By Fair Means or Foul
| Industry | Video games |
|---|---|
| Founded | 1980 |
| Founder | Michael Simpson, Terry Simpson |
| Products | By Fair Means or Foul (Pro Boxing Simulator) |
By Fair Means or Foul, which was subsequently re-released under the name Pro Boxing Simulator, is a boxing-themed video game initially launched in 1988 by Superior Software for various 8-bit home computer systems. Later, Codemasters rebranded and distributed it for 16-bit platforms. The title offers a variety of boxing techniques, including illegal moves, and garnered a range of critical responses.
Gameplay
The game allows players to engage in either a single-player mode against the computer or a two-player contest, with the objective of becoming the World Champion by overcoming six progressively tougher adversaries and then defending the championship. It incorporates both legitimate boxing actions such as punches and jabs, alongside prohibited tactics like kicks and head butts, which carry the risk of referee penalties if detected. Visual cues on-screen alert players when foul moves might be spotted. Landing successful blows reduces the opponent’s energy meter; a knockout concludes the round, while the competitor with the lowest energy loses one 'chance'. During matches, audience remarks appear in speech bubbles.
Development and release
Created by Michael and Terry Simpson for the BBC Micro and Acorn Electron, the game was subsequently ported to Commodore 64, Amstrad CPC, and ZX Spectrum, all of which were released simultaneously by Superior Software in 1988. The BBC Micro and Electron editions were issued under Superior/Acornsoft, whereas other versions carried the Superior/Alligata label. Distribution was primarily via cassette tape across all platforms, with floppy disk versions available for all except the Electron.
In 1990, Codemasters issued a budget edition titled Pro Boxing Simulator to fit within their existing series lineup. The initial packaging described it as a "New Release," which led to consumer confusion since it was identical to By Fair Means or Foul. After receiving complaints, Codemasters revised the packaging to include "Previously known as 'Fair Means or Foul'" and provided refunds for customers who had purchased both versions.
Additionally, Codemasters developed Amiga and Atari ST editions released in 1991, broadening the game's reach into the 16-bit market segment.
Reception
Critical response varied widely. Electron User awarded an 8 out of 10 score, commending its distinctive approach to boxing gameplay. Amstrad Action rated it at 83%. Sinclair User appreciated the diverse fighting moves, sound effects, and crowd interaction but criticized its lack of smoothness and innovation, giving it a 68% rating.
Zzap!64 acknowledged the quality of the boxing simulation but found fault with the "blocky" visual presentation, assigning a 66% score. Your Sinclair gave it 6 out of 10, noting subpar graphics, cumbersome controls, and sluggish performance. In a 1994 retrospective, Amiga Force rated it 58%, describing it as "engaging."
Reviewing the Amstrad version, Computer and Video Games gave a low score of 36%, citing minimalistic graphics and awarding playability just 2 out of 5.