The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (film)
| Company type | Film |
|---|---|
| Industry | Motion picture |
| Founded | 2018 |
| Founder | Mike Newell (director), Kevin Hood, Don Roos, Tom Bezucha (screenwriters) |
| Headquarters | United Kingdom / United States / France |
| Products | Historical romantic drama film |
| Parent | StudioCanal, Blueprint Pictures, Mazur/Kaplan Company |
The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society is a historical romantic drama film from 2018, directed by Mike Newell and scripted by Kevin Hood, Don Roos, and Tom Bezucha. It is adapted from the 2008 novel authored by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows.
The cast features Lily James, Michiel Huisman, Glen Powell, Jessica Brown Findlay, Katherine Parkinson, Matthew Goode, Tom Courtenay, and Penelope Wilton. Set in the year 1946, the narrative centers on a London-based writer who begins exchanging correspondence with a Guernsey islander, where German forces had occupied during World War II.
A collaborative production involving the UK, US, and France, the movie was funded and distributed by StudioCanal, with production handled by Blueprint Pictures alongside the Mazur/Kaplan Company. The project entered development in 2010, with Lily James joining the cast in October 2016 and Mike Newell taking on directing duties. Filming took place throughout England between March and May of 2017.
The film premiered in UK theaters in April 2018, followed by its French release in June 2018. It earned $15.7 million globally and garnered predominantly favorable critical reception. Netflix secured international distribution rights, launching it as one of their original films on 10 August 2018.
Plot
During 1941 on the island of Guernsey, four friends narrowly avoid arrest by explaining they were returning from a book club meeting they had quickly named "The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society" amid the German occupation.
Fast forward five years to January 1946 in London: Juliet Ashton, an author promoting her latest work under the pseudonym Izzy Bickerstaff, is commissioned by publisher Sidney Stark to write an article for The Times Literary Supplement about literature’s positive impact. She receives a letter from Dawsey Adams of Guernsey, who has her copy of Charles Lamb’s Essays of Elia and wants to know where to find additional books. Dawsey mentions his involvement with the Society, which regularly convenes. Juliet sends books to him in exchange for information about the group’s history.
Intrigued, Juliet decides to visit Guernsey to write about the Society despite Sidney’s reservations. Before she leaves, her American boyfriend Mark proposes marriage, which she accepts. Upon arrival, Juliet is greeted by members Dawsey Adams, Amelia Maugery, Isola Pribbey, Eben Ramsey, and his grandson Eli. Elizabeth—the Society’s founder—is away abroad; her daughter Kit is cared for by Dawsey, whom she calls “dad.” Juliet seeks permission to document the Society’s story but encounters opposition from Amelia.
Opting to extend her stay, Juliet investigates the German occupation period and discovers Elizabeth was detained and transported to Germany. The members remain hopeful for her return. Juliet asks Mark to help find Elizabeth; meanwhile, her landlady suggests Elizabeth may have collaborated with German forces for personal benefits.
Dawsey reveals he is not Kit’s biological father; Kit’s real father was Christian Hellmann, a German physician who died when his ship was sunk after being sent back to Germany. Mark arrives with news that Elizabeth was sent to Ravensbrück concentration camp and died while protecting another inmate.
Back in London, Juliet ends her relationship with Mark and begins writing about the Society. She shares the manuscript with Sidney and sends a copy to the group on Guernsey. Dawsey reads her letter aloud before deciding to visit her in London. Juliet plans another trip to Guernsey; they reunite at the ferry terminal and become engaged.
Later on, Dawsey reads Tales from Shakespeare aloud to Kit with Juliet at his side. The Society continues its gatherings—now including Sidney—with ongoing exchanges of books and lively discussions.
Development
In July 2010, producer Paula Mazur revealed that Fox 2000 Pictures had acquired the rights to adapt the 2008 novel The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society into a screenplay. Despite minimal financial benefits, Mazur was determined to shoot on location in Guernsey to maintain authenticity. Initial casting ideas featured Kate Winslet, Anne Hathaway, and Emily Blunt. On 4 August 2011, Kenneth Branagh was announced as director, with filming initially scheduled for March 2012.
By January 2012, Winslet was confirmed to portray Juliet Ashton; however, the project faced delays in April 2012 due to scheduling issues. By February 2013, both Winslet and Branagh had departed from the film. In February 2016, Mike Newell was named as the new director, and Rosamund Pike was considered for the lead role. Financing and distribution were taken over by StudioCanal. In October 2016, Lily James was officially cast as the lead, followed by the addition of Michiel Huisman and Glen Powell in March 2017. Pre-production commenced in January 2017, with principal photography planned for spring.
Filming
Principal photography started in March 2017 in North Devon. The coastal village of Clovelly served as a stand-in for Guernsey’s Saint Peter Port Harbour, with other nearby locations representing Guernsey circa 1946. Exterior scenes at Princes Wharf in Bristol depicted Weymouth Docks from the same period. London sequences were filmed on Sicilian Avenue, at the former House of Detention in Sans Walk, Clerkenwell, and inside the lobby of Senate House, London. Studio filming took place at Ealing Studios. Shooting concluded in May 2017, coinciding with the release of the first official images.
Release
The film debuted in April 2018 at London's Curzon Cinema in Mayfair and saw theatrical releases in the UK during April and France in June through StudioCanal. It became available internationally as a Netflix original film on 10 August 2018.
Critical response
On Rotten Tomatoes, the movie holds an approval rating based on reviews, with an average score reflecting positive feedback. The consensus calls it "a charming comfort watch for enthusiasts of period dramas." On Metacritic, it has a weighted average score of 65 out of 100 from ten critics, signifying "generally favorable reviews."
Harry Windsor from The Hollywood Reporter praised James's portrayal alongside the film’s contemporary sensibility, describing it as "a blend of classic romance and a detective narrative promoting gender equality." Trevor Johnston of Radio Times awarded three stars, commending the "engaging" cast especially highlighting Penelope Wilton. Geoffrey McNab from The Independent also gave three stars, calling it a "lively and good-natured production" with nostalgic charm.
On the other hand, Kevin Maher of The Times rated it one star, citing weak chemistry between James and Michiel Huisman. Guy Lodge from Variety found the mystery aspect uninspired. Olly Richards of Empire granted three stars, noting its soothing familiarity and gentle approach.
Robbie Collin of The Daily Telegraph gave four stars, describing it as an "irresistible romantic mystery," complimenting director Newell’s handling of the ensemble cast with special mention of Katherine Parkinson. Anna Smith from Metro also awarded four stars, praising performances by both Tom Courtenay and Parkinson but remarked that subplots felt crowded and the two-hour length somewhat excessive. Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian assigned two stars, labeling it "naive" and overly solemn. Wendy Ide from The Observer shared this view with two stars, calling it a "visually appealing but laborious adaptation" marked by uneven casting.
Paul Whitington of The Irish Independent took a more favorable stance with three stars, describing it as a "gentle and meandering drama." David Bradley from The Adelaide Review rated it 6 out of 10, likening it to a "Downton Abbey reunion" while applauding James for her embodiment of British charm.
External links
- 2018 films
- 2018 romantic drama films
- British romantic drama films
- Ealing Studios productions
- Films directed by Mike Newell
- Films produced by Graham Broadbent
- Films set in the year 1941
- Films set in the year 1946
- Films located in Guernsey
- Films filmed in Bristol
- Films filmed in Devon
- Films filmed in London
- Films shot across the United Kingdom
- Screenplays by Thomas Bezucha
- Screenplays by Don Roos
- StudioCanal productions
- British films about World War II
- Films adapted from American novels
- 2010s English-language films
- 2010s British cinema
- English-language romantic dramas
- StudioCanal films