Jump to content

Tell Your Children: The Truth About Marijuana, Mental Illness and Violence

From Alfawiki
Adapted from the English Wikipedia article Tell Your Children: The Truth About Marijuana, Mental Illness and Violence, available under CC BY-SA 4.0Updated 29 November 2025
Tell Your Children: The Truth About Marijuana, Mental Illness and Violence
Company typePublication
IndustryPublishing
Founded2019
FounderAlex Berenson
ProductsBook

Tell Your Children: The Truth About Marijuana, Mental Illness and Violence is a 2019 publication authored by Alex Berenson. In this work, Berenson asserts a direct causal relationship between cannabis consumption and the onset of psychosis as well as violent behavior—claims that have been broadly rejected by the scientific and medical communities as alarmist and unsupported by evidence. Specialists contend that Berenson improperly equates correlation with causation, neglecting the multifaceted nature of these issues. For instance, while marijuana usage has risen since the early 1990s, rates of violent crime have notably declined. Scholars emphasize that cannabis use is not a driver of violent offenses and criticize Berenson’s dependence on limited datasets from states such as Washington and Colorado.

Critiques highlight that although psychosis appears more frequently among cannabis users, other substances—including tobacco and opioids—are also linked to psychotic symptoms, complicating any straightforward causal inferences. Numerous experts stress the critical distinction between correlation and causation, cautioning against oversimplified interpretations. Moreover, the overwhelming majority of individuals who consume marijuana do not experience psychosis or engage in violence, thereby challenging Berenson's sweeping conclusions.

Berenson faces accusations of selectively citing studies to bolster his viewpoint and demonstrating selection bias through anecdotal storytelling. For example, he recounts a homicide involving a THC-infused edible but omits significant contextual details such as the victim’s pre-existing fears and marital difficulties. These methodological shortcomings undermine the strength of his arguments.

Beyond scientific objections, many academics argue that Berenson’s focus neglects the detrimental effects of marijuana prohibition while exaggerating the drug’s dangers. A coalition of 75 healthcare professionals characterized the book as alarmist fear-mongering grounded in a misinterpretation of scientific data. Despite ongoing concerns about cannabis-related public safety issues, experts maintain that Tell Your Children favors sensationalism over thorough analysis, impeding constructive policy dialogue.

The book’s title Tell Your Children was originally associated with Reefer Madness, a 1936 propaganda film notorious for its overstated anti-cannabis messaging. Berenson has acknowledged his intentional choice of this title, anticipating criticism but choosing to engage controversy directly.

Criticism

In January 2019, Alex Berenson released a book alongside opinion pieces in The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times, asserting that cannabis use leads to psychosis and violence, referencing increases in violent crime within states legalizing recreational marijuana. Nevertheless, his interpretation of scientific findings has faced widespread rebuke from researchers and medical authorities as alarmist and based on flawed readings. An open letter signed by over 100 scholars and clinicians from institutions including Columbia University, Harvard Medical School, and NYU challenged Berenson's assertions, pointing out problems such as conflating correlation with causation, selective data usage, confirmation bias, and overlooking how marijuana enforcement disproportionately affects communities of color despite comparable usage rates across racial groups.

Berenson dismissed this letter, contending it lacked sufficient medical doctor endorsements to substantiate its critique. Ziva Cooper, a UCLA cannabis researcher involved in a pivotal study cited by Berenson, clarified that their findings showed correlations rather than causative links between cannabis use and schizophrenia. She further noted that genetic predispositions likely influence both cannabis consumption and schizophrenia risk, adding that cannabidiol (CBD) might alleviate symptoms of schizophrenia.

Psychologists Carl Hart (Columbia University) and Charles Ksir (University of Wyoming) criticized Berenson for mistaking association for causation and ignoring similar links between psychosis and substances like tobacco or opioids. They described his arguments as misinformed and irresponsible, emphasizing that exaggerated claims about marijuana’s harms should not influence serious public policy debates. Yasmin Hurd of Mount Sinai stated there is no evidence connecting marijuana legalization to higher homicide rates and rejected mental illness as an explanation for such crimes.

Additional criticism points to Berenson’s misunderstanding regarding cannabis products; he inaccurately describes CBD as non-psychoactive despite its FDA-approved medicinal applications. He conflates medical marijuana—which typically contains low THC levels—with recreational products high in THC. Furthermore, Berenson overlooks cannabis’s federal Schedule I status in the U.S., which limits research opportunities despite his implication that American scientists lack interest.

A Rolling Stone article acknowledged Berenson’s observation that marijuana industry players sometimes manipulate research but also noted his own financial motivations to sensationalize claims. Despite extensive criticism, Berenson persists in asserting "Cannabis causes psychosis causes violence," frequently sharing anecdotal accounts on social media linking cannabis use to criminal acts.

See also

References