Jump to content

The X Factor (Australian TV series) season 3

From Alfawiki
Adapted from the English Wikipedia article The X Factor (Australian TV series) season 3, available under CC BY-SA 4.0Updated 11 August 20258 sources
The X Factor Australia (Season 3)
Company typeReality television series
IndustryTelevision
FoundedAugust 29, 2011; 15 years ago (2011-08-29)
Headquarters
Australia
Area served
Australia
Key people
Luke Jacobz (host), Guy Sebastian, Ronan Keating, Natalie Bassingthwaighte, Mel B (judges)
ProductsTelevision program

The X Factor is an Australian reality television music contest adapted from the UK original, designed to uncover emerging vocal talent. The champion is awarded a management contract alongside a recording deal with Sony Music Australia. The third installment was broadcast on the Seven Network from 29 August until 22 November 2011. Reece Mastin emerged as the winner, launching his debut single "Good Night" immediately following the finale, becoming the first victor from the Boys category. Mastin’s mentor was Guy Sebastian, who achieved his inaugural mentor win. The final voting was exceptionally close, with Mastin securing victory by a mere one percent over runner-up Andrew Wishart. Hosting duties were handled by Luke Jacobz, while judges Ronan Keating and Sebastian returned from the previous season, joined by new panelists Natalie Bassingthwaighte and Mel B, who replaced Natalie Imbruglia and Kyle Sandilands respectively.

The series unfolded through stages including auditions, bootcamp, home visits, and live performance shows. Initial auditions took place in March and April 2011, followed by successful acts performing before judges and a live audience during May and June. At bootcamp, contestants were sorted into four groups: Boys, Girls, Over 25s, and Groups; each category was overseen by a judge who selected their teams with support from guest judges such as Wynter Gordon, Stephen Belafonte, Darren Hayes, and The Veronicas. The home visits further reduced the contestant pool with guest judge input from Beyoncé, Melanie C, Jason Derulo, Good Charlotte, and Leona Lewis. Live shows began airing on 19 September 2011.

Season 3 experienced some controversy when Mel B publicly criticized fellow judges for being dishonest and dull. Disagreements also arose between judge Sebastian and contestant Mitchell Callaway regarding Callaway’s attitude during performances. Additionally, conflicts were reported between Callaway and fellow contestant Declan Sykes. The grand finale drew an audience of 1.99 million viewers, making it the most-watched episode of that season.

Judges and Presenter

Mel B, Sebastian, Bassingthwaighte, and Keating all returned as judges in 2012.

On 16 March 2011, judge Kyle Sandilands announced his departure from season 3 due to the workload being too intense. Subsequently, on 31 March 2011, Natalie Bassingthwaighte was confirmed as his replacement on the judging panel, taking over from Natalie Imbruglia. Bassingthwaighte pledged to offer candid feedback and support contestants throughout their journey. Later in April 2011, Mel B was announced as Sandilands’ successor; she described her judging style as hardworking with a balance of firmness and approachability.

Returning judges from season 2 included Guy Sebastian and Ronan Keating exclusively.

Auditions

For the 2011 season, the minimum age for auditioning was lowered from 16 to 14 years old. Producer auditions commenced in March across five cities: Perth, Adelaide, Brisbane, Sydney, and Melbourne. Contestants who passed this stage were invited to perform in front of the judges and a live audience during final auditions held in Brisbane, Melbourne, and Sydney.

Bootcamp

Bootcamp took place in Sydney and was first broadcast on 7 September 2011. Each judge was assigned a category to mentor with assistance from celebrity guests to select their top twelve acts. Wynter Gordon supported Sebastian with the Boys; Stephen Belafonte assisted Mel B with the Girls; Darren Hayes worked alongside Bassingthwaighte for the Over 25s; and The Veronicas helped Keating guide the Groups.

During bootcamp challenges included: Boys singing songs originally performed by female artists; Over 25s engaging in styling exercises followed by solo performances; Girls learning choreography to Adele’s "Rolling in the Deep" or Lady Gaga’s "Born This Way"; Groups participating in studio recording sessions with vocal coach Erana Clark. Judges and their guests then trimmed each category down to six contestants.

The final group of 24 successful acts comprised:

  • Boys: Rob Baron, Trent Bell, Reece Mastin, Johnny Ruffo, Declan Sykes, Mali Talefenua
  • Girls: Tyla Bertolli, Sophie Metcalfe (who replaced Tara-Lynn Sharrock due to visa complications), Chantelle Morrell, Jacqui Newland, Christina Parie, Amy Walton
  • Over 25s: Mitchell Callaway, Pamela Cook, Marina Davis, Cleo Howman, Paige Phoenix, Andrew Wishart
  • Groups: Audio Vixen, Femme Da Funk, Hype (formerly Lazy J & Big Guy), Three Wishez, Up Front, Young Men Society

Home visits

The concluding phase before the live shows, known as the home visits (previously called "judges' houses"), involved each judge narrowing down their initial six contestants to just three. Each judge brought their acts to prestigious international destinations: Sebastian and his Boys traveled to New York City, accompanied by Beyoncé and her team; Mel B took her Girls to Hollywood, joined by Melanie C; Bassingthwaighte guided the Over 25s to Double Island, Queensland with support from Jason Derulo; and Keating brought the Groups to Los Angeles, assisted by Good Charlotte and Leona Lewis. Following these sessions, judges together with their celebrity collaborators chose their final three contestants.

Overview of judges' houses
Judge Category Location Celebrity Assistant Eliminated Contestants
Sebastian Boys New York City Beyoncé Rob Baron, Trent Bell, Mali Talefenua
Mel B Girls Hollywood Melanie C Sophie Metcalfe, Chantelle Morrell, Amy Walton
Bassingthwaighte Over 25s Double Island, Queensland Jason Derulo Pamela Cook, Marina Davis, Paige Phoenix
Keating Groups Los Angeles Good Charlotte
Leona Lewis
Femme Da Funk, Hype, Up Front

Contestants

Key:

– Champion
– Second place
Contestant Age(s) Hometown Category (Mentor) Outcome
Reece Mastin 16 Scunthorpe/Greenwith, South Australia Boys (Sebastian) Winner
Andrew Wishart 40 Seaford, Victoria Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) Runner-Up
Johnny Ruffo † 23 Balcatta, Western Australia Boys (Sebastian) 3rd Place
Three Wishez 18–23 Sydney Groups (Keating) 4th Place
Declan Sykes 15 Fitzroy, Victoria Boys (Sebastian) 5th Place
Christina Parie 15 Castle Hill, New South Wales Girls (Mel B) 6th Place
Mitchell Callaway 25 Bowraville, New South Wales Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 7th Place
Young Men Society 22–26 Sydney, New South Wales Groups (Keating) 8th Place
Audio Vixen 19–28 Sydney, New South Wales 9th Place
Jacqueline "Jacqui" Newland 23 Geelong, Victoria Girls (Mel B) 10th Place
Tyla Bertolli 19 Melbourne 11th Place
Cleopatra "Cleo" Howman 25 Gold Coast, Queensland "Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte)" "12th Place"

Results summary

Colour legend
Contestant from Boys  
Contestant from Girls  
Contestant from Over 25s  
Contestant from Groups  
– Bottom two and performed again in final showdown
– Eliminated immediately due to lowest public votes
– Received highest public votes
Contestant Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Week 5 Week 6 Week 7 Quarter-Final Semi-Final Final
Monday Vote Tuesday Vote
Reece Mastin "1st" "1st" "1st" "1st" "1st" "1st" "5th" "1st" "1st" "1st" "Winner"
Andrew Wishart "2nd" "2nd" "2nd" "2nd" "2nd" "2nd" "1st" "2nd" "2nd" "2nd" "Runner-Up"
Johnny Ruffo "3rd" "3rd" "3rd" "8th" "3rd" "6th" "2nd" "3rd" "3rd" "3rd" "Eliminated (Final)"
Three Wishez "7th" "7th" "7th" "7th" "6th" "5th" "4th" "5th" "4th" "Eliminated (Semi-Final)"
Declan Sykes "4th" "4th" "4th" "3rd" "7th" "3rd" "3rd" "4th" "Eliminated (Quarter-Final)"
Christina Parie '5th' '5th' '5th' '4th' '4th' '4th' '6th' "Eliminated (Week 7)"
Mitchell Callaway '6th' '6th' '6th' '5th' '5th' '7th' "Eliminated (Week 6)"
Young Men Society '9th' '8th' '10th' '6th' '8th' "Eliminated (Week 5)"
Audio Vixen '10th' '9th' '8th' '9th' "Eliminated (Week 4)"
Jacqui Newland '12th' '11th' '9th' "Eliminated (Week 3)"
Tyla Bertolli '8th' '10th' "Eliminated (Week 2)"
Cleo Howman '11th' "Eliminated (Week 1)"
Final Showdown "Howman, Newland" "Newland, Bertolli" "Newland, Young Men Society" "Ruffo, Audio Vixen" "Young Men Society, Sykes" "Callaway, Ruffo" "Parie, Mastin" "Sykes, Three Wishez"
Judges’ Votes to Eliminate "Howman", "Newland", "Newland", "Ruffo", "Sykes", "Ruffo", "Parie", "Sykes" "Newland", "Bertolli", "Newland", "Ruffo", "Young Men Society", "Ruffo", "Parie", "Sykes" "Howman", "Bertolli", "Newland", "Audio Vixen", "Young Men Society", "Callaway", "Parie", "Three Wishez" "Howman", "Bertolli", "Young Men Society", "Audio Vixen", "Sykes", "Callaway", "Mastin", "Sykes"
rowspan='4' colspan=2 align=center valign=middleEliminated "Cleo Howman"
By majority votes
"Tyla Bertolli"
By majority votes
"Jacqui Newland"
By majority votes
"Audio Vixen"
Deadlock decision
"Young Men Society"
Deadlock decision
"Mitchell Callaway"
Deadlock decision
"Christina Parie"
By majority votes
"Declan Sykes"
By majority votes
"Three Wishez"
Saved by public vote
  1. "Johnny Ruffo"
    Saved by public vote
  2. "Andrew Wishart"
    Public vote winner


Week 1 (19/20 September)

Performances by contestants during the initial live show
Contestant Category (Mentor) Performance Order Song Performed Outcome
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 1 "Closer to the Edge" Safe
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 2 "Telephone"
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 3 "The Man Who Can't Be Moved"
Christina Parie Girls (Mel B) 4 "Since U Been Gone"
Mitchell Callaway Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 5 "Only Girl (In the World)"
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 6 "Moves Like Jagger"
Audio Vixen Groups (Keating) 7 "Viva la Vida"
Cleo Howman Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 8 "Jar of Hearts" Bottom Two
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 9 "Uprising" Safe
Jacqui Newland Girls (Mel B) 10 "Love Story" Bottom Two
Young Men Society Groups (Keating) 11 "The Lazy Song"/"Price Tag" Safe
Tyla Bertolli Girls (Mel B) 12 "Set Fire to the Rain"
Details of the final showdown
Cleo Howman Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 1 "Chasing Pavements" Eliminated
Jacqui Newland Girls (Mel B) 2 "Heavy Cross" Safe

Judges' elimination decision

  • Mel B: Cleo Howman – chose to support her own contestant Jacqui Newland despite personal reservations about Howman.
  • Sebastian: Cleo Howman – decision based on the final showdown performance.
  • Bassingthwaighte: Jacqui Newland – voted in favor of her own act, Cleo Howman.
  • Keating: Cleo Howman – impressed by Newland's enthusiasm.

Additional information

Week 2 (27/28 September)

Contestants' performances during the second live show
Contestant Category (Mentor) Performance Order Song Performed Outcome
Audio Vixen Groups (Keating) 1 "Valerie" Safe
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 2 "I Write Sins Not Tragedies"
Mitchell Callaway Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 3 "All Summer Long"
Jacqui Newland Girls (Mel B) 4 "Heaven Is a Place on Earth" Bottom Two
Young Men Society Groups (Keating) 5 "You Shook Me All Night Long" Safe
Tyla Bertolli Girls (Mel B) 6 "The Edge of Glory" "Bottom Two"
Reece Mastin "Boys (Sebastian)" "7" "I Kissed a Girl" "Safe"
Andrew Wishart "Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte)" "8" "I Want to Break Free" "Safe"
Three Wishez "Groups (Keating)" "9" "Don't Stop the Music"/"Wanna Be Startin' Somethin'" "Safe"
Johnny Ruffo "Boys (Sebastian)" "10" "Down" "Safe"
Christina Parie "Girls (Mel B)" "11" "Girls Just Want to Have Fun"
Final showdown details for week two
Jacqui Newland "Girls (Mel B)" "1" "Respect" "Safe"
Tyla Bertolli "Girls (Mel B)" "2" "Fighter" "Eliminated"

Judges' elimination votes

  • Sebastian: Tyla Bertolli – voted based on gut feeling.
  • Bassingthwaighte: Tyla Bertolli – decision influenced by final showdown performance.
  • Keating: Jacqui Newland – acknowledged Bertolli’s greater progress.
  • Mel B: Tyla Bertolli – cited Newland’s superior composure.

Additional notes

  • Due to Seven Network’s broadcast of the 2011 Brownlow Medal, episodes were aired on Tuesday and Wednesday.
  • Song selections were determined through public voting in Australia.
  • Sebastian was absent from the live results show but cast his vote via live video link, validating his participation.

Week 3 (3/4 October)

  • Theme: Rock
  • Mentor: Alice Cooper
  • Featured guest artists: Natalie Bassingthwaighte performing "All We Have" and Simple Plan with "Can't Keep My Hands Off You"
  • Ensemble performance: "Live and Let Die"
Performances by contestants during the third live show
Contestant Category (mentor) Performance order Song choice Original Rock Artist Outcome
Jacqui Newland Girls (Mel B) 1 "Shut Up and Drive" Rihanna Bottom Two
Christina Parie Girls (Mel B) 2 "Gives You Hell" The All-American Rejects Safe
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 3 "The Flame" Cheap Trick
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 4 "Here Without You" 3 Doors Down
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 5 "Numb" Linkin Park
Young Men Society Groups (Keating) 6 "Walk This Way" Run D.M.C Bottom Two
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 7 "Dream On" Aerosmith Safe
Audio Vixen Groups (Keating) 8 "Good Times" The Easybeats
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 9 "Life on Mars?" David Bowie
Mitchell Callaway Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 10 "Run to Paradise" The Choirboys
Jacqui Newland Girls (Mel B) 1 "Just a Girl" Eliminated
Young Men Society Groups (Keating) 2 "Change the World" Safe

Elimination decision by judges

  • Mel B: Chose Young Men Society, supporting her own act Jacqui Newland.
  • Keating: Opted to eliminate Jacqui Newland, backing his own act Young Men Society.
  • Bassingthwaighte: Voted for Jacqui Newland due to her third consecutive appearance in the bottom two.
  • Sebastian: Selected Jacqui Newland, highlighting her repeated final showdown appearances versus Young Men Society’s potential.

Week 4 (10/11 October)

Contestants' performances during the fourth live show
Contestant Category (mentor) Performance order Song performed Outcome
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 1 "I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)" Bottom Two
Mitchell Callaway Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 2 "Everybody Hurts" Safe
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 3 "Ghetto Supastar (That Is What You Are)"
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 4 "Ironic"
Audio Vixen Groups (Keating) 5 "Chains" Bottom Two
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 6 "Nothing Compares 2 U" Safe
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 7 "Smells Like Teen Spirit"
Young Men Society Groups (Keating) 8 "Black or White"
Christina Parie Girls (Mel B) 9 "Zombie"
Final showdown details
Johnny Ruffo "Boys (Sebastian)" "1" "Just the Way You Are" "Safe"
Audio Vixen "Groups (Keating)" "2" "Somebody to Love" "Eliminated"

Judges' elimination vote

  • Keating voted to eliminate Johnny Ruffo, supporting his own act Audio Vixen.
  • Bassingthwaighte chose Johnny Ruffo, believing Audio Vixen showed greater improvement.
  • Sebastian voted against Audio Vixen, backing his mentee Johnny Ruffo.
  • Mel B selected Audio Vixen, resulting in a tie.

With an even split of votes, the decision moved to deadlock and reverted to the public vote. Consequently, Audio Vixen was eliminated for receiving fewer public votes.

Week 5 (17/18 October)

  • Theme: Chart-topping singles
  • Guest artists: Altiyan Childs performing "Ordinary Man" and Jason Derülo presenting a medley of "It Girl" and "Don't Wanna Go Home"
  • Collective performance: A Michael Jackson medley featuring Jason Derülo
Performances by contestants during the fifth live show
Contestant Category (mentor) Performance order Song performed Outcome
Christina Parie Girls (Mel B) 1 "Teenage Dirtbag" Safe
Young Men Society Groups (Keating) 2 "Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)"/"Get Busy" Bottom Two
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 3 "Forever Young"
Mitchell Callaway Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 4 "(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction" Safe
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 5 "What Goes Around... Comes Around"/"Cry Me a River"
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 6 "Dakota"
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 7 "She Will Be Loved"
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 8 "Lose Yourself"
Details of the final showdown
Young Men Society Groups (Keating) 1 "Let's Get Married" Eliminated
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 2 "Wonderwall" Safe

Judges' elimination votes

  • Sebastian: Voted to eliminate Young Men Society, supporting his own contestant Declan Sykes.
  • Mel B: Chose to eliminate Declan Sykes, favoring Young Men Society due to their broader international appeal.
  • Keating: Opted to eliminate Declan Sykes, backing his own group, Young Men Society.
  • Bassingthwaighte: Selected Young Men Society for elimination, deferring to deadlock while highlighting that it was their second time in the bottom two.

The tie in judges' votes led to deadlock, reverting the decision to the public vote. Consequently, Young Men Society was eliminated as they received the fewest public votes.

Week 6 (24/25 October)

  • Theme: Hits from Australian artists
  • Guest performers: Aloe Blacc with "I Need a Dollar" and Darren Hayes singing "Bloodstained Heart"
  • Group performance: A medley of Savage Garden songs alongside Darren Hayes
Contestants' performances during the sixth live show
Contestant Category (mentor) Performance order Song performed Original Australian artist Outcome
Mitchell Callaway Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 1 "Throw Your Arms Around Me" Hunters & Collectors Bottom Two
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 2 "Lost Without You" Delta Goodrem
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 3 "You're the Voice" John Farnham Safe
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 4 "Flame Trees" Cold Chisel
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 5 "Fall at Your Feet" Crowded House
Christina Parie Girls (Mel B) 6 "Weir" Killing Heidi
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 7 "Joker & the Thief" Wolfmother
Final showdown details
Mitchell Callaway Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 1 "I Won't Let Go" Eliminated
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 2 "Billie Jean" Safe

Judges' elimination decisions

  • Bassingthwaighte: Voted against Johnny Ruffo, defending her own contestant Mitchell Callaway.
  • Sebastian: Chose to eliminate Mitchell Callaway, supporting his own act Johnny Ruffo.
  • Mel B: Opted to eliminate Mitchell Callaway, praising Ruffo's progress since the first week.
  • Keating: Selected Johnny Ruffo for elimination, believing Callaway had shown greater effort that week.

The judges' split vote led to deadlock and the matter was decided by public voting. Mitchell Callaway was eliminated after receiving the lowest number of votes.

Week 7 (31 October/1 November)

Performances by contestants during the seventh live episode
Contestant Category (mentor) Performance order Song choice Outcome
Christina Parie Girls (Mel B) 1 "When Love Takes Over" Bottom Two
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 2 "Walking on a Dream" Safe
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 3 "Stayin' Alive" Bottom Two
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 4 "Titanium" Safe
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 5 "Without You"
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 6 "I Feel for You"/"Push It"
Details of the final showdown
Christina Parie Girls (Mel B) 1 "I'm with You" Eliminated
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 2 "Always" Safe

Judges' elimination decision

  • Sebastian: Christina Parie – chose to support his own contestant, Reece Mastin.
  • Mel B: Reece Mastin – voted in favor of her own act, Christina Parie.
  • Keating: Christina Parie – highlighted Mastin’s superior progress.
  • Bassingthwaighte: Christina Parie – felt Mastin showed more promise and advised Parie to remain authentic.

Week 8: Quarter-Final (7/8 November)

Quarter-final performances by contestants
Contestant Category (mentor) Performance order Song performed Result
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 1 "Sir Duke" Safe
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 2 "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For"
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 3 "Help!" Bottom Two
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 4 "In the Air Tonight"
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 5 "All by Myself" Safe
Final showdown details
Declan Sykes Boys (Sebastian) 1 "The Ballad of Mona Lisa" Eliminated
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 2 "Nobody's Perfect" Safe

Judges' elimination vote

  • Sebastian: Three Wishez – backed his own contestant, Declan Sykes.
  • Bassingthwaighte: Declan Sykes – supported Three Wishez due to their improvement.
  • Keating: Declan Sykes – voted for his own act, Three Wishez.
  • Mel B: Declan Sykes – believed Three Wishez displayed greater potential.

Week 9: Semi-Final (14/15 November)

Semi-final performances by contestants
Contestant Category (mentor) Performance order 1 First song Performance order 2 Second song Outcome
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 1 "Animal" 5 "Burn for You" Safe
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 2 "So Sick" 6 "Tonight Tonight"
Reece Mastin 3 "Breakeven" 7 "Paradise City"
Three Wishez Groups (Keating) 4 "The Time (Dirty Bit)" 8 "Turning Tables" Eliminated

Additional Information

  • Contestants each delivered two performances—one spirited and one heartfelt.
  • This episode marked the first occasion this season without a final showdown; the act receiving the lowest public votes was eliminated immediately.

Week 10: Final (21/22 November)

21 November
Monday Final performances by contestants
Contestant Category (mentor) Order 1 Audition song Order 2 Song representing series Order 3 Winner's single Order 4 Superstar duet partner(s) Result
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 1 "Someone Like You" 4 "Dakota" 7 "This Much I Know" 10 "You Found Me" Safe
Johnny Ruffo Boys (Sebastian) 2 "Do You Remember" 5 "Sir Duke" 8 "You Don't Wanna Know" 11 "Shoop"/"Push It" Eliminated
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 3 "Come Get Some" 6 "Dream On" 9 "Good Night" 12 "Kids" Safe

Johnny Ruffo was eliminated after receiving the lowest number of public votes.

22 November

Guest performances included The Fray with "Heartbeat", Luke O'Dell performing "Introvert Extrovert", Guy Sebastian singing "Don't Worry Be Happy", and Kylie Minogue with "I Should Be So Lucky".

Tuesday Final contestant performances
Contestant Category (mentor) Performance order Song performed Final result
Andrew Wishart Over 25s (Bassingthwaighte) 1 "With or Without You" Runner-Up
Reece Mastin Boys (Sebastian) 2 "Cryin'" Winner

Controversy

Just three days prior to the season's debut, Mel B openly criticized her fellow judges, labeling them as insincere and dull. She remarked, "Ronan acts like he knows everything, Natalie is overly kind yet quite dishonest, and Guy can be downright boring." In response, Natalie Bassingthwaighte addressed these comments on The Kyle and Jackie O Show, expressing hope that Mel B was joking. Subsequently, Mel B accepted her role as the show's outspoken provocateur, stating, "Everyone is intimidated by me... there has to be one 'bitch' on the panel, so I might as well claim that title."

Additional disputes emerged when judge Guy Sebastian publicly reprimanded contestant Mitchell Callaway following his rendition of "Run to Paradise." Sebastian stressed the importance of concentration, respect, and dedication, criticizing Callaway for forgetting lyrics and allegedly showing disrespect toward the production team. In defense, Callaway’s mentor Bassingthwaighte challenged these allegations during a radio interview and highlighted Callaway’s determination to persevere despite the criticism. Callaway also confirmed via Twitter his intention to remain in the contest. Although Sebastian apologized for the timing of his comments, he stood firm on his concerns regarding Callaway's conduct. Insider sources linked Sebastian’s criticism to an offstage altercation between Callaway and fellow contestant Declan Sykes—who has Asperger syndrome—after Sykes was reportedly pricked with a pin by Callaway.

Contestants

Emmanuel Kelly featured in the season's first audition episode aired on 29 August 2011, delivering a heartfelt performance of John Lennon's Imagine. His rendition received a standing ovation from both judges and audience members. Keating expressed profound admiration, stating, "I don't think I've ever been moved as deeply as I was by that performance." Emmanuel and his brother Ahmed were adopted by Moira Kelly, head of the Children First Foundation, which also supports the formerly conjoined Bangladeshi twins Krishna and Trishna. Originating from Iraq, the brothers were abandoned in an orphanage and suffered limb impairments due to chemical warfare exposure. Despite his initial impact, Sebastian eliminated Emmanuel during bootcamp after he forgot lyrics in a prior performance. Years later, on 30 May 2018, Kelly delivered an inspiring address and performance at the UN Youth Dialogue.

Another notable contestant, Luke O'Dell, appeared during the third audition episode on 31 August. Following a lackluster cover of Kelly Clarkson's Since U Been Gone, he performed an original piece titled Introvert Extrovert, which rapidly gained viral attention online. The song quickly climbed into the iTunes Top 100 and amassed thousands of followers across social media platforms. Additionally, it trended globally on Twitter for over two hours after his televised appearance. Despite drawing comparisons to Rebecca Black, O'Dell did not progress further in the competition. Both Emmanuel Kelly and Luke O'Dell returned later to perform on the live grand final episode.

Ratings

The debut episode aired on 29 August 2011 achieved the highest viewership of the evening, drawing 1,319,000 viewers and exceeding the audience for the second season's premiere, which was 1,186,000. Each of the six audition episodes secured the top position on their respective broadcast nights, with the peak audience reaching 1,690,000 the following evening. The initial live performance episode on 19 September 2011 attracted 1,452,000 viewers, again leading the night's ratings. The live grand final decider broadcast on 22 November 2011 recorded the season’s highest rating with an audience of 1,998,000.

Colour key
– Season’s highest rating
– Season’s lowest rating
  | 19 | Live show 4 |  | Monday 7:30 pm–9:00 pm |    | #3 | rowspan=2 |[7]     |#2 |- |21 |Live show 5 | | Monday7 :301 pm-9 :00 pm |13711 |'#2' |- [8] |- |22 |' Live decider5 '|' '18 October' '|' 'Tuesday' '|' '7 :301 pm-830 pm '|' '14181' '|' '#2' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-23 |' Live show6 '|' '24 October' '|' 'Monday' '|' '730 pm-900 pm' '|' '13521' '|' '#3' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-24 |' Live decider6 '|' '25 October' '|' 'Tuesday' '|' '730 pm-830 pm' '|' '13871' '|' '#2' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-25 |' Live show7 '|31 October' '|Monday' '|730 pm-830 pm' '|style=background:#FFC0CB|'12051 '|style=background:#FFC0CB|' #3' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-26 |' Live decider7 '|November01,'11' '|Tuesday' '|730 pm-830 pm' '|15171 '| '#3' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-27 |' Live show8 '|November07,'11' '|Monday' '|730 pm-830 pm' '|13261 '| '#3' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-28 |' Live decider8 '|November08,'11' '|Tuesday' '|730 pm-830 pm' '|15741 '| '#l' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-29 |' Live show9 '|November14,'11' '|Monday' '|730 pm-900 pm' '|14081 '| '#l' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-30 |' Live decider9 '|November15,'11' '|Tuesday' '|730 pm-830 pm' '|14981 '| '#l' '| Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name |- |-31 |Live Grand Final show||21 November201121||Monday730 pm-930 pm||14581||'#2'||Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name|-|-32||Live Grand Final decider||22 November201122||Tuesday730 pm-930 pm||17211||'#2'||Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name|- ! Winner announced ! style=background:#90EE90 !19981 ! style=background:#90EE90 !'#l'
Episode Original airdate Timeslot Viewers
(millions)
Nightly
rank
Ref
1 Auditions Monday 7:30 pm–9:00 pm 1.319 #1 [1]
2 Tuesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.690 #1
3 Wednesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.526 #1
4 Thursday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.403 #1
5 Monday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.475 #1 [2]
6 Tuesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.636 #1
7 Bootcamp Wednesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.527 #1
8 Thursday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.403 #1
9 Monday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.398 #1 [3]
10 Home Visits Tuesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.404 #2
11 Wednesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.457 #1
12 Thursday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.284 #1
13 Live show 1 Monday 7:30 pm–9:30 pm 1.452 #1 [4]
14 Live decider 1 Tuesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.429 #5
15 Live show 2 Tuesday 7:30 pm–9:30 pm 1.410 #1 [5]
16 Live decider 2 Wednesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm 1.221 #2
17 Live show 3 1.255 #1 [6]
18 Live decider 3   Tuesday 7:30 pm–8:30 pm   1.399   #2 


References

External links

  1. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named week 1
  2. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named week 2
  3. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named week 3
  4. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named week 4
  5. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named week 5
  6. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named week 6
  7. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named week 7
  8. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named week8