Car dealerships in the United States
| Company type | Commercial establishment |
|---|---|
| Industry | Automotive sales |
Area served | United States |
| Products | New cars, used cars, vehicle maintenance, repairs, trade-ins, leasing, financing |
Template:Use American English
Template:Multiple issues
Template:Use mdy dates


In the United States, a car dealership refers to a commercial establishment engaged in the sale of cars. Such dealerships may be either franchised, offering both new and used vehicles, or independent used car dealerships that exclusively sell pre-owned cars. Typically, dealerships also provide services including vehicle maintenance, repairs, trade-ins, leasing options, and financing arrangements for customers.
Used car dealerships often stock vehicles from multiple manufacturers, whereas nearly all new car dealerships operate as franchises tied to one or more specific manufacturers. Certain new car dealerships might represent several brands under the same manufacturer umbrella. In some regions, dealership ownership has been consolidated, with corporations managing chains that represent various manufacturers.
Historically in the United States, nearly every state had franchise laws prohibiting direct sales from manufacturers to consumers, mandating that new vehicles be sold solely through dealers.[1] However, after the initiatives led by Tesla during the 2010s, these restrictions have been substantially altered. Economists describe these franchise regulations as a form of rent-seeking behavior that extracts economic rents from automobile manufacturers, elevates costs for buyers, restricts market entry for new dealerships, and enhances profits for existing dealers.[2] Studies indicate that these laws contribute to higher retail prices for automobiles than would otherwise occur.[2] Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name
Selling cars


Most dealerships showcase their available vehicles both inside a showroom and on an adjacent lot. U.S. federal regulations require all new cars to display a window sticker detailing the manufacturer’s suggested retail price and key vehicle specifications.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name Sales personnel—usually compensated primarily through commission—engage buyers in negotiations to finalize the sale price. This process frequently involves discussing the value of a trade-in vehicle—the customer’s current automobile offered to the dealer as part of the transaction. From the dealership’s perspective, negotiation encompasses interactions starting with the salesperson’s efforts to reach an agreement and continuing until the customer submits an offer on a new vehicle, often incorporating their trade-in.
Once an offer is made along with a demonstration of good faith—such as a refundable deposit via check or credit card—the salesperson presents it to the sales manager. This deposit is commonly called the booking amount. The sales manager then works through various scenarios regarding monthly payments, financing options, and pricing configurations in a procedure known as "desking" the deal. Upon reaching mutual agreement on terms between customer and manager, both parties approve the selected option. Subsequently, a purchase and sales agreement is executed along with receipt of any required down payment. Following this step, responsibility transfers to the finance and insurance office (often called "the box"), where additional products like paint protection, wheel guards, or extended warranties are offered. Final documentation is also completed during this phase. While some buyers perceive desking as part of negotiation, it typically occurs only after a genuine offer accompanied by earnest money has been presented to management.
Dealerships acquire vehicles by ordering directly from manufacturers and finance this inventory through loans known as flooring or floor planning interest. Manufacturers also provide dealer holdbacks—payments made back to dealers—to support inventory stocking and enhance profitability.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name Usually amounting to about 1% to 3% of the vehicle’s manufacturer's suggested retail price (MSRP), holdbacks are not typically disclosed or negotiated with consumers but may be relinquished by dealers to expedite sales of slow-moving stock or to qualify for manufacturer incentives tied to sales volume.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad nameCite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name Initially designed to offset interest expenses incurred by dealers on financed inventory, holdbacks effectively reduce gross profit margins and thus impact sales commissions.[3] This mechanism enables dealerships to offer promotions near invoice prices while maintaining satisfactory profit levels.[3]
The rise of Internet usage has significantly transformed car sales processes. Over 70% of vehicle purchases in the U.S. begin with online research, providing buyers with detailed information on features and pricing comparisons across dealers within their region. This enhanced transparency empowers customers during price negotiations and places additional pressure on dealer profit margins.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name
Vehicle trade-ins
For most dealers, the trade-in cash value represents an estimate of what the vehicle might fetch at auction within six weeks to three months, after deducting any necessary refurbishment expenses if the dealer opts not to resell the vehicle directly to consumers. Given that numerous states mandate dealers to provide warranties or guarantees on used vehicles sold at certain price points or mileage thresholds, dealers must secure a profit from selling these previously traded-in cars as used vehicles.
Trade-in valuation plays a crucial role in automotive transactions. Various online platforms provide estimated trade-in values. Yet, these figures often rely on theoretical pricing guides that may not reflect recent average sale prices for specific makes and models. When less reliable auction data exists for a particular vehicle type, dealers tend to exercise greater caution when appraising the trade-in.
Typically, a dealership employs a manager responsible for evaluating trade-in vehicles. This individual frequently attends used car auctions, handling purchases and sales on behalf of the dealer and thus possesses an informed understanding of the vehicle’s realistic cash value. In assessing a trade-in, the dealer examines factors such as body condition, windshield integrity, engine sounds, and known model-specific issues to price the vehicle for profitable resale.
Supplementary offerings
A wide range of financing solutions, including loans and lease agreements, are commonly available through dealerships. Financing arrangements represent a significant revenue stream for dealers. Due to past controversies involving discriminatory or predatory lending practices, financing activities are subject to stringent regulations in many jurisdictions. For instance, California requires dealerships to prominently display multiple notices on-site and include explicit warnings in contracts—such as "THERE IS NO COOLING-OFF PERIOD."
While installment loan terms are negotiated between dealer and buyer, only a minority of dealerships directly extend credit to consumers; these are known as "Buy Here Pay Here" operations. Such dealers can finance purchases internally because they have mechanisms to repossess vehicles if buyers default, with repossession rules varying by state.
Most dealers partner with indirect lenders: installment contracts are promptly "assigned" or sold to third-party financial institutions—often affiliated with automakers like GM Financial or Ally Financial, or banks—that compensate the dealer upfront and then collect payments from borrowers. To facilitate this process, dealerships typically utilize pre-approved standardized contracts provided by vendors such as Reynolds and Reynolds, whose agreements have undergone extensive legal scrutiny in disputes between customers and dealers.
Dealers may increase the contract's interest rate above the wholesale rate offered by lenders and retain part of this markup. For example, if a bank’s base rate is 6.75%, the dealer might charge 7.75%, receiving a portion of the difference from the bank. This practice is common since selling financing contracts resembles selling vehicles themselves. However, banks or state laws often cap allowable markups by setting acceptable interest rate ranges. The impact on monthly payments is usually minimal due to relatively small loan amounts and shorter terms compared to mortgages.
Consumers might find that dealers can secure more favorable rates than local banks or credit unions offer. Nevertheless, manufacturers frequently provide incentives such as low-interest financing or cash rebates—but not both simultaneously—when financing is arranged through channels other than the dealership. Buyers should evaluate whether applying a larger rebate reduces overall payments by decreasing financed amounts; for example, comparing a dealer’s 7.9% financing offer versus an 8.25% credit union loan after accounting for rebates can clarify which is more cost-effective. Dealers can perform credit checks on customers through their lending partners; buyers may also authorize their own lenders to conduct credit assessments for comparison purposes. Most new car financing is facilitated through manufacturer-affiliated finance arms or local banks.
Dealerships often present additional services including:
- Service contracts: Although vehicles sold in the U.S. now come with manufacturer warranties covering certain periods or mileage limits, buyers can choose from various extended service contracts that protect against mechanical failures beyond the original warranty term. These contracts may differ significantly in coverage terms and often include deductibles similar to insurance policies. Consumers should carefully review contract details before purchase since routine maintenance items like brake pads, fluids, or filters are typically excluded. Some states—Florida being notable—impose strict regulations on service contract pricing.
There are three primary types of service contracts: 1. Manufacturer-backed plans sold through dealerships that honor repairs at any franchised dealer nationwide; claims are submitted to manufacturers who reimburse repair costs minus deductibles paid by customers. Dealers generally have no incentive other than repairing vehicles properly since reimbursement is profitable. 2. Insurance-style contracts purchased wholesale by dealers but administered by third-party companies (often major insurers). Payments collected from customers fund a reserve account managed by this administrator; repair authorizations occur prior to work completion with costs deducted from reserves. Unused funds after contract expiration return to dealers minus administrative fees, creating profit potential. 3. Directly purchased policies from select automobile insurance providers independent of dealerships.
- GAP insurance: Guaranteed Asset Protection covers outstanding loan balances if a vehicle is totaled due to accident or theft, preventing borrowers from owing money on a non-existent asset. Many states regulate GAP insurance sales; for example, New York prohibits dealerships from profiting on GAP policy sales.
- Credit/Life/Disability insurance: These products serve as profit centers for dealerships and resemble the second type of service contract described above but cannot be mandated as loan conditions. Buyers may opt for coverage protecting loan payments if disabled beyond 30 days (usually requiring proof) or ensuring loan payoff upon death during contract term. Consumers often find comparable policies through their own insurers and should compare rates accordingly.
- Aftermarket accessories: Dealers frequently offer add-ons not provided directly by manufacturers. Caution is advised as some engage in illegal "payment packing," inflating monthly payments deceptively to encourage accessory purchases at understated prices. Legal cases have upheld employee whistleblower rights against such practices. Like credit-related insurances, consumers may purchase accessories independently outside dealership channels.
- Maintenance agreements: Dealerships with service departments offer prepaid maintenance plans either through manufacturers (e.g., Saturn’s Basic Care) or independently. Due to variability across programs and providers, buyers should understand included services and recommended maintenance intervals before committing.
- Lease Here Pay Here Contracts: These lease-to-own arrangements typically involve used vehicles leased for terms ranging from one to three years and target customers with limited financial resources. Such dealers face scrutiny since they lack conventional lending standards and may repossess vehicles promptly upon default without bankruptcy protections afforded elsewhere. Advocates argue lease payments might be lower due to absence of sales tax compared with traditional loan purchases.
Automotive dealers also provide maintenance and repair services; new car dealerships especially emphasize these offerings since they stock manufacturer parts and handle warranty claims for represented brands. Maintenance services generally generate high margins and constitute an important profit center within dealership operations.
Regulation
In the United States, the regulation of car dealership operations predominantly falls under state jurisdiction. Vehicle titles are issued and transferred by each state's Departments of Motor Vehicles. When purchasing a vehicle, the price typically encompasses various fees that the dealer remits to the state's DMV to facilitate the title transfer to the buyer. In numerous states, DMVs also oversee the licensing and regulation of car dealerships. Many dealerships have the authority to submit all required documentation to the DMV on behalf of customers and can provide temporary paperwork to demonstrate that the transaction is underway, thereby sparing customers from visiting a DMV office in person.
Consumer grievances related to car dealerships are generally handled by the Attorney General's office within the state where the dealership operates. In states where the DMV handles dealership licensing and regulation, it often manages initial consumer complaints, with involvement from the state AG's office occurring only if there is suspicion of criminal conduct by a dealer.
Customer experience
A survey revealed that over half of buyers would choose to purchase directly from manufacturers if given the option, even without financial incentives. An analysis estimates that adopting a direct sales approach could reduce vehicle costs by approximately 8.6%. This suggests a substantial latent demand for direct manufacturer-to-consumer sales. Nevertheless, many U.S. states have laws preventing manufacturers from selling vehicles directly, mandating that consumers must acquire new cars through authorized dealers.
Discrimination
Research indicates that certain auto dealerships impose higher interest rates or increase prices specifically for women and ethnic minorities, including Asian and African American customers. These discriminatory practices have led to legal actions such as class action lawsuits targeting dealers accused of bias based on race or ethnicity.
New Vehicle Sales
2024 figures
- Lithia Motors - 729,799 vehicles sold
- AutoNation - 591,265 vehicles sold
- Penske Automotive Group - 587,483 vehicles sold
- Group 1 Automotive - 406,985 vehicles sold
- Sonic Automotive - 315,473 vehicles sold
- Asbury Automotive Group - 277,016 vehicles sold
- Hendrick Automotive - 260,497 vehicles sold
- Morgan Auto Group - 201,927 vehicles sold
- Ken Garff Automotive Group - 149,395 vehicles sold
- Staluppi Auto Group - 86,329 vehicles sold
Pre-Owned Vehicle Sales
2023 figures
- Lithia Motors - 325,764 units sold
- AutoNation - 274,019 units sold
- Penske Automotive Group - 256,721 units sold
- Group 1 Automotive - 199,963 units sold
- Sonic Automotive - 173,886 units sold
- Asbury Automotive Group - 127,507 units sold
- Hendrick Automotive - 95,676 units sold
- Morgan Auto Group - 85,207 units sold
- Ken Garff Automotive Group - 56,163 units sold
- Hudson Automotive Group - 54,200 units sold
Note: These rankings exclude dealerships operating exclusively online such as CarMax, Carvana, and Vroom.