth figures. The company’s shares dropped by 25% within 45 minutes following Muddy Waters’ televised presentation. Subsequently, German authorities launched an investigation into Muddy Waters over potential market manipulation and failure to disclose a short position exceeding 0.5% in a timely manner. Since June 2017, prosecutors in Frankfurt have been actively pursuing this matter.
In August 2016, Muddy Waters disclosed cybersecurity flaws in pacemakers and implantable devices produced by St. Jude Medical. St. Jude Medical refuted these allegations and filed a defamation lawsuit. Nevertheless, in January 2017, both the U.S. FDA and Department of Homeland Security validated the existence of these security vulnerabilities.
Block characterizes his investigative method as piecing together a puzzle to uncover what companies are genuinely engaged in.
He regularly appears on Bloomberg Television, CNBC, and BBC, and has penned opinion pieces on corporate governance and market transparency for publications including the Wall Street Journal, Financial Times, and The New York Times.
On June 29, 2017, Muddy Waters took a short position against biotech firm Prothena Corp PLC, challenging the commercial prospects of its primary product.
In August 2019, Muddy Waters initiated a short on Burford Capital, criticizing its fair value accounting methods. Later that December, it revealed a short position in NMC Health.
In January 2020, Muddy Waters accused Luckin Coffee of falsifying sales and expense figures while insiders liquidated shares; the company later admitted to significant fraud in April, which led to a stock collapse exceeding 70%.
In May 2020, Muddy Waters established a short position in GSX Techedu Inc. (GSX US).
By November 2020, it announced a short on JOYY Inc (NASDAQ: YY).
In March 2021, Muddy Waters disclosed holding a short position in XL Fleet Corp (NYSE: XL US).
On July 12, 2022, Muddy Waters revealed a short on Hannon Armstrong Sustainable Infrastructure Capital (NYSE:HASI US), citing "complex and misleading" accounting practices that rendered financial reports essentially meaningless.
In November 2022, it declared a short position on DLocal Ltd (DLO US).
Most recently in June 2024, Muddy Waters disclosed a short position against Eurofins Scientific.
See also
- Hindenburg Research
- Citron Research
- James Chanos
- Short selling
- Sino-Forest
- Olam International
- The Big Short