Jump to content

CIA black sites

From Alfawiki
Adapted from the English Wikipedia article CIA black sites, available under CC BY-SA 4.0Updated 7 August 20258 sources
CIA Black Sites
Company typeCovert government program
IndustryIntelligence, Detention, Interrogation
Founded2001
FounderCentral Intelligence Agency (CIA)
Defunct2009
FateTerminated by U.S. government
Headquarters
United States (operated globally)
Area served
Worldwide (including Afghanistan, Lithuania, Morocco, Poland, Romania, Thailand)
Key people
George W. Bush, Barack Obama, Condoleezza Rice, Dana Priest
ProductsCovert detention and interrogation of suspected enemy combatants
OwnerUnited States Government (CIA)

Following the September 11 attacks and the ensuing war on terror, the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) initiated a "Detention and Interrogation Program" that utilized covert extrajudicial detention centers commonly referred to as "black sites". These locations were used to hold, question, and frequently torture individuals suspected of being enemy combatants, often operating with the consent of host nations.[1]

The CIA black sites implemented "enhanced interrogation techniques" on detainees, many of whom had been unlawfully seized and transferred. These facilities were situated in countries such as Afghanistan, Lithuania, Morocco, Poland, Romania, and Thailand.[2] This network formed part of a wider international program that included foreign-run sites—typically in Syria, Egypt, and Jordan—as well as the U.S. military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, which detained individuals classified as "illegal enemy combatants" under a presidential military directive.[2]

Access to information about black site locations was limited to senior U.S. officials and select intelligence personnel within the host countries.[2] Human rights organizations and media outlets began reporting on these secret facilities as early as 2002.[3] In November 2005, The Washington Post revealed the existence of this clandestine global detention network operated by the CIA in collaboration with foreign governments.[3] In 2006, President George W. Bush confirmed the presence of CIA secret prisons but denied allegations of detainee abuse.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name Although black sites effectively ceased operations in 2006, many details remained classified.

On February 14, 2007, the European Parliament issued a report indicating that several EU member states had cooperated with the CIA’s rendition program, naming Poland and Romania as hosts for covert CIA detention facilities.[1][4] In January 2009, President Barack Obama officially terminated black site activities and banned detainee torture,Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name but extraordinary rendition practices continued.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name A 2010 United Nations report identified a coordinated international system of secret detentions involving the U.S. and allied governments.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name

Following a five-year inquiry, the U.S. Senate Intelligence Committee released a summary report in 2014 concluding that the CIA employed harsh and ineffective interrogation methods at black sites while providing misleading information to officials and the public;[5] although the CIA acknowledged shortcomings in the program, it denied deliberately deceiving anyone.[5]

In 2014, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) affirmed the existence of CIA black sites and ruled that Poland permitted detention and torture within its borders.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name Later that year, Poland conceded to hosting such facilities,Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name with investigations identifying it as a significant element of the CIA’s worldwide detention framework.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name A 2018 ECtHR decision also held Romania and Lithuania accountable for torture carried out in CIA black sites located on their territories.Cite error: The opening <ref> tag is malformed or has a bad name

Official recognition

In late 2006, President George W. Bush publicly acknowledged black sites’ existence, stating that numerous detainees were being transferred to Guantanamo Bay. The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) conducted interviews with prisoners moved from black sites to Guantanamo Bay toward the end of 2006. Their report—delivered to the Bush administration in early 2007—documented conditions experienced by "high value detainees," including Abu Zubaydah, Walid bin Attash, and Khalid Shaikh Mohammed. The findings were later made public in 2009 by the New York Review of Books, shedding light on treatment and interrogation practices at these hidden locations.

Greystone

Greystone, also known by the acronym GREYSTONE (GST), served as the classified codeword for a Sensitive Compartmented Information (SCI) program that detailed CIA activities involving rendition, interrogation, and counter-terrorism initiatives launched following the September 11 attacks. This program covers covert operations in the Middle East, including pre-deployment actions in Afghanistan and targeted drone strikes.

The abbreviation GST became publicly known in December 2005 when Dana Priest of The Washington Post reported on secret programs aimed at capturing suspected Al-Qaeda operatives, managing clandestine detention facilities overseas, and employing disputed interrogation techniques. Confirmation of GST appeared later in 2009 through a declassified Justice Department document dated 2004.

The complete codeword GREYSTONE was revealed in the 2013 publication Deep State, Inside the Government Secrecy Industry by Marc Ambinder and D.B. Grady. Within GREYSTONE, there exist numerous numbered sub-compartments (such as GST-001), with access strictly limited to individuals directly involved in those specific operations.

Legal authority for operation

The legal foundation underpinning U.S. and allied black site activities remains ambiguous and heavily debated. The United Nations has played a role in monitoring these operations.

British Prime Minister Tony Blair remarked that a related report "added absolutely nothing new." Poland and Romania were strongly implicated as locations used for detainee transfers, with airports in Timișoara, Romania, and Szymany, Poland, identified as transit points. Additionally, eight other airports outside Europe were also named.

On May 19, 2006, the United Nations Committee Against Torture urged the United States to terminate secret detention centers and cease transferring prisoners to nations where torture is likely. This recommendation followed hearings during which U.S. representatives defended their policies.

Statements from the Bush administration

Addressing accusations concerning black sites, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice declared on December 5, 2005, that the U.S. had not infringed upon any nation's sovereignty during rendition operations and that detainees were never sent to countries known to practice torture. Nonetheless, some media outlets pointed out that her remarks did not rule out secret prisons operating with host country consent or unreliable assurances against torture. On September 6, 2006, President Bush publicly confirmed the existence of secret detention facilities and acknowledged that numerous detainees had been moved to Guantanamo Bay.

In December 2002, The Washington Post reported that intelligence gathered during interrogations contributed to the capture of al Qaeda figures such as Ramzi bin al-Shibh, Omar al-Faruq, Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, and Muhammad al Darbi.

On April 21, 2006, CIA analyst Mary O. McCarthy was terminated amid allegations of leaking classified information to journalist Dana Priest, who earned a Pulitzer Prize for exposing CIA black sites. While some speculated that leaked details pertained to the detention camps, McCarthy’s attorney denied she had access to such material. The Washington Post suggested McCarthy had been investigating claims of CIA wrongdoing and suspected agency officials had misled Senate staff in 2005.

During a speech on September 29, 2006, President Bush asserted that interrogations of Abu Zubaydah, Ramzi bin al-Shibh, and Khalid Sheikh Mohammed yielded intelligence that thwarted several terrorist plots targeting U.S. interests both domestically and internationally.

On July 20, 2007, President Bush signed an executive order prohibiting torture by intelligence personnel and mandating CIA adherence to the Geneva Conventions.

Prominent detainees

Among the individuals suspected of affiliation with al-Qaeda and detained by the CIA were Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, Riduan Isamuddin, Ramzi bin al-Shibh, and Abu Zubaydah. The estimated number of ghost detainees exceeds one hundred, although less than 10% have faced formal charges or convictions. According to Swiss senator Dick Marty, approximately 100 people were abducted by the CIA on European territory and transferred to nations where torture may have been practiced. This count is distinct from those held as ghost detainees under U.S. custody.

In late 2006, several detainees were relocated to the U.S.-operated Guantanamo Bay facility in Cuba, effectively acknowledging the existence of covert overseas prisons maintained by the United States.

Khaled el-Masri

German national Khalid El-Masri was apprehended in Skopje, transported to Afghanistan, and subjected to months of CIA interrogation before being released without charges in Albania in May 2004. His capture stemmed from a mistaken identity involving alleged terrorist Khalid al-Masri. Germany issued arrest warrants for 13 individuals implicated in his kidnapping but withdrew them in 2007.

On October 9, 2007, the United States Supreme Court refused to review El-Masri's civil lawsuit against the U.S. government (El-Masri v. Tenet), thereby upholding lower court rulings that prohibited the case from proceeding due to concerns over disclosing state secrets.

Imam Rapito

The CIA orchestrated the abduction of Hassan Mustafa Osama Nasr (known as Abu Omar) in Milan, transferring him to Egypt where he was reportedly subjected to torture. An Egyptian judiciary declared his detention "unfounded" and released him in February 2007; he was never formally charged in Italy. Ultimately, indictments were issued against 26 Americans—mostly alleged CIA operatives—and nine Italians. On November 4, 2009, an Italian court convicted 23 Americans in absentia, including a U.S. Air Force colonel, while two Italians received convictions in person.

Aafia Siddiqui

During her trial in New York City, defense attorneys argued that Aafia Siddiqui endured captivity and torture at a clandestine U.S. facility in Bagram for five years, where she was reportedly the sole female detainee, referred to as "Prisoner 650." Her case gained notoriety after allegations by Yvonne Ridley concerning a spectral female prisoner unsettling other inmates. Siddiqui’s relatives assert she suffered mistreatment at Bagram.

The trial spanned 14 days in 2010, with the jury deliberating for three days before convicting her on charges including attempted murder, armed assault, firearm offenses, and assault on U.S. personnel. On September 23, 2010, she received an 86-year prison sentence following her testimony.

Alleged detention locations

[[File:Map of Countries involved in US Extrordinary Rendition.svg|thumb|400px|right|



Sources: Amnesty International Human Rights Watch]

It is estimated that around 50 detention facilities across 28 countries have been used to hold prisoners, alongside at least 25 sites in Afghanistan and 20 within Iraq. Since 2001, the U.S. is reported to have employed 17 vessels as floating detention centers, contributing to over 100 sites operated by the United States and its partners for holding terrorism suspects.

Fifty-four nations have been identified as participating in capturing, detaining, torturing, or facilitating the transfer of CIA detainees. These include Algeria, Azerbaijan, Bosnia, Djibouti, Egypt, Ethiopia, Gambia, Israel, Jordan, Kenya, Kosovo, Libya, Lithuania, Mauritania, Morocco, Pakistan, Poland, Qatar, Romania, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Somalia, South Africa, Thailand, United Kingdom, Uzbekistan, Yemen, and Zambia.

Asia

Shortly after the events of September 11, 2001, the CIA established its inaugural black site in Thailand. This location functioned as a preliminary setting for the enhanced interrogation methods that were later adopted as standard within the CIA’s program. Thailand was selected because of its official alliance with the United States and its longstanding history of collaboration in military and intelligence matters.

A high-ranking Thai security official disclosed that the Udorn Royal Thai Air Force Base operated a black site known by the codename "Detention Site Green." This facility was used to interrogate at least three high-value detainees, including Abu Zubaydah, a significant figure connected to Osama bin Laden. Zubaydah was transferred there in March 2002 with approval from the Thai government and became the first CIA prisoner subjected to torture during the War on Terror.

In August 2018, plans were announced by the Royal Thai Army to transform the former Ramasun Station—suspected of being a black site—into a tourist destination, while denying any use of the site for detention purposes. Additionally, Don Muang Royal Thai Air Force Base has been identified as another potential location for CIA detention operations.

The U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence found that at least eight senior Thai officials were aware of the secret facility; however, some officials opposed CIA activities strongly enough to nearly cause its shutdown. In 2005, Thai media connected a remote Voice of America relay station in Udon Thani Province with a CIA black site referred to as "Cat's Eye" or "Detention Site Green." Former Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra denied these allegations. Thailand has consistently refuted claims about black sites on its territory and has not conducted investigations into officials involved in covert CIA detentions.

Due to concerns regarding leaks exposing the site’s location to U.S. media and widespread knowledge among Thai officials, the CIA shut down this detention center in December 2002. Nonetheless, illegal detentions reportedly continued in Thailand until at least 2004. According to a 2013 report by the Open Society Justice Initiative, a total of ten CIA detainees were held on Thai soil before being transferred without legal process either to Guantanamo Bay or other countries.

Middle East

In Afghanistan, the detention facility at Bagram Air Base initially operated out of an abandoned factory near Kabul known as the "Salt Pit". After a detainee died from hypothermia, operations moved inside the base. Although numerous incidents of torture and mistreatment occurred at Bagram, these were not connected to the CIA-run section. Prior to 2005, the prison was relocated to a classified location. Reports have described metal shipping containers at Bagram as black sites. Some detainees sent to Guantanamo Bay spoke of torture at a facility near Kabul labeled "the dark prison." Other suspected detention locations include Jalalabad and Asadabad.

In Iraq, Abu Ghraib was exposed as a black site notorious for a prisoner abuse scandal in 2004. Additional reported sites include Camp Bucca close to Umm Qasr and Camp Cropper near Baghdad International Airport.

The UAE is known to operate clandestine prisons within Yemen, where detainees endure enforced disappearances and torture. Human rights organizations have urged Emirati forces to shut down these facilities, which reportedly hold political dissidents, civilians, and influential figures. Reports document that Saudi and UAE forces subjected Yemeni detainees to severe forms of torture.

On 11 April 2021, Mwatana for Human Rights reported that around 27 civilians remained unlawfully detained by UAE authorities at Al Munawara Central Prison in Mukalla City despite court orders mandating their release. Survivors and eyewitnesses have confirmed that Emirati forces maintain illegal detention centers in southern Yemen where torture is practiced; some detainees have taken their own lives in protest against unjust imprisonment.

Africa

Locations in Egypt, Libya, Morocco, and Djibouti have been identified as CIA-operated sites. Among these, the Temara interrogation facility, situated roughly 5 miles from Rabat, Morocco, is noted as one such center. On January 23, 2009, The Guardian revealed the existence of a covert CIA detention site at Camp Lemonnier in Djibouti, a base formerly used by the French Foreign Legion.

Indian Ocean

Initially denied by both UK and U.S. authorities, the U.S. Naval Base on Diego Garcia was later acknowledged by Time magazine and a high-ranking American official as a location utilized for detaining suspects linked to the "war on terror." In 2015, Lawrence Wilkerson, who served as chief of staff to U.S. Secretary of State Colin Powell, disclosed that Diego Garcia functioned as a CIA transit and interrogation facility when other venues were inaccessible or deemed unsafe.

This revelation brought reputational challenges for the governments involved, particularly the UK, which had consistently denied the presence of U.S. detention centers on its territories or bases. The UK also faces potential repercussions for breaching international agreements. On February 21, 2008, British Foreign Secretary David Miliband issued an apology after confirming that two U.S. extraordinary rendition flights had refueled on Diego Garcia in 2002, retracting previous denials.

Europe

Numerous European nations—especially former Soviet-aligned states such as Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bulgaria, Czechia, Georgia, Hungary, Kazakhstan, Lithuania, Poland, and Romania—have faced accusations of hosting CIA black sites, though most governments have refuted these claims. EU Justice Commissioner Franco Frattini cautioned that any member state confirmed to harbor such facilities could face suspension of voting privileges.

Romanian Interior Minister Vasile Blaga rejected allegations that Mihail Kogălniceanu Airport was used for detentions, asserting it served solely as a logistical hub despite intercepted communications suggesting secret interrogations occurred there. Investigator Dick Marty exposed purported CIA prisons in Poland and Romania in 2007. Former Romanian President Ion Iliescu acknowledged granting CIA access to a Romanian location without understanding its function, describing it as an act of goodwill prior to Romania’s NATO membership. Similarly, ex-presidential advisor Ioan Talpeș confirmed confidential accords permitting CIA operations at the Mihail Kogălniceanu Air Base and other Romanian airports. Marty’s findings indicated these sites detained Taliban figures, al-Qaeda members, and other significant detainees between 2002 and 2005.

Both Ukraine and North Macedonia denied hosting black sites despite reports suggesting otherwise. In June 2008, the New York Times quoted CIA personnel stating Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was held near Poland’s Szymany Airport where waterboarding was extensively employed before he cooperated. Polish intelligence later corroborated that detainees were held at a military installation in Stare Kiejkuty from 2002 to 2005 under limited Polish supervision. Prime Minister Leszek Miller and President Aleksander Kwaśniewski reportedly knew about the base but likely were unaware of torture practices. The Guardian reported additional CIA black sites operated at Camp Eagle in Bosnia and Camp Bondsteel in Kosovo. The United States declined to assist with Polish investigations.

In Lithuania, a former equestrian school close to Vilnius was alleged to have been transformed into a CIA detention center in 2004, prompting a parliamentary investigation. President Dalia Grybauskaitė expressed indirect suspicions; however, the commission found no conclusive evidence of such a facility. Former Lithuanian President Valdas Adamkus stated no terrorist detainees were held within Lithuania’s borders. Nonetheless, a 2015 submission to the European Court of Human Rights argued that the Senate Intelligence Committee’s report on CIA torture implicated Lithuania’s involvement strongly. In January 2022, Lithuania announced intentions to sell the former site, which Defense Minister Arvydas Anušauskas described as containing windowless and soundproof rooms suitable for secret confinement.

Following the release of the Senate report, Aleksander Kwaśniewski admitted Poland consented to host a CIA black site under assurances that detainees would be treated as prisoners of war under Polish law; however, no formal memorandum with the U.S. was finalized due to time limitations.

Mobile detention platforms

  • The U.S. Navy vessel USS Bataan (LHD-5) has served as a provisional interrogation location for detainees before their relocation to other sites, potentially including clandestine black sites.
    • Significant aircraft involved in rendition operations include:
    • N221SG (Learjet 35)
    • N44982 (Gulfstream V, also identified as N379P)
    • N8068V (Gulfstream V)
    • N4476S (Boeing Business Jet)
  • Investigations into FAA registrations indicate that some of these tail numbers may have been falsified, assigned to different types of planes.
  • On May 31, 2008, The Guardian disclosed that the human rights organization Reprieve claimed that as many as seventeen U.S. naval vessels were covertly utilized to detain prisoners. Besides the USS Bataan, the list includes: USS Peleliu, USS Ashland, USNS Stockham, USNS Watson, USNS Watkins, USNS Sisler, USNS Charlton, USNS Pomeroy, USNS Red Cloud, USNS Soderman, and USNS Dahl. Additionally, the MV ships PFC William B. Baugh, Alex Bonnyman, Franklin J Phillips, Louis J Huage Jr., and James Anderson Jr. were mentioned. Notably, the USS Ashland was deployed off the coast of Somalia in 2007 and reportedly functioned as a receiving vessel for up to 100 captives captured in East Africa.

The Washington Post December 2002

On December 26, 2002, The Washington Post revealed the existence of a covert CIA detention facility at Bagram Air Force Base in Afghanistan, constructed from metal shipping containers. Subsequently, on March 14, 2004, The Guardian uncovered that three British nationals were held within a secretive section (Camp Echo) of Guantánamo Bay. Numerous reports highlighted the CIA’s practice of maintaining ghost detainees alongside officially acknowledged "enemy combatants." However, it was an article by The Washington Post on November 2, 2005, that ignited widespread public controversy.

Human Rights Watch March 2004 report

In March 2004, Human Rights Watch issued "Enduring Freedom: Abuses by US Forces in Afghanistan," detailing CIA activities in Afghanistan following September 2001. This included a sizable facility located in Kabul’s Ariana Chowk area and a detention and interrogation center situated at Bagram Airbase.

Village March 2005 report

Early in 2005, Ireland’s Village magazine reported that the CIA utilized Dublin and Shannon airports for suspected abduction flights during its "war on terror." A Boeing 737 (tail number N313P, later changed to N4476S) passed through these airports fourteen times between January 2003 and late 2004. Its flight routes included Estonia, Larnaca, Salé, Kabul, Palma, Skopje, Baghdad, and Marka. On September 23, 2003, the plane landed at Guantanamo Bay after stops in Poland, Romania, and Morocco. This aircraft was connected to the kidnapping of Khalid El-Masri in Macedonia and his subsequent transfer to a U.S. detention facility in Afghanistan.

Originally registered to Premier Executive Transport Services based in Massachusetts, the plane was reassigned to Keeler and Tate Management in Nevada by February 2005. On the same date, a Gulfstream V jet (Tail No. N8068V), which had been used for similar purposes, was transferred from Premier Executive Transport Services to Baynard Foreign Marketing.

Washington Post November 2005 Coverage

On November 2, 2005, a Washington Post article by Dana Priest disclosed that the CIA was holding significant alleged al Qaeda detainees at a facility dating back to the Soviet era in Eastern Europe, according to sources within U.S. and international agencies. This clandestine detention network is said to extend across multiple European democracies, Thailand, Afghanistan, and a section of Guantánamo Bay in Cuba—referred to by Amnesty International as "The Gulag Archipelago" in allusion to Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's work.

The Bush Administration challenged the accuracy of the report but did not seek to suppress its publication. Instead, officials requested that the identities of the countries hosting these secret prisons remain confidential to prevent interference with ongoing counter-terrorism efforts. As a result, the Post refrained from disclosing the names of the Eastern European states involved at the behest of senior U.S. authorities.

Human Rights Watch Findings

On November 3, 2005, Tom Malinowski from New York–based Human Rights Watch presented indirect evidence indicating that Poland and Romania were sites for CIA-run covert detention centers. Flight logs revealed that a Boeing 737 bearing tail number 'N4476S', leased by the CIA for prisoner transfers, made stops in Poland and Romania during routes from Kabul to Morocco before reaching Guantánamo Bay.[6] These flight itineraries supported assertions that detainees were sorted and held at separate locations. Malinowski’s statements led to denials from Polish and Romanian governments and raised alarms at the International Committee of the Red Cross ("ICRC"), which demanded access to all terrorism suspects detained by U.S. authorities.

Allegations that certain EU members permitted U.S. detention or torture operations on their soil sparked controversy within the European Union, which in November 2005 cautioned that any implicated nations risked losing their voting privileges within the council.

Amnesty International November 2005 Publication

On November 8, 2005, Amnesty International published its initial comprehensive accounts from former detainees held at CIA black sites.[7] The document focused on three nationals from Yemen, describing conditions endured during secret detention. In April 2006, Amnesty International analyzed flight data to pinpoint a black site location situated in Eastern Europe or Central Asia.

BBC Report December 2006

On December 28, 2006, the BBC disclosed that in 2003 a CIA-operated Gulfstream V aircraft known for rendition missions, designated N379P, frequently landed at Szymany airbase in Poland. Airport personnel were instructed to avoid interaction with the plane, which remained parked at a remote section of the runway with engines running. Vans associated with a nearby intelligence facility (Stare Kiejkuty) briefly met the aircraft before departing. Landing charges were settled in cash with invoices issued under apparently fictitious American company names.[8]

New Yorker August 2007 Investigation

In an August 13, 2007 article for The New Yorker, Jane Mayer exposed that following 9/11, CIA-run secret "black site" prisons operated under explicit presidential authorization from George W. Bush. The piece detailed harsh psychological interrogation techniques inspired by the Vietnam-era Phoenix Program, including sensory deprivation, sleep disruption, enforced nudity combined with humiliation, and administration of drugs via suppositories. Reports indicated that CIA personnel secured professional liability insurance in anticipation of possible criminal charges should these practices become publicly known.

Media coverage from September 2007 onward

In 2007, the Justice Department was requested to submit legal opinions related to interrogation techniques to both the Senate Intelligence Committee and the House Judiciary Committee. Senator John D. Rockefeller IV criticized the department for providing less information than what was already available through media sources. On October 5, President Bush publicly defended the interrogation methods, affirming they adhered to U.S. legal standards and international commitments, and emphasized that Congress had been thoroughly informed.

During an event hosted by the Chicago Council on Global Affairs on October 30, CIA Director Michael Hayden confirmed the legality and effectiveness of CIA programs but refrained from commenting specifically on waterboarding until he had a full understanding of the context, referencing attorney general nominee Michael Mukasey.

On December 6, 2007, the CIA admitted to destroying videotapes documenting harsh interrogation techniques used in a covert program back in 2002. The agency justified this action by citing security concerns for those conducting interrogations and stating that the tapes held no intelligence value or relevance to ongoing investigations. This destruction elicited strong criticism from Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman Carl Levin and other Democratic members of Congress, who raised questions about potential legal breaches.

Investigations across Europe

Following widespread European media reports and public concern regarding alleged "secret CIA prisons" in Poland and other U.S. allied nations, the European Union's Committee on Legal Affairs launched an inquiry into whether member countries such as Poland, the Czech Republic, or Romania hosted such detention centers. The investigation did not uncover definitive proof confirming these prisons' existence but did identify credible indicators that justified further examination.

The CIA's purported program prompted numerous official probes within Europe into clandestine detentions and illegal transfers between states belonging to the Council of Europe. A report issued by the Council of Europe in June 2006 estimated that approximately 100 individuals had been abducted by the CIA on European Union soil, frequently passing through covert "black sites," some situated within Europe itself. Additionally, a February 2007 European Parliament report recorded 1,245 flights operated by the CIA to locations where detainees faced a significant risk of torture, thereby violating provisions of the UN Convention Against Torture.

Investigations in Spain

In November 2005, El País revealed that CIA aircraft had landed in the Canary Islands and Palma de Mallorca without official Spanish authorization. This discovery led a state prosecutor to launch an investigation into potential violations of Spanish sovereignty due to unauthorized foreign operations occurring on national territory.

French inquiries

The Bobigny court prosecutor in France initiated an investigation to verify whether the aircraft bearing registration number N50BH was present at Le Bourget Airport on July 20, 2005. This followed a December 2005 complaint filed by the Ligue des droits de l'homme (LDH) and International Federation of Human Rights Leagues (FIDH), accusing parties of "arbitrary detention," "torture," and breaches of rights pertaining to war prisoners. The probe seeks to establish if this plane transported CIA detainees to Guantanamo Bay detainment camp and whether French authorities were aware of its landing. A lawyer representing LDH expressed surprise that the investigation only commenced in January 2006 without prior verification efforts.

On December 2, 2005, Le Figaro disclosed that two CIA-operated planes had landed in France under suspicion of prisoner transport activities. The inquiry concentrated on N50BH, a Gulfstream III, which arrived at Le Bourget from Oslo, Norway, on July 20, 2005. Another suspected aircraft touched down in Brest on March 31, 2002; Canadian officials are investigating this flight that originated from St. John's, Newfoundland and Labrador, with stops at Keflavík, Iceland before continuing to Turkey.

Investigations in Portugal

On February 5, 2007, the Portuguese general prosecutor Cândida Almeida from the Central Investigation and Penal Action Department (DCIAP) initiated a probe into allegations of "torture or inhuman and degrading treatment." This followed claims made by MEP Ana Gomes on January 26, 2007, regarding "illegal operations and severe human rights breaches."

Gomes openly criticized the Portuguese government for its hesitance to cooperate with the European Parliament Commission’s inquiry into CIA flights, which caused friction with Foreign Minister Luís Amado, a fellow party member. She claimed that unauthorized flights were common during the administrations of Durão Barroso (2002–2004) and Santana Lopes (2004–2005), and she documented 24 such flights occurring under the Socialist government led by José Sócrates. While supporting the investigation, she emphasized that a parliamentary inquiry remained essential.

Journalist Rui Costa Pinto from Visão provided testimony to the DCIAP after his article about flights via Lajes Field, a U.S. Air Force base in the Azores, was declined by the magazine. Subsequently, he published a book elaborating on his research.

Approximately 150 CIA flights have been identified as having crossed Portuguese airspace.

Investigations in Poland

In January 2012, Poland’s Prosecutor General commenced legal proceedings against former intelligence chief Zbigniew Siemiątkowski, accusing him of enabling a CIA detention operation on Polish soil that allegedly involved torture during the War on Terror. These purported breaches of constitutional and international law took place under Prime Minister Leszek Miller (2001–2004), who might also be subject to future proceedings before the State Tribunal.

The inquiry, ongoing since 2008, has encountered obstacles. After charges were brought against Siemiątkowski in Warsaw, responsibility for the case shifted to another prosecutorial team in Cracow. U.S. officials have declined to cooperate, and relevant documents from the Intelligence Agency were only disclosed following intervention by Poland’s Supreme Court First President.

Significantly, detainees such as Abu Zubaydah and Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri were reportedly held and subjected to physical abuse at the Stare Kiejkuty intelligence facility located in northeastern Poland.

Investigations across Europe

Both the European Union (EU) and the Council of Europe committed to examining these allegations. On November 25, 2005, Swiss parliamentarian Dick Marty, serving as lead investigator for the Council of Europe, secured coordinates of suspected secret detention sites and intended to utilize satellite imagery during his investigation. Shortly thereafter, on November 28, 2005, EU Justice Commissioner Franco Frattini cautioned that any EU member state found operating clandestine prisons risked suspension of its voting privileges.

On December 13, 2005, Marty presented findings indicating individuals had been abducted and transferred without adherence to legal procedures. Although no direct evidence confirmed the existence of secret CIA prisons within Europe, he asserted it was "highly unlikely" that European governments were unaware of rendition activities. His interim report—primarily based on media sources—drew criticism from several EU countries. The report concluded it was probable that European intelligence agencies had knowledge of approximately one hundred renditions conducted on European territory.

By April 21, 2006, The New York Times reported that European investigators had yet to uncover definitive proof of black sites located in Europe.

On June 27, 2007, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe adopted Resolution 1562 along with Recommendation 1801 endorsing Marty’s conclusions. The Assembly determined with strong likelihood that secret CIA detention facilities operated in Poland and Romania as part of its High Value Detainee (HVD) program.

Intercepted fax by Onyx

On January 8, 2006, the Swiss publication Sonntagsblick revealed a document obtained through Switzerland's Onyx interception system, which is comparable to the UKUSA's ECHELON network. The intercepted message, reportedly sent from the Egyptian embassy in London to Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit, indicated that 23 individuals from Iraq and Afghanistan underwent questioning at the Mihail Kogălniceanu base near Constanța, Romania. The document also mentioned analogous facilities located in Bulgaria, Kosovo, Macedonia, and Ukraine.

Subsequently, Egypt's Foreign Ministry explained that the fax was a summary of Romanian media coverage by the Egyptian Embassy in Bucharest, likely referring to remarks made by the controversial Senator Corneliu Vadim Tudor. Although the Swiss government did not officially verify the document's authenticity, it pursued legal measures against the newspaper for disclosing classified information.

Report of the European Parliament on February 14, 2007

On February 14, 2007, the European Parliament passed a resolution condemning numerous European nations for permitting unlawful CIA activities within their borders, including covert flights. The countries implicated were Austria, Belgium, Cyprus, Denmark, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Spain, Sweden, and the United Kingdom—although no definitive proof implicated the UK directly.

The resolution censured member states and intelligence agencies for insufficient cooperation during investigations and called for independent inquiries into CIA-operated flights used for unlawful detainee transfers. It advocated for shutting down Guantanamo Bay and urged repatriation of individuals held unlawfully by U.S. authorities. According to the Parliament's findings, the CIA had conducted 1,245 flights associated with extraordinary rendition operations posing risks of torture.

Prepared by Giovanni Fava of the Italian Socialist Party, the report suggested that EU governments might have been aware that intelligence obtained through these illegal renditions was shared with them. It also exposed secret detention centers within Europe, notably in Romania and Poland. Extraordinary renditions were defined as unauthorized abductions or transfers of terrorism suspects involving secret detention and torture. UK officials denied participation in detention or torture or hosting prisons; any possible use of UK territory for transit remains unconfirmed.

Obama administration

On January 22, 2009, President Barack Obama issued an executive order mandating that the CIA employ only the 19 interrogation techniques specified in the U.S. Army Field Manual unless further instructions are provided by the Attorney General. This order also required shutting down all CIA detention sites and prohibited establishing any new ones.

In March 2009, Bloomberg News reported that the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence had initiated a one-year investigation into the CIA’s detention program.

By April 2009, CIA Director Leon Panetta announced that the agency had ceased operating detention facilities or black sites and was in the process of closing remaining locations. He confirmed that external contractors were no longer authorized to conduct interrogations and that harsh methods previously used had been discontinued. Panetta stressed that only interrogation techniques approved by the Army Field Manual would be employed and detainees would be held briefly before transfer to their home countries or other U.S. agencies.

In 2011, it was revealed that under Obama's administration a Somali detainee was held aboard a U.S. naval vessel at sea for two months for interrogation purposes.

Analysis by the US Senate on the CIA's Detention and Interrogation Program

On December 9, 2014, the United States Senate Select Committee on Intelligence (SSCI) published a 525-page summary of its Committee Study of the Central Intelligence Agency's Detention and Interrogation Program. The comprehensive report, spanning approximately 6,000 pages, remains classified. The summary outlined 20 principal conclusions:

  1. The enhanced interrogation methods employed by the CIA failed to produce effective intelligence or encourage detainee cooperation.
  2. The rationale provided by the CIA for utilizing these methods was founded on overstated claims of their success.
  3. The interrogations involved severe brutality that exceeded what was disclosed to policymakers.
  4. Conditions in which detainees were held were more severe than officially reported.
  5. The CIA supplied misleading information to the United States Department of Justice, complicating legal review processes.
  6. Congressional supervision was deliberately circumvented or obstructed by the CIA.
  7. Oversight and decision-making efforts by the White House were hindered due to CIA actions.
  8. The program interfered with or complicated national security operations conducted by other Executive Branch entities.
  9. Oversight attempts by the CIA's Office of Inspector General faced significant obstacles.
  10. The CIA orchestrated classified disclosures to the media, including inaccurate assertions regarding interrogation efficacy.
  11. The program was implemented without adequate preparation, commencing over six months after detention authority was authorized.
  12. Persistent management and operational deficiencies were evident throughout, particularly during 2002–2003.
  13. Two contracted psychologists developed the techniques and exerted considerable influence over program execution; by 2005, most activities were outsourced to contractors.
  14. Certain coercive methods lacked formal approval from the Department of Justice or authorization from CIA Headquarters.
  15. The CIA failed to maintain accurate detainee records and held individuals not meeting legal detention criteria; data on detainee numbers and use of techniques were misrepresented.
  16. Assessments evaluating the effectiveness of interrogation methods were insufficient.
  17. Accountability for personnel involved in violations and managerial failures was infrequently enforced.
  18. Internal criticisms and objections were marginalized or disregarded entirely.
  19. By 2006, due to media exposure, diminished international collaboration, and legal challenges, the program became unsustainable.
  20. The initiative adversely affected the United States’ international reputation and resulted in considerable financial and non-financial costs.

The investigation determined that at least 26 out of 119 detainees (approximately 22%) were held improperly, with many subjected to torture. Enhanced interrogation techniques were applied to a minimum of 39 detainees; in at least six instances, torture occurred before any assessment of detainee willingness to cooperate.

Judgments by the European Court of Human Rights

On July 24, 2014, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Poland breached the European Convention on Human Rights by collaborating with the US government to facilitate CIA detention and torture of Abu Zubaydah and Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri within Polish territory during 2002–2003. Poland was mandated to compensate each individual with 100,000 euros in damages; Abu Zubaydah received an additional 30,000 euros for incurred costs.

Subsequently, on May 31, 2018, the ECHR determined that Lithuania and Romania similarly violated the rights of Abu Zubaydah and Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri during periods spanning 2003–2005 and 2005–2006 respectively. Both nations were ordered to pay each detainee damages amounting to 100,000 euros.

See also


External links

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Bbc070214
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named auto
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named :1
  4. ↑ Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named bbc key
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named :2
  6. ↑ ...
  7. ↑ ...
  8. ↑ ...